Chapter 27 of 29 · How a field works and shifts
1 The bottom line
Win agreement by tying the new approach to a failure everyone admits, then show better numbers and surprising results through early champions. Proof alone never settles the contest, so build support gradually and translate between camps.
2 Key takeaways
- Tie the pitch to a failure everyone already admits. Correct ideas get ignored when they touch no known trouble spot.
- Thomas S. Kuhn notes that Aristarchus anticipated heliocentrism in the third century B.C. and was ignored.
- Seventeenth-century combustion theories from Rey, Hooke and Mayow met the same fate because no crisis existed yet Kuhn.
- Lead with better numbers and with results the old approach never predicted. Precision on the crisis problem, and surprise, persuade more than argument.
- Equip a few early champions who are new or deep in the failing problem. Their development work produces the arguments that convert the majority.
- Darwin pinned his hopes on young and rising naturalists Kuhn.
- Translate across camps instead of arguing for proof. Rival groups use the same words for differently grouped things and talk past each other.
- Proust and Berthollet argued inconclusively because Berthollet saw a variable compound where Proust saw a mixture Kuhn.
- Expect adoption to build over years, not from one demo. Rivals disagree about problems, standards and meanings, so proof cannot settle it.
The competition between paradigms is not the sort of battle that can be resolved by proofs.
Thomas S. Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
2.1 Anchor the pitch in a known failure
A new approach gets a hearing only when it speaks to a problem people already admit is broken.
- Frame the proposal around the problem the incumbent cannot solve. Kuhn
- Name the failure the field already admits, then show your approach as the answer to it.
- Treat a crisis as the signal that the moment has come. In Kuhn's words: "The significance of crises is the indication they provide that an occasion for retooling has arrived."
- Aristarchus anticipated heliocentrism in the third century B.C. and was ignored, since nothing was yet failing.
- Keep a file of rejected ideas and revive them when the incumbent enters crisis. Kuhn
- An idea that fails today may be the right one once a trouble spot opens.
- Combustion theories from Rey, Hooke and Mayow in the seventeenth century were ignored because no crisis existed yet.
2.2 Build the evidence that persuades
Show clearly better results on the old approach's pain points, plus consequences nobody saw coming.
- Lead with quantitative results on the problems that put the incumbent in crisis. Kuhn
- This is the most common and effective argument. Strikingly better precision persuades even when the new approach raises fresh problems.
- If the crisis problem is not yet solved, draw evidence from other areas.
- Kepler's Rudolphine tables beat any Ptolemaic computation and helped convert astronomers.
- Newton's quantitative predictions probably beat more reasonable but qualitative rivals.
- Hunt for consequences your approach implies but you did not design in, then demonstrate them. Kuhn
- Results that were clearly not built in persuade more than ones that were.
- Long-known anomalies that you explain unexpectedly carry the same surprise value.
- Poisson, an opponent, showed that Fresnel's wave theory implied a white spot at the center of a disk's shadow. When Fresnel demonstrated it, French resistance collapsed suddenly and fairly completely.
- Aim your approach at a surprising, concrete artifact and explain it better than rivals do. Kuhn
- An artifact gives everyone something to explain. The school that explains it best gains a strong argument for becoming the shared standard.
- Electricians who saw electricity as a fluid tried to bottle it and produced the Leyden jar in the early 1740's. Franklin's success at explaining it was the strongest argument for his theory.
2.3 Recruit the right early supporters
New ways of seeing start with people who are focused on the crisis and lightly committed to the old rules.
- Recruit newcomers and people deep in the failing problem first. Kuhn
- These people have the least invested in the old rules and the most attention on the crisis.
- Darwin pinned his hopes on young and rising naturalists.
- Equip a few early champions and let them do the development work. Kuhn
- Their experiments, tools and arguments are what convert the majority later.
- Accept that early supporters act on faith. Kuhn writes: "A decision of that kind can only be made on faith."
- Do not count on converting experienced practitioners. Kuhn
- Their loyalty to the old approach is not irrational, so do not treat it as a flaw to argue away.
- Priestley never accepted oxygen and Kelvin never accepted electromagnetic theory. Planck said new truths win because opponents eventually die.
2.4 Bridge the camps that are stuck
When two groups talk past each other, translate first and prove second.
- Find the terms that cause trouble only between the groups, and clarify them in shared everyday language. Kuhn
- Rival groups use the same words for differently grouped things, so the same sentence means different things to each.
- Proust and Berthollet argued inconclusively over fixed proportions. Where Berthollet saw a variable compound, Proust saw a mixture.
- Learn to predict what the other side would say, and never explain their view as error or madness. Kuhn
- Do not wait for a neutral rule to settle the matter. Kuhn writes: "There is no neutral algorithm for theory-choice, no systematic decision procedure."
2.5 Plan for slow, cumulative adoption
Allegiance shifts as supporters build things, and the decisive demonstration usually comes afterward.
- Budget for years of building, not a single winning demo. Kuhn
- Rivals disagree about problems, standards and meanings, so proof cannot settle the contest.
- Keep supporters producing experiments, tools, articles and books. Allegiance moves with that output.
- Copernicanism won few converts for almost a century after Copernicus died. Newton's work was not generally accepted on the Continent for over half a century.
- Save the crucial demonstration for the textbook, not for the argument. Kuhn
- Crucial demonstrations usually arrive after the shift and serve the later textbooks.
- The Foucault pendulum and the Fizeau experiment came long after acceptance.
2.6 Where the books differ
| Fresnel's wave theory | Copernicanism | Newton on the Continent | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What persuaded | Poisson's white spot shown | Kepler's better tables | Quantitative predictions |
| Speed of shift | Sudden | Almost a century | Over half a century |
| Settled by one result? | Yes | No | No |
Kuhn's own cases disagree on whether one result can turn a field quickly.
- A single striking prediction sometimes works, but do not rely on it. Kuhn
- Use a surprising prediction as one tool among several, alongside better numbers and early champions.
- Fresnel's white spot ended French resistance suddenly. Yet Copernicanism took almost a century and Newton over half a century on the Continent.
Sources
Part of How a field works and shifts in the growth library.