CaddieOpen in CaddieDownload for Mac

This Is What 40 Years of Writing Discipline Looks Like (Elizabeth Gilbert Interview)

Shared by Caddie Library · Updated
David Perell1:15:49Open on YouTube
Chapters show their main points

The bottom line

Writing is mostly discipline and preparation, with inspiration a rare gift that arrives only to those who show up. Short daily sessions, seasons of research, and rest keep the work sustainable over decades.

Key takeaways

Measure by time sat, and stop wanting more
Stopping while you still want to write is what makes you return the next day.
  • Discipline, not inspiration, does nearly all the work. 10:40
    • The channeling state, where the writing happens through her, is a minuscule share of 40 years at the desk, and chasing it doesn't work.
    • She writes by the clock, not by word count. Set a 45-minute timer, don't stand up or go online, and stop when it rings so you want to return tomorrow.
  • Most of the work is preparation, done in seasons. 12:44
    • She calls preparation 90% of the work, then clears three or four months for a daily writing season that starts at 4:30 a.m.
    • Her research lives in shoe boxes of index cards sorted by character and topic, so she can reach in and build a scene.
  • A writer needs real-world experience to have anything to write. 33:22
    • Bartending at the Coyote Ugly Saloon put hundreds of people a week in front of her, and she called it her graduate school classroom.
    • In Tahiti she found the landing beach had black sand, a detail none of her book research had mentioned.
  • Show early work only to people who want you to succeed. 26:57
    • Her first readers must want her to win, have taste she trusts, and deliver bad news tenderly. She avoids anyone who advertises being "brutally honest" until the book is in galleys.
    • She reads aloud to a friend who says it's perfect, and listens for where the friend's energy dips.
  • When the creative well runs dry, stop completely. 1:06:17
    • She took a six-month sabbatical with no writing and no flights, spending the time on walks, her dog, and coffee with friends.
    • Like farm fields, creative ground that is overworked never recovers, so it needs fallow seasons.

You don't gauge it by how much you did, you gauge it by how long you sat.

Elizabeth Gilbert

Chapter summaries

0:00 Introduction

Gilbert's story starts with a teenage vow, and the conversation asks what four decades of writing have taught her about craft, dry spells, character and advice.

  • The conversation covers the craft, the creative well, storytelling and advice for new writers. 0:11
    • Gilbert is known for Big Magic and Eat, Pray, Love.
    • The questions: what she has learned about the craft, where she goes when the well runs dry, how she builds characters and tells stories.
    • The talk is recorded in the host's New York apartment.
    • It begins with the vow she made as a teenager and works toward advice for aspiring writers.

1:44 The vow she made to become a writer

At 15 or 16 Gilbert vowed her life to writing, and copying other writers by hand taught her the craft.

  • She committed to writing for life, whatever the cost or result. 0:29
    • She held a witchy little teenage girl ceremony to vow her life to it.
    • The vow meant doing it whether she was good or successful at it or not.
    • Writing gave her the first sense I had of divinity, something mysterious, beautiful and like a gift.
    • She took little else seriously in her youth, including her own health, but she took this seriously.
  • Copying beautiful passages by hand was how she learned to write. 1:54
    • She filled notebooks with excerpts, some four or five pages long, handwritten from novels she loved. Cheryl Strayed kept the same kind of notebooks.
    • A painter friend learned to draw by sketching other artists' work in museums.
    • There were no computers then, so the physical act of writing the words may have helped her absorb them.
    • She wanted to eat the writing, and asked herself how the authors did it.
  • She read everything within reach, then the whole NYU English reading list. 3:10
    • Her father's shelves gave her Roth, Updike, Patrick O'Brian, John Irving, Hemingway and Faulkner.
    • She also read Reader's Digest, Woman's Day and the back of a shampoo bottle.
    • She skipped an English major to study what she couldn't learn by reading, but got the reading lists for the undergraduate English classes and read all the books.

4:15 Should you get an MFA?

An MFA can be worth it only if someone else pays, because starting an artist's life in debt is a nightmare.

  • Take an MFA only if you are rich, funded or can pay without harm, and never borrow for it. 4:23
    • Some great writers have come out of MFA programs, so it can be right if your intuition says so.
    • She would plead with you as though for my own life not to go into debt for an arts degree.
    • Her friend Ann Patchett holds that a program that doesn't offer a full ride hasn't really accepted you and just wants your money.
    • Gilbert says she doesn't know the realities well enough to say whether that is true.

5:43 Labor vs inspiration

Labor does the work; inspiration is a rare guest
LaborInspiration
Who controls itShe does, every dayCan't be summoned
How it feelsTiring, restless, hardBlessed relief; she's not there
Afterwards"I did that"A blackout she barely remembers
Share of 40 yearsNearly allMinuscule
ExampleMost of her booksThe Signature of All Things
She can always produce the labor, but she can't summon the blackout state that wrote The Signature of All Things.

Creativity needs both human labor and a mysterious inspiration, and the labor is far the larger share.

  • Both the worker and the channel are true, so her answer to "which one?" is yes. 5:53
    • She can tell the difference between what she did and what she watched come out of her.
    • She can create the labor, but she can't make the second thing happen.
    • If she were only a channel she wouldn't be so tired from how hard she works.
    • Her definition of creativity as a divine partnership came from someone asking her to choose one side.
  • One book feels beyond her skill, and she barely remembers writing it. 7:46
    • She says The Signature of All Things is better than she can write.
    • She prepared hard for almost four years, but the summer of writing is a little bit of a blackout.
    • She can point to other books and say I did that, as the measure of how well she can write.
  • The channeling state is a relief from being herself, and it only comes while she is working. 8:31
    • It doesn't feel like anything because she isn't there, a vacation from having to be myself.
    • She can't sit down cold and trigger it, but it comes upon her when she is working.
    • A French visual artist said to kick out the critics, then your rivals, then your admirers, and then to leave yourself.
    • Writing has felt like what people promised meditation would feel like, while her meditation mostly feels like sitting around thinking.

