Chapter 28 of 29 · Organising a place for discovery
1 The bottom line
Give people protected time for self-chosen work, fund foundational bets apart from incremental work, and anchor the whole group to a need someone depends on. Without a real need behind it, even a great lab declines slowly and unnoticed.
2 Key takeaways
- Make slack time for self-chosen work an explicit norm. Side work keeps promising plans alive until the timing is right.
Joel Engel, Bell Labs believed advancement required spending 20 or 30 percent of your time beyond your assignment, and he used it to plan cellular.
- Back staff side projects that leaders are tempted to discourage. Leaders misjudge ideas that do not fit the current business.
- Boulton and Watt discouraged Murdoch's gas lighting, and within years London streets and many mills were gas lit.
- Fund steady work and risky bets separately. Incentives and competition mostly produce incremental gains.
- Josiah Wedgwood ran useful ware and ornamental ware as separate partnerships with their own workshops, ovens, sales and accounts.
Mervin Kelly, Bell Labs spent decades improving the vacuum tube, then backed the transistor that made that work irrelevant.
- Tie the group to a concrete need someone depends on. Buildings, equipment and people do not sustain research on their own.
Bell Labs was about a third of its former size by 2005, and Holmdel closed in 2006.
- When a leader blocks your idea, wait and return with a budget and a competitive argument. Escalating at once can backfire.
- A January 6, 1959 proposal asking $1 million was approved as
Project Echo at Bell Labs after Kelly had retired.
- A January 6, 1959 proposal asking $1 million was approved as
The mission was absolutely essential to the research done at the old Laboratories, and that mission is gone and has not been replaced.
Jon Gertner, Bell Labs
2.1 Give people room for self-chosen work
Slack time keeps good ideas alive until the moment fits, and leaders have to make it normal and protect it.
- Say out loud that people may spend part of their time beyond their assignment.
- Make the norm explicit so people actually use it, as
Bell Labs culture did informally. - Name a share of time. Google lets workers spend up to 20 percent on projects of their choosing
Jon Gertner.
Joel Engel used his 20 or 30 percent to plan cellular before its time came.
- Make the norm explicit so people actually use it, as
- Back staff side projects you are tempted to discourage.
- Treat your own urge to discourage as a warning sign, and look at a demonstration before you say no.
- Boulton and Watt discouraged Murdoch's gas lighting and talked him out of a patent. They backed it only after Gregory Watt saw a demonstration in Paris.
- For the Peace of Amiens, 1802 to 1803, all of Soho blazed with gaslight Jenny Uglow.
2.2 Separate steady work from foundational bets
| Useful ware | Ornamental ware | |
|---|---|---|
| Partnership | Separate | Separate |
| Workshops & ovens | Its own | Its own |
| Sales | Its own | Its own |
| Accounts | Own books | Own books |
| Demand | Steady | Riskier artistic trade |
Keep the core line and the risky lines apart, so neither starves or hides the other.
- Run the steady core apart from experimental lines, with their own books.
- Fund foundational bets with patient money, technically competent leaders and freedom to stop failed lines.
- Do not expect incentives to deliver platforms. In the words of
Jon Gertner, "Incentives are fine, but they produce incremental improvements in what's there." - Let people end a failed line without career damage.
Kelly spent decades improving the vacuum tube, then backed the transistor that made that work irrelevant.
- Do not expect incentives to deliver platforms. In the words of
2.3 Tie the group to a need someone depends on
Freedom lasts only while someone urgently needs what the group produces.
- Name who depends on your output, and keep that link alive.
- Do not assume buildings, equipment and people will sustain research alone.
Great labs rise because someone urgently needs what they produce.
- Do not assume buildings, equipment and people will sustain research alone.
- If the mission goes, replace it early, because decline is slow and hard to spot.
2.4 Handle a leader's "no"
A blocked idea is often only delayed, if you pick the moment and the argument.
- Hold your rebuttal, then return later with a clear budget.
- Argue that someone else will act if you do not.
- Do not escalate immediately, because it can backfire.
Kelly called the satellite a nonstarter in summer 1958, and a rebuttal was never sent.- After he retired, a January 6, 1959 proposal asking $1 million was approved as Project Echo
Gertner. His summary: "Even great men can be wrong."
2.5 Where the books differ
The right move depends on whether you are the leader or the proposer, and on how much protection you already have.
- Leaders should back the project at once, while proposers should often wait.
- Protection for foundational work may need to be built by design.
Sources
- The Idea Factory: Bell Labs and the Great Age of American Innovation · Books
- The Lunar Men: The Inventors of the Modern World, 1730–1810 · Books
Part of Organising a place for discovery in the growth library.