
Novelist and memoirist, author of Big Magic
Elizabeth Gilbert is a novelist and memoirist, author of Big Magic and Eat, Pray, Love, with about 40 years of writing behind her. The thing most worth learning from her is that writing is mostly discipline: short timed sessions, seasons of preparation and real rest, with inspiration as a rare bonus.
you don't gauge it by how much you did, you gauge it by how long you sat
This Is What 40 Years of Writing Discipline Looks Like (Elizabeth Gilbert Interview)
Gilbert vowed her life to writing at 15 or 16. She held what she calls a witchy little teenage girl ceremony. The vow meant writing whether or not she was good or successful at it.
Writing gave her the first sense of divinity, something mysterious and like a gift. She took little else seriously in her youth, but she took this seriously.
She learned the craft by copying other writers by hand. She filled notebooks with passages from novels she loved, some four or five pages long. She read everything within reach, then the whole NYU English reading list.
She skipped an English major to study what she couldn't learn from books. She wanted to eat the writing and asked herself how the authors did it.
She chose bartending over an MFA and called it graduate school. In 1990s New York she had a $900 apartment, and about four bar shifts a week paid for her life. At the Coyote Ugly Saloon she saw hundreds of people a week.
She felt she knew nothing to write about, so she went looking for humanity. She also didn't want to find her voice in a room of young people still finding theirs. She says to take an MFA only if someone else pays, never with debt.
She turned to Dickens to learn the novel when an agent asked for one. She only knew how to write stories of 10 or 15 pages. The agent said story collections are hard to sell, but a novel proposal could bring a two-book deal.
She calls Dickens the greatest novelist and the greatest character writer.
Six weeks after her partner died, she wrote a light book. She began City of Girls then and made it the most upbeat, champagne happy book of her life, because she needed to get off the grief.
Seven years later she could write about the loss openly. Her rule is to choose what you write to match what you can carry.
Gilbert says writing is mostly labor, with inspiration as a rare gift. She says the state where writing comes through her is a tiny share of 40 years at the desk, and chasing it doesn't work. She can create the labor but can't make the second thing happen.
She says The Signature of All Things is better than she can write, and she barely remembers drafting it after almost four years of preparation.
She writes by a 45-minute timer, not by word count. The only rules are that you can't stand up and you can't get on the internet. Ending with three sentences is a good day.
Her measure is time in the chair: "you don't gauge it by how much you did, you gauge it by how long you sat."
She stops when the timer rings, even in flow. Gilbert says that after four or five hours you feel you've paid your dues, skip the next day, and the habit breaks. Overlong binges can turn into four months of not writing.
Leaving while you still want more gives you excitement to return to tomorrow.
She tells writers to keep the day job and write one hour a day. Quitting to write a book leaves too much time. She says to set the alarm an hour earlier, write, then go to work.
She says the brain handles only about an hour in the furnace of creativity before weariness hits.
Gilbert writes in seasons, not every day. She spends a season on research and preparation, which she calls 90% of the work. Then she clears three or four months, set months ahead, and tells everyone not to expect her.
During drafting she keeps farmer's hours and rises at 4:30. Her farm childhood shaped the model.
She lies on the floor between bursts of intense drafting. After about an hour she gets up and does nothing, treating rest as part of the work. Near the end of a book she gets "barn fever," a burst of energy over the last 50 to 100 pages.
She has finished days afraid she had broken her brain.
When burned out, she stopped writing completely for six months. Her first sabbatical had no writing and no flights. She walked her dog, healed an injury, organized her house and saw friends.
She compares creative ground to a field that is ruined if overworked. She refused to write again until it felt fun, and now sees little sprigs of green in her imagination.
Gilbert picks the time and place first, then people, then plot. For City of Girls she started with New York City in the 1940s. Next came who is in that world, and last what they are doing, which she finds the hardest part.
She likens setting to a key in music. Plot begins to arrive as she researches the setting and builds characters.
She reads casual letters to learn how people really spoke. For 1940s New York she spent a year or two on period novels by forgotten authors, old New Yorker pieces and letters. She read John O'Hara and Talk of the Town columns.
With several mail deliveries a day, people wrote chatty, quick letters, much like email.
She keeps research on index cards in shoe boxes. She learned the method in a high school class in 1983. Each card holds one fact, with a code naming the book and page, plus cards per character and topic.
Cards can be shuffled, and she can reach in and pull a whole box on one character. After leaving a box on a train, about two years of work, she photocopies both boxes every few weeks.