11:00 Don't write every day

Write in seasons, not every day
The actual writing is a short golden summer that sits on top of months of preparation.

Gilbert borrows farm rhythms of daily duty and seasonal work, and keeps writing sustainable by stopping early and resting hard.

  • Growing up on a farm taught her to work hard and repeat the work. 11:46
    • Farming is still her best metaphor for a creative life. Animals can't be skipped for a day.
    • She thanks her mother for teaching her to work, though she didn't at the time.
    • Avicii looked stressed and insecure in a studio video while Chris Martin called him a genius, a gap between the mundane process and the result.
  • She works in seasons instead of writing every day. 12:47
    • She tells everyone to expect her gone for three or four months, and clears the calendar months ahead.
    • During that season she works farmer's hours, rising at 4:30.
    • She calls the writing season the summer, the golden time of actually making the thing.
    • Both her fiction and non-fiction need heavy research first.
  • Stopping when the timer rings protects the habit. 14:37
    • If you write four or five hours on a good day, you may not write the next day, and then not for four months.
    • Stopping early leaves carbonated excitement to return to.
    • The Yiddish word sitzfleisch names the cushioning needed to stay in the chair when restless and bored.
    • She sits as a form of meditation, because it lasts only for a set period.
  • Keep your day job and write one hour a day. 15:56
    • Quitting to write a book leaves too much time, and you need about an hour, not eight.
    • Wake an hour earlier, sleep an hour earlier, write, then go to work.
  • The brain tires after about an hour, so rest is part of the work. 16:50
    • Once in flow she writes an hour, then lies on the floor and does nothing.
    • Near the end she gets barn fever, a burst of energy like a horse that sees the barn, over the last 50 to 100 pages.
    • She guesses the exhaustion comes from building new brain synapses.
    • At that stage she stops eating and sleeping, and has called a friend afraid she had broken my brain.

20:08 Let characters take over

Gilbert treats ideas and characters as a presence that visits her, so she builds the map and then lets them act.

  • Ideas feel like visitors, so the muses are a sane name for that feeling. 20:17
    • Inspiration literally means breathing a spirit in from outside you.
    • Even scientists and atheists say a big idea came to me.
    • Hilary Mantel pulled up a chair and talked to Thomas Cromwell while writing Wolf Hall.
    • Mantel also described seeing ghosts as a child. Gilbert says she "co-wrote" the books with Cromwell.
    • Gilbert finds this saner than claiming to generate everything from her "big beautiful brain".
  • Once the characters exist, she lets them decide what happens between them. 22:10
    • In City of Girls, a love story is referred to for four fifths of the book and appears only at the end.
    • She had the book mapped but did not know the love story, so she asked the pair What are you to each other?
    • A romance novelist friend told her to create the characters, put them together, and let them do what they would do.
    • She used that advice on the erotica awakening in The Signature of All Things, after worrying it might embarrass her character.
    • She is too much of a control freak to hand over the whole book, but open enough to say "over to you guys".

24:07 Why she outlined 70 pages

Preparation is what lets the drafting go fast
Gilbert compares her most controlled book to an expert house painter: all the slow work happens before the fun roller pass.

A sprawling, multigenerational plot needs a detailed map, and the map is what makes drafting fast.

  • She wrote a 70-page synopsis because the book was too complex to hold in her head. 24:26
    • The story spans 150 years, several generations and many plot twists.
    • She knew the last line and needed to know how to get there.
    • She calls it the most controlled she has ever been.
    • Painting a house: her first time, she hit window panes, furniture, filthy radiators and a hole in the wall, and had to start over.
    • An expert strips the room, tapes, sands rust and cleans, so the roller pass is fast and the most fun part.

26:40 Choose your first reader

Criticism has never improved Gilbert's work, so early readers should be chosen with great care.

  • Criticism has never made Gilbert a better writer. 26:57
    • She urges being very careful about whom you show work or ideas to.
    • It is hard enough without brutal critics' voices in your head.
    • Some people in her life do not get to see a book until it is in galleys.
    • Brené Brown codified a standard for a creative team, and the first test is that they want you to succeed.
  • Perell argues the very first reader should offer pure support. 29:17
    • A first draft is so vulnerable that he has "no skin on".
    • Gilbert is surprised, having stressed that supporters must also tell hard truths gently.
    • His fear is what the reader will see in him that he does not want seen.
    • He wants "tender velvet gloves" for the first read.
  • Writing classrooms are dangerous rooms, so she skipped the MFA. 30:41
    • In college classes she saw people speak casually and confidently, with cruelty, cliques and exclusion.
    • She did not want to find her voice among young people still finding theirs.
    • She has seen people "absolutely wrecked by criticism".

31:26 Working at a bar vs grad school

Cheap rent and survival jobs let Gilbert learn voice by going out among strange people instead of sitting in a seminar.

