Chapter 27 of 29 · How a field works and shifts
1 The bottom line
Commit your team to a good-enough shared model, and work only on problems that model guarantees can be solved. A shared framework turns scattered effort into steady progress, because everyone knows which facts matter and what counts as an answer.
2 Key takeaways
- Commit to a good-enough shared model. It only has to beat its rivals, and it stops each person from rebuilding the field alone.
- Franklin's theory covered nearly all electrical effects and became the common paradigm. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Work on puzzles, not on every important problem. A puzzle has an assured solution and rules for acceptable answers, and importance gives neither.
- Curing cancer and securing lasting peace are urgent, yet they may have no solution. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Keep the rules when a problem is hard. Changing the rules sets a new problem and leaves the old one unsolved.
- Scientists kept the rules until, in 1750, one of them found how to apply them successfully. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Teach newcomers with worked problems, not principles. A general law is nearly useless until problems show how to apply it.
- Galileo's incline, Huyghens' physical pendulum and Daniel Bernoulli's efflux problem all use one vis viva law. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Push the model past its proven range. A model kept to known facts is safe, but it can never lead to discovery.
- Phlogiston theory, limited to the facts it already explained, could never have been challenged. Thomas S. Kuhn
Truth emerges more readily from error than from confusion.
Thomas S. Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
2.1 Commit to a good-enough shared model
A shared model that beats its rivals is enough to start, and it does not need to explain everything.
- Pick the best available model and make it the team's common one. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Without a shared model every fact seems equally relevant, and each person rebuilds the field from scratch.
- The model only needs to beat its competitors, not explain everything.
- Early eighteenth-century electricity had nearly as many views as major experimenters.
- Treat what the model cannot explain as problems to solve. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Keep a visible list of the model's leftovers and assign them as work.
- Franklin's theory still could not explain every case of repulsion.
2.2 Pick problems the model guarantees can be solved
| Attribute | Puzzle | Important problem |
|---|---|---|
| Assured solution | Yes, the framework guarantees one | Not guaranteed, may have none |
| Rules for acceptable answers | Clear | Often missing |
| Example | Franklin's unexplained repulsion cases | Curing cancer, lasting peace |
| How to plan | Assign as normal work | Staff and schedule separately |
Put your effort on problems with assured solutions, and plan open-ended ones separately.
- Test every problem for a guaranteed solution and rules for acceptable answers before you assign it. Thomas S. Kuhn
- A puzzle is defined by those two things, not by how important it is.
- Fast progress comes from working only on problems the framework guarantees can be solved.
- "Though intrinsic value is no criterion for a puzzle, the assured existence of a solution is."
- Staff and schedule open-ended problems differently, and audit what your framework leaves out. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Go through your list of important problems and mark the ones your framework silently excludes.
- Such problems may have no solution, which is why they need a different plan.
2.3 Hold the rules when the work gets hard
A hard problem is a reason to look for a new route, not to rewrite your core assumptions.
- Keep the rules and push for a new route to the expected result. Thomas S. Kuhn
- That push is what makes hard work productive.
- The expected result stays fixed. Only the route to it changes.
- Treat any proposal to change a core assumption as a new problem, not an answer. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Ask whether the change solves the old problem or only sets a new one.
- Through the eighteenth century some proposed swapping the inverse square law to explain the moon's motion.
2.4 Train newcomers on worked problems
People learn the model by solving concrete problems, not by reading its principles.
- Build your training from solved examples that newcomers work through themselves. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Working knowledge lives in concrete solved examples.
- Choose examples that look different on the surface but rest on the same law, so people learn to see a new situation as like an old one.
- Students often understand a chapter and still fail its problems until they spot the resemblance to one already solved.
- Never hand over the general law alone. Thomas S. Kuhn
- A law is nearly useless until problems show how to apply it.
- The verbal vis viva law alone gave little guidance without the problems.
2.5 Stretch the model and spread the risk
Push the model past what it has proven, and let people weigh shared values differently so a few bet on anomalies.
- Apply the model to cases beyond what it has already explained. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Restricting a model to what is already observed makes it safe and stops all discovery.
- Pushing it further creates puzzles, surprises and the anomalies that point to deeper change.
- "Is it really any wonder that the price of significant scientific advance is a commitment that runs the risk of being wrong?"
- Let members weigh shared values differently. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Values like consistency and simplicity are widely shared but weighed differently by individuals.
- Let a few people bet on anomalies and new ideas while most keep doing productive normal work.
- Einstein saw an inconsistency in the old quantum theory as intolerable, while Bohr and others saw it as a difficulty normal work would resolve.
2.6 Where the books differ
Every tip in this lesson comes from Kuhn, so the tension sits inside one account: keep the rules, yet bet against them.
- Split the team: most keep the rules, a few chase anomalies. Thomas S. Kuhn
- Tell the majority to hold the core assumptions and look for new routes to expected results.
- Let a small group treat anomalies as serious, since people weigh shared values differently anyway.
- Betting on a model beyond its proven range may prove you wrong. That risk is the cost of progress.
Sources
Part of How a field works and shifts in the growth library.