The Binding of Isaac
A roguelike shooter where item effects are left unexplained to create mystery.
Where The Binding of Isaac comes up1 episode or test
The Binding of Isaac hid item effects to recreate the mystery of the original Legend of Zelda, but wikis explained every item in about five seconds. McMillen calls the missing descriptions its biggest flaw and in 2023 considered an optional version, while a mod that adds them has almost 2 million Steam subscribers. Lesson: a design choice fails if players can route around it, so close the loophole or support it.
- 1Hide item effectsZelda-style mystery, no descriptions
- 2Wikis list every itemMystery lasted about five seconds
- 3Players build description modAlmost 2 million subscribers
- 4McMillen weighs official textConsidered optional descriptions in 2023
From Edmund McMillen on Isaac's design
What was said about The Binding of Isaac
Isaac hid item effects for mystery, but wikis undid it within seconds. Edmund McMillen left Binding of Isaac items unexplained to recreate the mystery he felt playing the original Legend of Zelda, where players experimented and compared notes with friends. It worked for about five seconds, until wikis listed every item. McMillen now calls the missing descriptions the game's biggest flaw.
Isaac is now played largely with a browser open. McMillen said: "I hated that that's how everyone played for so long... and still play." The lesson is that a bold design choice fails if players can route around it, so don't hide effects a wiki can reveal.
Players built the missing item descriptions themselves, and McMillen considered making them official. The External Item Descriptions mod is the most popular add-on on Isaac's Steam workshop, with almost 2 million subscribers. In 2023 McMillen considered adding optional item descriptions, since backing a workaround players will use anyway beats leaving them with a worse game.
Opening the game to mods let players add the feature without official endorsement. The source suggests that for console players who can't mod, a cheat code would make people seek the option out rather than stumble on it in a menu.
Balatro's 'Cursed' Design Problem
Hid item effects to recreate the mystery of the original Legend of Zelda, but wikis explained every item in about five seconds. McMillen calls the missing descriptions its biggest flaw and in 2023 considered an optional version, while the External Item Descriptions mod has almost 2 million Steam workshop subscribers.
Isaac hid item effects for mystery, but wikis undid it within seconds. Edmund McMillen left Binding of Isaac items unexplained to recreate the mystery he felt playing the original Legend of Zelda, where players experimented and compared notes with friends. It worked for about five seconds, until wikis listed every item. McMillen now calls the missing descriptions the game's biggest flaw.
Isaac is now played largely with a browser open. McMillen said: "I hated that that's how everyone played for so long... and still play." The lesson is that a bold design choice fails if players can route around it, so don't hide effects a wiki can reveal.
Players built the missing item descriptions themselves, and McMillen considered making them official. The External Item Descriptions mod is the most popular add-on on Isaac's Steam workshop, with almost 2 million subscribers. In 2023 McMillen considered adding optional item descriptions, since backing a workaround players will use anyway beats leaving them with a worse game.
Opening the game to mods let players add the feature without official endorsement. The source suggests that for console players who can't mod, a cheat code would make people seek the option out rather than stumble on it in a menu.
More in Games
GamesNintendo
A Zelda adventure where Princess Zelda copies objects and monsters as echoes to solve puzzles and fight.
GamesThe Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
Nintendo's long-running action-adventure series about Link exploring Hyrule, solving puzzles and fighting Ganon.
GamesDead Space
A major video game publisher and the guest's employer.
G
29 sources · 94 tipsMind Over Magnet
A puzzle platformer where you escape a factory using a magnet and a magnetic field.
GamesFar Cry 2
An open world action game where you recruit and play any of London's citizens.
GamesGod of War
A combat-focused action adventure game from Santa Monica Studio with Norse mythology and light puzzles.
Mind Over Magnet
Mark Brown's first game, a puzzle game he made while learning Unity.
GamesDishonored
A first-person stealth action game from Arkane with supernatural powers and the Clockwork Mansion level.