  • 1990s New York was cheap enough for a bartender to live as an artist. 31:59
    • She had a $900 apartment, and about four bar shifts paid for her life.
    • She now sees it was a golden age, though nobody knows it at the time.
    • She went to NYU, then traveled, then returned to New York.
    • A Philadelphia diner and a ranch served the same purpose.
    • The Coyote Ugly movie was based on an article she wrote about the bar.
  • She went looking for humanity because she felt she knew nothing to write about. 33:40
    • Behind the bar it was a "reverse stage", a theatrical performance she was paid to watch.
    • Told to write what she knew, she felt she knew only her field hockey team.
    • Her journalism beat became eccentric outcasts in subcultures so siloed they did not know they were one.
    • She worked on Maine lobster boats and in island communities with territory wars, heavy drinking and violence.
    • She describes those worlds as frozen in amber and doubts they survive in a more homogenized world.

36:54 What she learned from Dickens

Dickens taught Gilbert to make every character unmistakable so the reader is never lost.

  • She turned to Dickens to learn the novel after an agent asked for one. 37:17
    • The agent said story collections are hard to sell, but a novel proposal could bring a two-book deal.
    • She only knew how to write stories of 10 or 15 pages.
    • Her first publication was a short story.
    • She calls Dickens the greatest novelist and the greatest character writer.
  • Distinct characters let a reader trust the writer and never feel lost. 37:49
    • In Bleak House, a character appears on page 10, returns on page 380, and is still instantly remembered.
    • Reading Dickens, she feels she is in "such good hands".
    • She complains that in long sci-fi and fantasy series she asks "which alien general is this?"
    • As a populist writer, she wants anyone who can read English to follow her.
  • Plot is her hardest part, and she builds toward it from setting and people. 39:23
    • She starts with a time and place, such as New York in the 1940s.
    • Next comes who is in that world, and last what they are doing.
    • Plot starts to arrive as she researches and builds characters and setting.
    • The last question, "What is the point of this book?", is the one she finds hardest.
    • She says she is not great at advising others on plot.

40:20 How she does research

Good research means learning the sound of an era, collecting details by hand, going to the place, and letting natives catch the errors.

  • A setting works like a musical key, so she steeps in an era's own voices first. 40:20
    • Lee Child's idea: choosing a setting rules out most possibilities, as winter in Maine differs from summer in Arizona.
    • For 1940s New York she read little but period novels and old New Yorkers for a year or two.
    • She reads John O'Hara and "Talk of the Town" pieces, writers few people read now.
    • Casual letters show how people really talked. With up to three mail deliveries a day in London, they chatted like email.
  • Her index card method comes from a high school class. 42:13
    • Mr. Kisco taught it in 1983 at Lichfield High. Each card holds one fact, and a code like A14 gives the book and page for footnotes.
    • Cards can be shuffled, so plots and characters can be moved around visibly.
    • She once left a box on a Metro North train, about two years of work. She got it back.
    • Now she photocopies both boxes every few weeks, since a house fire would destroy them.
  • Real research starts with going there and finding the key person. 45:30
    • For 1880 Mississippi, start with the weirdest out-of-print material. Visit the smallest town's historical society and talk to old people.
    • For Tahiti she asked around until she found the person who could open that world.
    • Her Tahiti list had a cave, a waterfall, and a cliff climb beside it.
    • A story like the Mississippi one needs a year, not a week.
  • Natives of the setting should read the draft to find her mistakes. 46:53
    • For Snow Forest she gave the manuscript to Russian writers and geologists and asked them to find the "omelets."
    • An omelet is her image for an error like Russians writing Americans eating omelets at a baseball game instead of hot dogs.
    • She asks after the vulnerable first draft: I would much rather be embarrassed in front of you than be embarrassed in the New York Times.
    • She asks them to flag what people would eat, wear, or say differently.

50:18 Should you pursue greatness?

She wants to be a great writer and leans on the identity hard, but she is learning to hold it loosely.

  • Writing is the ground she stands on, most of all in grief. 50:29
    • She has pursued greatness, and hearing "this is a great book" matters to her.
    • Six weeks after her partner Rya died, she started City of Girls because writing was ground she could touch.
    • She describes grief as feeling like a head injury, with no ground underfoot.
    • The vow at 16 meant she could mess up everything else and still be a writer.
  • Any identity can be lost, so she tries to cling less to being a writer. 52:26
    • She calls it slightly suboptimal to identify as anything that can be lost.
    • Being a writer is a lifeboat that got her through storms, but she may have to let it go.
    • She asks whether she can relax into having no identity at all.
  • She used fun writing to escape grief, then wrote about it years later. 53:41
    • City of Girls was the most upbeat, "champagne happy" book of her life. Seven years after Rya died she could write about the grief openly.
    • Her journal is private and keeps her "visible to herself," a phrase from a 12-step meeting.
    • Rob Bell calls past selves "seven Robs ago," and Springsteen says every past self is still "in the van."

56:18 The importance of fun in writing

Fun, easy, profitable means something different to her
WordWhat it sounds likeWhat she means
FunAlways enjoyableEven the not-fun part beats others' fun
EasyEffortlessShe knows how to work through the hard puzzle
ProfitableBig moneyNo other living she'd rather have
Each word is true for her only because she has redefined it around the work itself.

Writing is fun, easy, and profitable for her because even its bad days beat other work, though how writers earn has shifted.

  • Her joke that writing is "fun, easy, and profitable" is true in her own sense. 56:25
    • It is fun because even the not-fun part beats what most people call fun, like years studying moss.
    • It is easy because she knows how to work through the puzzle, and profitable because she wants no other living.
    • She said it to John Hodgman, and her friend Margaret's kids quote it at every writing assignment.
    • Big-money magazine work, her income for about four years, is gone. Substack now exists.

59:06 Has publishing gotten harder?

Attention is scarce and controversy is cheap, so publishing is harder, yet she keeps creating because it was always hard.

