Chapter 29 of 29 · Discovering together in a small group
1 The bottom line
A result spreads when you find who gains from it, prove it in one public showcase, and back the version with funding and protection. Quality alone does not win, because buyers adopt what they can see, trust and afford.
2 Key takeaways
- Map every party that gains, and recruit them before rivals do. Allies carry your figures and your cause further than you can alone.
- Garbett calculated that Baltic merchants could save up to fifteen shillings a ton, a figure Wedgwood's canal allies could repeat.
- Sell first where a shock leaves your saving as the only option. Small fixes to the old product lose once buyers have nowhere else to cut.
- Even after Smeaton doubled Newcomen efficiency by 1775, over forty engines often stood idle.
- Make the first win a public showcase, even if it earns little. Visible proof builds the credibility that later sales borrow.
- The Frog Service had 1,244 hand-painted views that pushed its cost over £2,500, just under Catherine's price, yet it drew the nobility and the Queen.
- Back the version with funding, protection and demos, not the best copy. The better-made product lost to the better-backed one.
- With Boulton's patent and demonstrations behind it, Watt's chemical press sold 150 by the end of the year.
- Price on value the buyer can see and understand. A clear unit and an open measure remove the buyer's doubt.
- Whitbread's engine, rated at ten horses, did the work of 14.
to disappoint them with the manly Simplicity of Truth
Josiah Wedgwood, Wedgwood
2.1 Map who gains and check the field
Before you push a result, list everyone it helps and confirm nobody already holds the ground.
- List every party that gains from your result and recruit them before rivals do. See Wedgwood.
- recruited Birmingham manufacturers, salt makers and Liverpool merchants to his canal cause.
- Hand each ally concrete savings figures.
- Win a powerful patron who will back you in public.
- Freight to the Potteries later fell from 10d to 1½d a mile.
- He argued that plain facts persuade suspicious readers better than flourish, and would not let wording delay printing.
- Check for a working rival and a committed buyer before you invest years. See Edgeworth.
- Ask whether anyone already runs a working version.
- Ask whether a named buyer is ready to adopt yours.
- designed a numerical telegraph and lobbied the Irish Government and the Admiralty for a decade.
- Chappe in France put up sixteen stations between Paris and Lille in 1791, and Edgeworth kept pushing until 1804 with no adoption.
2.2 Start where the old way has run out
Sell first where a shock makes your saving the only option, and where buyers are receptive.
- Look for the segment where a price shock has closed every other route to saving. See Boulton and Watt.
- Find the cost buyers cannot cut further. Cornish mines could not cut labour costs, and coal had to be shipped from South Wales.
- When copper prices fell, fuel became the only place left to save.
- From 1768 the easily worked Parys mine collapsed copper prices.
- Gradual fixes to the old engines were not enough, which opened the door to a step change.
- Start with the receptive segment, then use those wins on the hostile one. See Watt.
- For the Cornish engine, the receptive segment was the eastern mines.
- Carry those results to the hostile segment as proof.
2.3 Make the first win public
A visible first install, or a prestige commission, builds credibility that later sales can use.
- Put the first install where the district can watch it, and make it feel powerful. See Watt at Wheal Busy.
- Many locals were sure the first Cornish engine would never pump water, so it became a show the district came to watch.
- By September 1777 it was running and impressed spectators.
- Watt tuned it to run quietly, but left it noisy when told the noise impressed people.
- The advice he got was that "the noise serves to convey great ideas of ye power to ye ignorant".
- Win a hard prestige commission, then use the endorsement everywhere. See Wedgwood.
- Wedgwood took a costly gilded tea-set order for Queen Charlotte that no one else would touch.
- It earned him the title Potter to Her Majesty and renamed his creamware Queen's Ware.
- The King then ordered a 'Royal Pattern' service, and two years later demand was still rising.
- Judge a showpiece by its reach, not its margin. See Catherine the Great's Frog Service.
- The service took over a year and earned little.
- Displayed in London, it drew the nobility and the Queen and was the talk of the town for weeks.
- Wedgwood concluded that winning patrons deserved as much effort and money as design.
2.4 Back the version most likely to spread
| Watt's copying press | Darwin's bigrapher | |
|---|---|---|
| Copy quality | Mirror image on tissue | Clearer, on ordinary paper |
| Backing | Boulton's patent, Keir ran it | None |
| Demonstrations | MPs and Royal Society | No marketing |
| Ease of use | Simple to buy | Complex reassembly instructions |
| Outcome | Won | Lost |
Choose the version with money, legal protection and live demonstrations behind it, and keep it simple to buy.
- Back the version with funding, protection and demos, not the best copy. See Boulton, Watt and Keir.
- Boulton patented Watt's chemical press and demonstrated it to MPs and the Royal Society.
- Keir ran the business.
- Darwin's bigrapher made clearer copies on ordinary paper, but shipped with complex reassembly instructions and no marketing.
- Watt's press gave mirror images on tissue, and still won.
- Offer a small standard range, not fully custom builds. See Boulton.
- Complexity scared buyers, so Boulton sold a few standard sizes.
- Arkwright avoided their engines as complex and prone to disorder.
2.5 Price on value the buyer can see
Tie your price to a saving the buyer can measure, and invent a unit when the old one disappears.
- Charge a share of the value you deliver over the old product, and measure it openly. See Boulton and Watt.
- They charged a third of the yearly coal saved compared with a Newcomen engine of the same size.
- A counter on the engine recorded the saving.
- When the variable formula caused friction, Boulton swapped it for fixed sums and deferred full payment until engines ran at full load.
- Poldice paid £1,500 for two engines and Consolidated Mines £2,500 for five.
- Boulton judged that looking generous was worth more than squeezing every bargain, and said a hard bargain was a bad bargain.
- When the old pricing basis vanishes, invent a unit buyers understand. See Watt.
- Engines replacing horses in breweries saved no coal, so the coal royalty did not apply.
- Watt measured a horse's work and rated engines as horses.
- A horse raised 33,000 lbs one foot per minute.
- Showcases in London breweries and a corn mill then sold power to everyone.
2.6 Move to the bigger market
Once the first market proves the result, aim at the far larger one even when each unit earns less.
- Move to the far larger market even when margins per unit fall. See Boulton.
- Pumping engines served a finite market. Boulton saw that rotary engines could drive mills and factories.
- Be ready to carry losses on the bet. Boulton carried years of them.
- Watt feared the premiums would be tiny.
- The firm first showed a profit at the end of 1783.
- Launch high to build status, then sell cheaper to the middle. See Wedgwood.
- Display in palaces had fixed the goods' status.
- The much larger middling class then bought them at reduced prices, and it did.
- By 1772 the ormolu and vase vogues had peaked and Boulton held cartloads of unsold stock.
2.7 Where the books differ
Some tactics fit only some products or stages, so match them to what your buyer values.
- Chase prestige only when the product can survive it. See Wedgwood and Boulton.
- Wedgwood put as much effort into winning patrons as into design, but only after the product was already cheap and durable.
- Boulton's scientific clocks were praised, but did not strike the hours or play any tune, and would not sell.
- Do not mistake persistence for evidence. See Boulton and Edgeworth.
- Both men kept going through years without reward.
- Boulton had a far larger market in view, while Edgeworth had a working rival and no official buyer.
- Watt's worry was a small premium per unit. Edgeworth's problem was no buyer at all.
Sources
Part of Discovering together in a small group in the growth library.