Chapter 28 of 29 · Organising a place for discovery
1 The bottom line
Put theorists, experimenters and outsiders where they keep meeting, and manage them as a guide, not a rival. Mixed disciplines improve each other's work only if the space, the hiring and the boss all make meeting easy.
2 Key takeaways
- Design the building so different disciplines must cross paths. Meetings happen when the layout forces them.
- More than eighty industrial labs visited Murray Hill to copy its design
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- More than eighty industrial labs visited Murray Hill to copy its design
- Combine skills and temperaments on purpose, and pay to fill a missing skill. A team without a key capability stalls, however good the rest is.
- Kelly offered Bardeen a salary well above any university's
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- Kelly offered Bardeen a salary well above any university's
- Bring in people from adjacent fields to reframe stubborn data. Outsiders ask questions that insiders no longer think to ask.
- Dalton saw combining proportions that chemists had missed Thomas S. Kuhn.
- Value and protect the colleague who asks good questions. Their effect on others can exceed their own output.
- Top Bell Labs patent holders often ate lunch or breakfast with Harry Nyquist
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- Top Bell Labs patent holders often ate lunch or breakfast with Harry Nyquist
- As a manager, guide your reports and never compete with them. A star who races his team for credit can destroy it.
- Shockley secretly designed the junction transistor and sprang it on his team
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- Shockley secretly designed the junction transistor and sprang it on his team
Men are a kind of material, too.
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs
2.1 Build a space that forces collisions
People from different fields only improve each other's work if the building makes them meet.
- Separate people's labs from their offices so they must walk between them
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- Route that walking through long shared corridors on the way to common spaces.
- Murray Hill connected all wings and used a 700-foot corridor.
- Build with modular walls so teams can resize quickly
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- Fit every module with full utilities, so changing a team's size does not mean rebuilding.
- Murray Hill used six-foot modules with full utilities.
2.2 Combine people, and pay for the missing skill
Treat people as a material to be combined, and spend what it takes on the skill you lack.
- Mix theorists with experimentalists, across skills and temperaments
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- Put the theorist in the experimenter's lab, so the two work side by side.
- Bardeen landed in Brattain's lab, which started the theorist and experimentalist partnership.
- When the team lacks a key skill, find the few people who have it and pay what it takes
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- Name the gap first, then count how many people could fill it.
- Shockley and Fisk judged that only about three people in the country could fill the theory gap.
2.3 Bring in outsiders to reframe old data
Someone trained in a neighboring field can make stubborn data answer new questions.
- Bring in people from adjacent fields when your data will not yield Thomas S. Kuhn.
- Look for people whose training gives them different questions and concepts.
- Dalton was a meteorologist studying gas absorption.
- Watch neighboring specialties for tools and results Thomas S. Kuhn.
- Absorbing what they find can also trigger change in your own field.
- Dalton imported questions from physics and meteorology into chemistry.
2.4 Protect the people who ask good questions
Some colleagues lift everyone around them by drawing people out, not by handing over answers.
- Value the colleague who asks good questions over the one with the most raw output
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- Seek these people out and protect them, because their effect can exceed their own output.
- A patent lawyer's study found that eating with Nyquist was the only common thread among the top patent holders.
2.5 Manage as a guide, not a competitor
A manager who races his people for credit can lose the whole team.
- Guide your reports and never compete with them
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- A star who races subordinates may produce a better design but still destroy the team.
- Bardeen left for Illinois, and Brattain asked to stop reporting to Shockley.
- Promote on management fit, not brilliance alone
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- Ask whether the person can draw out a team before asking how brilliant they are.
- Later, Shockley's staff left after he asked them all to take polygraph tests.
2.6 Where the books differ
| Outsider | Paid specialist | |
|---|---|---|
| Use when | Old data won't yield | You can name the exact gap |
| Brings | New questions and concepts | A scarce key skill |
| Example | Dalton, a meteorologist, in chemistry | Bardeen, hired at a top salary |
| Watch for | Ideas from neighboring fields | A star competing with the team |
Outsiders and scarce specialists solve different problems, and a star's talent needs managing.
- Use an outsider when old data will not answer, and a paid specialist when you know the exact gap.
- Kuhn's case is a newcomer who reframes the questions Thomas S. Kuhn.
- The Bell Labs case is a known missing skill, so the lab went and bought it
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- Hire stars for the gap, but do not let them compete with the team.
- Paying for rare talent worked for Bardeen's hire, yet a star manager's secret design cost the lab its people
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs.
- Paying for rare talent worked for Bardeen's hire, yet a star manager's secret design cost the lab its people
Sources
- The Idea Factory: Bell Labs and the Great Age of American Innovation · Books
- The Structure of Scientific Revolutions: 50th Anniversary Edition · Books
Part of Organising a place for discovery in the growth library.