  • Distraction makes it harder to tell readers a book exists. 59:11
    • She sees fewer people making most of the money, and it feels less easy and more unfair than before.
    • Fans say her work changed their lives but do not know she has published three books in ten years.
    • She ran a four-month, eight-hours-a-day publicity campaign for a book that her own followers missed.
  • Fear of controversy adds strain for the people who publish. 1:02:03
    • She says it is much easier to land in a massive controversy, and some caution is fair.
    • Publicists spend their days putting out fires.
    • One line pulled from an early review can set off an internet pile-on and death threats.
    • She sees a bottleneck as an opening for someone with a new idea.
  • She keeps writing because the vow outlasts every era's difficulty, AI included. 1:03:13
    • It was hard in 1984, 1994, 2004, and 2014, and no one ever said the arts are easy.
    • She does not write the best novel, only the best she can, and humans like George Saunders already beat her.
    • When told AI will soon write a better novel, she answers that it changes nothing about her urge to create.

1:04:14 Herzog's advice to artists

Every decade says it's a hard time for art
Since the complaint never changes, a hard climate is never a reason to wait.

Artists in every era say it is a hard time to make art, so the hard climate is never a reason to wait.

  • Complaints about the times are constant, so they are not a reason to stop. 1:05:02
    • Elizabeth has heard it's really hard now to make art in every decade for almost 40 years.
    • Werner Herzog told a struggling filmmaker to stop whining and steal a camera if he had to.
    • The filmmaker was an Italian friend of hers who wrote to Herzog in the 1990s about the lack of funding and grants. He framed the reply in his office.
    • Herzog took his own advice and walked out of film school with a camera because he couldn't afford to continue.

1:06:14 What to do when burned out

Burnout calls for a full stop that lasts until the work feels fun again.

  • She refused to write until the joy returned, whatever others expected. 1:06:17
    • A friend predicted she would come out of the sabbatical with a novel. She answered that she was broken and would not write until it felt fun.
    • Only now does she feel tiny sprigs of green coming up in her imagination.
    • She also tidied her house, gave away many things and healed a physical injury.
    • While writing a book she has no time for anyone, so open days with friends felt special. She says she needed that very, very much.

1:07:57 Elizabeth's writing inspirations

Her heroes show that nerve, decency and a vivid sense of reality can sit alongside great talent.

  • George Eliot's nerve and George Saunders's decency show what a great writer's character can be. 1:08:10
    • Eliot knew she had the goods and knew she could not publish under a woman's name. Elizabeth calls the pen name a move cunning like a fox.
    • Saunders is a genius who is also kind. She rejects assholery as a side effect of genius.
    • Whitman likewise wrote his own publicity for Song of Myself, calling himself the greatest talent of the age.
    • Saunders keeps a Buddhist practice to become a better person and always has time for others.
  • Hilary Mantel made a historical novel feel present by never showing off her research. 1:10:09
    • Elizabeth has read Wolf Hall more than any other book in 15 years and studies it like it's the Torah.
    • Weak historical fiction feels like somebody did a lot of research and now we must all pay.
    • Every Mantel book is completely different from the others.
    • Cromwell feels so physically present that Elizabeth never doubts it happened that way. It feels of this moment, with no anachronism.

1:12:06 Get out of the classroom

Delight and lived experience matter more to a writer than study, grants or debt.

  • She tattooed "stubborn gladness" because enjoying the world is a duty even amid suffering. 1:12:22
    • The phrase comes from Jack Gilbert's poem A Brief for the Defense, which defends enjoying a world on fire.
    • He does not deny suffering. Miracles keep unfolding like an opening hand alongside it.
    • The poem says We can do without pleasure, but not delight.
    • In prayer she hears what a pity it would be if no one saw this.
  • Young writers should go live in the world instead of sitting in a seminar room. 1:14:06
    • After one semester teaching an MFA at the University of Tennessee, she wanted students out of the room, even if it hurts.
    • She told them not to go into debt, and to get jobs instead of grants.
    • A job with people teaches more than a grant. Her example was to wash dishes on a nuclear submarine.
    • Her summary: doing a lot more and thinking a lot less.

In the growth library

Elizabeth Gilbert, Novelist and memoirist, author of Big Magic. Gilbert says most of a writing life is discipline and preparation, with inspiration as a rare bonus that only visits people who keep showing up. The habit worth hearing is her 45 minute timer, paired with a season-based system of research, index cards and early readers who want you to succeed.

Lessons that draw on this:

More from How I Write · The whole library, and ask it anything

Transcript2020 lines
Introduction 0:00
0:00

We got Elizabeth Gilbert on the show today and you might know her from books like Big Magic or We Pray Love, but her story begins back when she was a teenager and she made a vow to dedicate her life to writing. [music] And now decades later, I want to ask, what is it that you've learned about the craft? Where do you go when the creative well runs dry? How do you tell great stories, build compelling characters, and what advice do you have for aspiring writers?

0:23

So, here we are, my apartment in New York, and here's my conversation with Elizabeth Gober. Tell me about the vow that you made with writing early in your life. >> Yeah. So, I made a decision when I was about 15 or 16 that that I was going to commit myself to this and I did a ceremony around it. Um, I did like a witchy little teenage girl ceremony [laughter] where I like vowed my life to to writing. Um, and and I'm not sure I'm trying to remember how much I knew of what I was committing to, but I think like no matter what it costs, no matter what anybody else says about it, um, whether we're good at it or not or successful at it or not, we're going to do this thing. And and it felt very holy. I think that for me from a very early age, what it felt like to write was the first sense I had of divinity, like something extraorldly, you know, something mysterious and beautiful and that felt like a gift. Um,

1:34

and I took it really seriously. There's a lot in my life I didn't take seriously when I was young, including my own health and well-being, but I took that seriously. I took that seriously.