She goes to the place and hunts for strange local sources. For a story set in 1880 Mississippi, she says to visit the smallest town's historical society, start with out of print oddities and talk to old people. Give it a year, not a week.
In Tahiti she learned the beach where Captain Cook landed had black sand, a detail no book she read had mentioned.
She has natives of a setting hunt for errors she calls omelets. For Snow Forest she gave the manuscript to Russian writers and geologists. An omelet is an error like Americans eating omelets at a baseball game instead of hot dogs.
She does this after the vulnerable first draft stage. She would rather be embarrassed in front of them than in the New York Times.
She wrote a 70-page synopsis for a 150-year story. For The Signature of All Things she knew the last line and mapped the whole plot, the most controlled she has ever been.
She compares it to painting a house: stripping, taping and sanding first makes the roller pass fast. Once she was drafting, the outline receded.
Gilbert thinks readers shouldn't pay for a writer's research. She admires Hilary Mantel's Wolf Hall, which feels present and has no anachronism. She dislikes books where "somebody did a lot of research and now we must all pay."
She has read Wolf Hall more than any other book in 15 years and studies it like scripture.
Gilbert maps a book, then lets her characters decide key scenes. In City of Girls a love story is mentioned for four fifths of the book and appears only at the end. She left it undefined and asked the pair what they were to each other.
A romance novelist friend gave her the method: create the characters, put them together, and let them do what they would do. She is too much of a control freak to hand over the whole book.
She makes every character distinct so readers are never lost. She learned from Dickens, whose character on page 10 is instantly remembered on page 380. As a populist writer, she wants anyone who reads English to follow her.
She dislikes long series where she is ten pages in asking which alien general is speaking.
She shows early drafts only to readers who want her to succeed. She cites Brene Brown's standard: the reader must want you to succeed, have taste you trust and deliver bad news tenderly. She avoids anyone who advertises being brutally honest.
Criticism has never made her a better writer, and some people don't see a book until it is in galleys.
She reads aloud to a friend and listens for energy dips. Her first reader always says the draft is perfect, which gives her fortification. Gilbert notices where the friend lights up and where she is only politely listening.
The dip shows what isn't working, even when nobody says it.
She aims for the best book she can write, not the best there is. When told AI will soon write a better novel, she answers that humans like George Saunders already write better ones than she does.
She says she writes novels to write the best novel she can write, so a machine beating her changes nothing about her urge to create.
Gilbert says most of a writing life is discipline and preparation, with inspiration as a rare bonus that only visits people who keep showing up. The habit worth hearing is her 45 minute timer, paired with a season-based system of research, index cards and early readers who want you to succeed.
Gilbert vowed her life to writing at 15 or 16. She held what she calls a witchy little teenage girl ceremony. The vow meant writing whether or not she was good or successful at it.
Writing gave her the first sense of divinity, something mysterious and like a gift. She took little else seriously in her youth, but she took this seriously.
She learned the craft by copying other writers by hand. She filled notebooks with passages from novels she loved, some four or five pages long. She read everything within reach, then the whole NYU English reading list.
She skipped an English major to study what she couldn't learn from books. She wanted to eat the writing and asked herself how the authors did it.
She chose bartending over an MFA and called it graduate school. In 1990s New York she had a $900 apartment, and about four bar shifts a week paid for her life. At the Coyote Ugly Saloon she saw hundreds of people a week.
She felt she knew nothing to write about, so she went looking for humanity. She also didn't want to find her voice in a room of young people still finding theirs. She says to take an MFA only if someone else pays, never with debt.
She turned to Dickens to learn the novel when an agent asked for one. She only knew how to write stories of 10 or 15 pages. The agent said story collections are hard to sell, but a novel proposal could bring a two-book deal.
She calls Dickens the greatest novelist and the greatest character writer.
Six weeks after her partner died, she wrote a light book. She began City of Girls then and made it the most upbeat, champagne happy book of her life, because she needed to get off the grief.
Seven years later she could write about the loss openly. Her rule is to choose what you write to match what you can carry.
Gilbert says writing is mostly labor, with inspiration as a rare gift. She says the state where writing comes through her is a tiny share of 40 years at the desk, and chasing it doesn't work. She can create the labor but can't make the second thing happen.
She says The Signature of All Things is better than she can write, and she barely remembers drafting it after almost four years of preparation.
She writes by a 45-minute timer, not by word count. The only rules are that you can't stand up and you can't get on the internet. Ending with three sentences is a good day.
Her measure is time in the chair: "you don't gauge it by how much you did, you gauge it by how long you sat."