The vow she made to become a writer 1:44
1:44

>> And did you feel that sense of magic as a reader >> or was it really as a writer where you felt that? >> Both. >> Huh. >> Um I certainly felt it as a reader. I was having conversation once with Cheryl Strade and we found out that we both had done the same thing when we were teenagers. We were such passionate readers that we had notebooks where we were copying things that we had read that we thought were really beautiful into those notebooks. So, I've got notebooks that are filled with excerpts, some of them four or five pages long, where I've like laboriously handwritten some whole section of a novel. Um, or sometimes it's just a line or a couple lines, but like something in me loved it so much I wanted to like eat it. and she did the same thing and I think I think actually even the physicality because again when I started writing we didn't have computers so everything was by hand so I think even my hand writing

2:42

these beautiful words >> did something to me embibing it and um and I have a friend who's an incredible painter and when she was a artistic teenager she would go to museums and like draw you know just draw like have notebooks filled with drawings of other people's work and that is partially how she learned how to draw. So I think what Cheryl and I were doing is partially how we learned how to write and that was and it was the things that just that stuff looked beautiful to me. It looked magical to me. I'm like how are they doing this?

3:10

>> Who did you copy? >> Whoever was around I mean I was such a voracious reader and my dad so he was reading like what men were reading in the 60s7s and 80s. So I was reading that. So I was I mean most of what was being published was white dudes of a certain age. Anyway, but like particularly because my dad was the reader. Um, so I was reading Philip Roth and I was reading John Updike and Patrick O'Brien, John Irving, and then I was also reading Hemingway and Faulner because he had those in the library. So like I read through whatever was in our house and I would read Reader's Digest and I would read Women's Day magazine and I would read the back of a you know shampoo bottle [laughter] like I was just like feed it to me, you know. Um, and then when I went to college, I didn't study English because I I want I I wanted to learn things that I couldn't just learn by reading, but I did get the reading lists for all of the

4:10

English classes in the undergraduate English department at NYU, and I read all of those books.

Should you get an MFA? 4:15
4:15

>> So, if I came to you, I said, "Hey, I want to I want to write novels. I want to learn do what you did." Would you caution me against getting an MFA? Would you say, "Hey, maybe." What would you tell me? If you're rich or you get a full scholarship and you want to do it, sure. I if you feel like that's going to be like great for you, I mean, some great writers have come out of MFA programs. >> Um, but I would beg you on my knees to not go into debt, to get an arts degree. Like I would plead with you as though for my own life for you to not do that because to start your life as an artist in debt is a nightmare. So please don't do that.

4:58

But if you if if you are dying to and you want to and it feels right in like in your own intuition and you either can pay for it out of pocket and it's not going to hurt you. Um and my friend Anne Patchet has a belief that if they don't give you a full ride, they haven't really accepted you into the program. they just want your money. But if they give you a full ride, then they want you there. Um, and and that's pretty harsh.

5:22

I don't know the realities well enough to know that that's true. But please don't go into debt to be an artist. Please don't go into debt to be an artist. And lastly, please don't go into debt to be an artist. [laughter] >> And also, please don't go into debt to be >> Anything else to add? >> No, just about debt and art. Please don't. Please don't. There's this

Labor vs inspiration 5:43
5:43

definition of creativity that you shared many years ago that it's the divine partnership between human labor and the mystery of inspiration >> that came out of a question that somebody asked me one time about as if it were a binary as if you can only answer to one of these. Do you believe that you are the one creating like doing the work and creating this thing or do you believe that you're the channel that inspiration is pouring through? And my answer was yes. [laughter] [gasps] And I I think actually to make a mind that's expansive enough to include both of those realities to be true, right? because it isn't just me because I can tell the difference between something that I did and something that's happening that I'm watching come out of me and and both are important. I I can't make the second thing happen. I can create the labor that that's, you know, that makes work happen. But you know, anybody who's creative will know

6:51

about times where, you know, they lost a sense of hours going by where, you know, the the they looked up and the room had turned dark and night had fallen and they didn't even know where they were, you know. So there's this state of almost being taken over by this thing. But that's not always and sometimes it's labor and sometimes it's just allowing inspiration to come through. But I think >> both are true. And um and and that's what creativity is. Yeah. And also, I think when you get taken over, it's this sense of you made something and maybe how did I do that?

7:22

>> Yeah. Yeah. How did I do that? And and also if it were only just being a channel, then I wouldn't be so [laughter] tired from how hard I work because I also work really hard. Um but yeah, there's things there's things I think that every artist can point out and be like, I I don't remember doing that. I that's better. A feeling I have um about one of my books is that's better than I can write. >> Which book? >> The signature of all things. That's better than I can write. You know, I can't do that. [laughter] >> And I can look at other books and be like, I did that. You know, I did that.

7:59

My I sat down in my labor created that and that's how well I can write. That's there it is right there. And then that book's like, I didn't do that. I did a lot of the labor. I remember very hard. I remember working really hard to prepare for the writing of that book for almost four years. I don't have much memory of that summer of the actual process of writing it. It's a little bit of a blackout. So, I don't know what that is, but it's exciting.

8:26

>> When you're in that, we'll call it the channeling state. >> What does that feel like? >> It doesn't feel like anything because I'm not there. And I now wish I could remember which French artist, visual artist said, like when you get ready to create, first you have to kind of mentally and emotionally kick the critics out of the room and then you have to kick out of the room all the people that you compete with and then you have to throw out of the room all the people who admire you and then you have to leave.