She stops when the timer rings, even in flow. Gilbert says that after four or five hours you feel you've paid your dues, skip the next day, and the habit breaks. Overlong binges can turn into four months of not writing.
Leaving while you still want more gives you excitement to return to tomorrow.
She tells writers to keep the day job and write one hour a day. Quitting to write a book leaves too much time. She says to set the alarm an hour earlier, write, then go to work.
She says the brain handles only about an hour in the furnace of creativity before weariness hits.
Gilbert writes in seasons, not every day. She spends a season on research and preparation, which she calls 90% of the work. Then she clears three or four months, set months ahead, and tells everyone not to expect her.
During drafting she keeps farmer's hours and rises at 4:30. Her farm childhood shaped the model.
She lies on the floor between bursts of intense drafting. After about an hour she gets up and does nothing, treating rest as part of the work. Near the end of a book she gets "barn fever," a burst of energy over the last 50 to 100 pages.
She has finished days afraid she had broken her brain.
When burned out, she stopped writing completely for six months. Her first sabbatical had no writing and no flights. She walked her dog, healed an injury, organized her house and saw friends.
She compares creative ground to a field that is ruined if overworked. She refused to write again until it felt fun, and now sees little sprigs of green in her imagination.
Gilbert picks the time and place first, then people, then plot. For City of Girls she started with New York City in the 1940s. Next came who is in that world, and last what they are doing, which she finds the hardest part.
She likens setting to a key in music. Plot begins to arrive as she researches the setting and builds characters.
She reads casual letters to learn how people really spoke. For 1940s New York she spent a year or two on period novels by forgotten authors, old New Yorker pieces and letters. She read John O'Hara and Talk of the Town columns.
With several mail deliveries a day, people wrote chatty, quick letters, much like email.
She keeps research on index cards in shoe boxes. She learned the method in a high school class in 1983. Each card holds one fact, with a code naming the book and page, plus cards per character and topic.
Cards can be shuffled, and she can reach in and pull a whole box on one character. After leaving a box on a train, about two years of work, she photocopies both boxes every few weeks.
She goes to the place and hunts for strange local sources. For a story set in 1880 Mississippi, she says to visit the smallest town's historical society, start with out of print oddities and talk to old people. Give it a year, not a week.
In Tahiti she learned the beach where Captain Cook landed had black sand, a detail no book she read had mentioned.
She has natives of a setting hunt for errors she calls omelets. For Snow Forest she gave the manuscript to Russian writers and geologists. An omelet is an error like Americans eating omelets at a baseball game instead of hot dogs.
She does this after the vulnerable first draft stage. She would rather be embarrassed in front of them than in the New York Times.
She wrote a 70-page synopsis for a 150-year story. For The Signature of All Things she knew the last line and mapped the whole plot, the most controlled she has ever been.
She compares it to painting a house: stripping, taping and sanding first makes the roller pass fast. Once she was drafting, the outline receded.
Gilbert thinks readers shouldn't pay for a writer's research. She admires Hilary Mantel's Wolf Hall, which feels present and has no anachronism. She dislikes books where "somebody did a lot of research and now we must all pay."
She has read Wolf Hall more than any other book in 15 years and studies it like scripture.
Gilbert maps a book, then lets her characters decide key scenes. In City of Girls a love story is mentioned for four fifths of the book and appears only at the end. She left it undefined and asked the pair what they were to each other.
A romance novelist friend gave her the method: create the characters, put them together, and let them do what they would do. She is too much of a control freak to hand over the whole book.
She makes every character distinct so readers are never lost. She learned from Dickens, whose character on page 10 is instantly remembered on page 380. As a populist writer, she wants anyone who reads English to follow her.
She dislikes long series where she is ten pages in asking which alien general is speaking.
She shows early drafts only to readers who want her to succeed. She cites Brene Brown's standard: the reader must want you to succeed, have taste you trust and deliver bad news tenderly. She avoids anyone who advertises being brutally honest.
Criticism has never made her a better writer, and some people don't see a book until it is in galleys.
She reads aloud to a friend and listens for energy dips. Her first reader always says the draft is perfect, which gives her fortification. Gilbert notices where the friend lights up and where she is only politely listening.
The dip shows what isn't working, even when nobody says it.
She aims for the best book she can write, not the best there is. When told AI will soon write a better novel, she answers that humans like George Saunders already write better ones than she does.
She says she writes novels to write the best novel she can write, so a machine beating her changes nothing about her urge to create.