8:55

>> You have to leave. >> Yeah. >> And then you have to leave. [laughter] like you also have to go um so that this thing can happen. My experience is like you can't I can't sit down cold and have that happen. But it will happen upon me when I'm working. Um so it when it's in when I'm in that zone um it doesn't feel like anything because I'm I'm I'm not there and it's a blessed relief like a vacation from having to be myself. I guess it's a some sort of non normal state of consciousness or its own sort of altered state. Every single thing that when I began my spiritual journey people promised meditation would feel like is what writing has felt like.

9:39

>> Wow. >> Um and very rarely has meditation felt like that. Meditation for me mostly feels like me sitting around thinking. [laughter] >> And what is what is the thing? Is it uh a clear mind? Is it a release? Is it kind of no thoughts? It can feel like a lot of other parts of meditation too, like boring. Um, and looking at your watch like how long much longer do I have to sit here? Um, and and and I want to be really clear. The thing I'm talking about, we sort of jumped right into it. That rarified altered state of something capturing you and you not being present for it and you coming out a few states later and something has been done through your hands is so rare. And it's it's a minuscule percentage of what my writing life has felt like for the last 40 years. I don't chase it because you can't cha you're not going to get it by chasing it. So a lot of what I do is just discipline. Um and much much much

10:44

more of what I do is discipline than inspiration. But with the discipline and sitting down at your desk at the same time every day and being prepared and making yourself sit there for two hours and that's the ground that opens you up for the preparation to maybe have a

Don't write every day 11:00
11:00

miracle, >> right? There's a real kind of mundanity to creativity. Is that a word? Mundanity. >> Um there's this great >> I don't know. Ask a writer. There's this great video. [laughter] There's a great video where Avichi is in the studio with um uh Chris Martin from Coldplay. >> Uhhuh. >> And Avichi is making a sound and Avichi is kind of like stressed out and like really not that happy and super focused and Chris Martin hears the sound and he goes, "Dude, you're a genius." And Avichi just goes, "Do you like it?" like very kind of insecure and you almost don't even feel like he's in the flow and I find that just the justosition between those two to be wild.

11:46

>> Yeah. I mean I had good preparation for a writing life because I grew up on a farm and to me still farming everything having to do with agricultural life is still the most operative metaphor that I can think of for what it feels like for me to be a creative person. Um, first of all, it's very hard work [laughter] and so I was taught to do very hard work and from a very young age was taught and this I thank my mother for even though I didn't at the time but I was taught to work and the thing about farming is like it has to be done you know especially if you're taking animal taking care of animals like you can't skip it for a day the animals will suffer and die right like you have to really be disciplined and repetitive And it's a lot of repetitive stuff. But then I also think of the agricultural model of like seasons of work, which is how I feel like my work comes through. Like there's

12:44

research season. So for me, I don't write every day. I write in seasons. So I'm not in a season of writing right now, but I've just come out of a season of writing, but it's like season of research and then preparation, which for me is 90% of the work, and then gathering everything that I'm going to need because both my fiction and non-fiction require a lot of research typically. And then there's the season of creativity. And that is the sort of most that's like the summer, you know, that's like the magical or spring or something like that's the most generative time and you only have a certain amount of time to do it. You know what I mean? Like so so I don't know. Like the way I do it is I let everybody in my life know that you're not going to see me for a few months and I clear that calendar months in advance. I'm like we're leading up to this. I'm going to be writing so don't ask me doing anything between these

13:38

dates. Like usually three or four months. And then then that's the golden time, the season of the of the actual making of the thing. >> And then you're working farmers hours, >> working farmers hours. I'm up at 4:30 and I'm >> pulling the sun over the horizon, >> and and you know, and like just especially at the very beginning, I write by the clock. I don't write by the words. So the best advice I always have for people about establishing discipline in writing is 45 minutes is a magical number. Like you set that timer for 45 minutes. you sit down and the only rule is for me um you can't stand up from the chair and you can't get on the internet.

14:16

And if you end up after that 45 minutes with three sentences, then that's a good day's work. Um you don't gauge it by how much you did, you gauge it by how long you sat and then you do that every day. 45 minutes, 45 minutes. And then the magical trick is the first day that you want to keep going. Don't >> what >> you don't. Because here's the thing I figured out is if you keep going like suddenly you're in the zone and you're like, "Oh my god, I'm in the zone." And you sit there for four or five hours, you won't write the next day. It's going to break this. It's going to break the discipline because the next day you're going to wake up and be like, "I don't have to because yesterday I wrote for four hours." And then you won't write for four months. That's how that's how I experience it. So like timer goes off, get up, leave, and then then there's that sort of carbonated excitement like I want to get back into this tomorrow,

15:07

you know, and you pick up it. So you don't burn yourself out. It's like steady, steady, steady. And that's usually what the first weeks feel like and then the flow starts and then by the end I'm not even in the room anymore, you know? But that's that's my that's my tactic. >> I like the idea of when you start writing, you just can't stand for a little while. You got to to get vertical in the seat. They call the there's a there's a Yiddish word um sits flesh that means like ass flesh basically like do you have the and people will say when they talk about discipline like do you have the sits flesh to do that like do you have the cushioning [laughter] do you have enough cushioning on that butt to not stand up and it's hard because you get restless and bored and frustrated and it's like yeah but it's not forever and that's where it does feel like meditation it's only for this period of time so that's why I get like

15:58

squirrely when People I hear people say they're going to quit their job to write a book. I'm like, "Oh, no, no, no. Don't do that because it's too much time. You'll have too much time on your hands." And you're not going to be writing eight hours a day. You don't need eight hours a day. You need an hour a day. And much better that you set your alarm for an hour earlier than you usually wake up, go to sleep an hour earlier than you usually do, write for an hour, and then go to work. Um, and then come back and do that and do that and do that and don't quit your day job as you know. I'm not an advocate of that.

16:33

>> So, what is it like a little bit of time and then like a lot of yearning, a lot of desire, a lot of want to like what's the other ingredient there? >> I think we're unrealistic about how much time your brain can handle being in the furnace of creativity. the furnace or the graveyard, you know, or that like it's boring or it's exciting, but it's intense. Like it what your brain has to do like the amount of logic that your brain has to be creating and like it's it's exhausting and and I usually can't sit for more than about an hour before there's a weariness that comes over me that's huge. But once I'm in the flow, what I'll do is I'll write for an hour and then I'll get up and then I'll lay on the floor do nothing.

17:20

And a huge part of my creativity is just laying on the floor and doing nothing because it's like it's physically exhausting for some reason. And I think it's because you're >> creating new brain synapses or something. I I don't know what why it feels so tiring. Um thinking that hard, you know, like it and being that dialed in and being that focused, >> there's only so much of it that I I can take. So there it's good to alternate.

17:47

It's like, right, stop and don't stop and scroll. You know, lay down, shut your eyes, right? Like, just stop. Your brain is hurt hurting. And like when I'm toward the end of a writing project and I'm going because then I get this another agricultural metaphor, something that I learned in my family is called barn fever. Like when you've got a horse out for the day and it's lagging and it's exhausted and it's dragging its feet, but when it sees the barn, all sudden has this tremendous burst of energy and it runs to the barn really fast and it's called barn fever because it knows it's almost over. So I get barn fever like in the last 100, you know, 50 or 100 pages of the book where I'm just like, we're not eating now. We're not sleeping now. And that's where I will sometimes call a friend and say like, I'm really afraid I might have broken my brain today. [laughter] And that's that's suboptimal. Like I try

18:39

to lead an or order orderly enough life that I'm not breaking my brain, but toward the end of the book, it's can start to feel like I've actually done harm to my [laughter] brain. >> Mhm. This episode is sponsored by Alpha School. When you think of school, what comes to mind? For me, it was lectures, homework, being stuck at a desk. And the worst part is that it doesn't even work. 54% of Americans read below a sixth grade level. That's over half of Americans. We need something new. And that's why I'm excited to have Alpha School as the flagship sponsor of How I Write. At Alpha, you go to school, you get all your academics done in only 2 hours per day. So that then you can spend the rest of the time learning life skills like running a business, writing a musical, giving a TEDex talk. You know, the kind of things that make you a capable and well-rounded person. And it's working. They have the academics

19:31

figured out. Alpha classes test in the top 1% nationally and more than 90% of students say they love school. Now, I used to live in Austin [music] where Alpha School started and I was consistently blown away by what was happening there. I personally mentored a bunch of the kids and what stuck out to me is how much their team believes in the potential of kids. Alpha's approach and the success it's already having is why it's the most talked about K through2 school in the world right now and also where I want to send my kids to school one day. So, if you want to learn more, visit go.alpha.school/howite.

20:05

[music]

Let characters take over 20:08
20:08

What do you make of the idea of the muses going back to ancient Greece? Like, is that in what ways is it right? In what ways you like, I'm not sure I agree with that? >> I think that like when I wrote Big Magic, I talked a lot in that book about ideas as an energetic force that is outside of us that wants to engage with us. That's what inspiration feels like. It's what inspiration means. It means breathing in like you're taking this spirit into yourself. And even people who are, you know, really empirical thinkers and, you know, um, scientists and and atheists, you talk to them about where they got big ideas, they'll almost always say it came to them, right? Like, oh, and then it came to me. Like they use this language of a visitation, right? It's what it feels like. It's what it actually feels like. And so to create this idea of muses is to name that feeling and to personalize it and and to say like yes, you are being

21:07

visited and you're being visited by these these female spirits who want to create with you. Um and I think that's actually a better way like more sane way to see it than I'm sitting here generating this out of my big beautiful brain because it doesn't feel like I'm sitting there generating it out of my big beautiful brain at all times. It does feel like there's some other presence in the room and and a lot of writers will say that. A lot of artists will say that. Hillary Mantel, who wrote the incredible Wolf Hall Thomas Cromwell series, would pull up a chair next to her because she was straight up talking to Thomas Cromwell while she was writing those books. Like she was like legit just like talking to him. She's also somebody who has talked about seeing ghosts when she was a child. like so she was very tapped into sort of nether worlds but she she co-wrote that book with Tom Cromwell if if you read

22:03

interviews with her talking about it and and I've had this experience with fictional characters where I will like with my novel City of Girls there's a a love story that comes at the very end of the book that's referred to through the first maybe four fifths of the book um but it doesn't appear until the very end of the book and I had that entire book mapped out like so planned, but I didn't know what was what that love story was actually about. And I left it to them.

22:32

Like by the time they showed up on the page and met each other, I trusted them. I was like, "What do you guys want to do? What's your what's your deal with each other? You're the whole this whole love story is the subject of this whole book. What is it? What are you to each other?" Um because I don't know. And then I just let them take the book and and I let them I let them tell it, you know. Um and they surprised me. I mean, I learned a little bit of that from a friend of mine who is a romance novelist. And I had a in my novel, The Signature of All Things, there's a character who's it's 19th century woman in a very repressive culture who discovers a cache of erotica and pornography and has this big sexual awakening. And I was writing about that and I got to that point and I'd known that that was going to be a plot point in the book and then I was like, "Oh, do I want to go in this direction?" Like,

23:24

"Do I want her?" Like, I felt like I'm like, "Is this going to be embarrassing for her?" Like, is this and and I went and talked to my friend who writes romance novels, who writes a lot of sex scenes, and I was like, "How do you how do you do like how do you do that? How do you know how far to go? Where do you pull back?" And she said, "It's really simple. you just create the characters, put them together, and then let them do what they would do if they were allowed to. And that made so much sense to me and I can do that. I'm in a little bit of a too much of a control freak to give them the whole book, but I'm enough.

24:01

But I'm open enough to be like, "Okay, over to you guys. Who how are you going to how are you going to do this?"

Why she outlined 70 pages 24:07
24:07

>> Was that the book where you wrote the 70page synopsis before writing the book? >> Yeah. >> Okay. And why'd you do that? because I had so much going on in that book that I needed it. So, it was like my guideposts. Um, and I and it was just like then this happens, then this happens, then this happens. But that book takes place over 150 years and has multiple generations of characters and lots of plot twists and turns and lots of people involved. So, I needed that map and I needed to know that I knew where I was going. like I knew the last line of that book. Um, and I needed to know how to get there. Um, so that's probably the most controlled I've ever been um, in terms of of writing. But, but then again, once I started writing that book, I I wasn't there. I think of it the metaphor I always use about preparation is like if you're going to paint your house, the first time I ever did I started big open space of wall and

25:06

then instantly hit obstacles. You know, it's like, >> "Oh, there's window panes here. Oh, there's furniture in the way. Oh, these radiators are filthy." Like, this like, "Oh, there's a big hole in the wall here." Like, I you know, and then back it up. Start over. Back it up. So then, if you're an expert in house painter, you're going to take everything out of the room. You're going to tape every single thing up. You're going to sand down all the rust spots. You're going to clean it. you're going to like every single precision thing so that when it's time to paint, you just get that big roller brush and you're like, "Let's go." You know, and that's probably the part that's the most fun, I would imagine, for the house painter.

25:45

>> But the preparation is why you can do that fast. That also escalated my not non-negotiative. Is it like I feel a tremendous sense of meaning? Oh, wow. This is so much fun. Uh, whoa, this is exciting. Like, what is the thing that you're feeling? >> I feel um the mo that I resemble myself the most that that if it's okay to say this, but like when I'm alone and when I'm writing and when I'm in writing is when I feel like I'm least full of [laughter] And I think that's also like the ego has left the room like that that there's no persona and it feels of God.

26:35

It just and it feels very um beautiful.

Choose your first reader 26:40
26:40

>> I would imagine that then there's because you were talking earlier about the critics's got to >> got to leave the room. Should you invite the critic back in during the editing phase and maybe there's a benefit to that or it's like no, keep that away. >> Criticism has never helped me be a better writer. Trying to think if that's true. That's true. It's never helped me be a a better writer. One thing that I often warn people about is is to be very very very very careful of who you show your work to, who you bring your ideas to.

27:16

um we have there might be a tendency to want to go to that person in your life who advertises themselves as um brutally honest. I wouldn't advise that for the first reader um because well first of all my experience with anybody ever who advertises themselves on as being brutally honest is that they can't wait to brutalize him. I mean, they used the word brutal right there in their own description of themselves, right? And so, um, there are people there have been people in my life who I'm like, you don't get to see this book until it's in galls. And I think Bnee Brown has has actually kind of codified like what you need in your first readers and in your creative team. And it's like they have to meet a certain standard. And it's first and foremost is they have to want you to succeed. So, it can't be a competitor, >> right? It can't be somebody who's jealous. It can't be somebody like they have to really want what's good for you.

28:16

Also, it has to be somebody whose taste you trust and somebody who knows how to be tender when they deliver unfortunate news. They have to know how to speak about what isn't working in a way that doesn't go into your system as defeating. Um, and so I have a few people like that in my life. Um, but you want to go with the you want to go with supportive people at the beginning. It's hard enough, you know what I mean? Like it's hard enough doing this if you've got the voices of brutally honest critics in your head.

28:54

It's not going to work for me. >> Right? And I think crucially supportive isn't, oh, they're not just going to be Vincent validation over here. You know, they're they can't just say everything you do is perfect, perfect, perfect. They have to be supportive in the sense of like they want what's best for you and are willing to tell you something gently, tenderly now so that it leads to the best end product. >> Respectfully, I slightly disagree.

29:19

Great. >> I think the very first person who reads it should just be the person who's incredibly supportive. >> Really? [laughter] >> Yeah. >> That's surprising. >> That's what I need. Yeah. because it's so scary >> and it's so vulnerable and I don't have any skin on when I've written something and everything is so vulnerable in the first draft. It's embarrassing to show to somebody like what are you going to see in me that I don't want you to necessar like I think tender velvet gloves for the first read and I have a friend who is that person for me and she's always my first read and she always says it's perfect you're perfect.

29:56

>> [clears throat and laughter] >> And that gives me the fortification that I need. But what I'll do is I'll read it to her and then I'll feel energetically where she's more excited and where she's just politely and lovingly listening to me because she's my friend. And I'm like, "Oh, your your energy is dipping. So, this isn't working. I'll find I'll hear it." She's not going to say it. She's like, "No, it's good." I'm like, "No, I can tell 100% by your voice that it isn't." you know, but but I could see where you're where where you got lit up, >> you know, and where that light dimmed.

30:31

>> But just be careful. Be careful. Be I mean, I've seen people be absolutely wrecked by criticism, you know, and it's one of the reasons I didn't go get an MFA because I took a couple writing classes in college and I was like, this is a dangerous room, you know, like what I mean, I don't know if I would have been able to articulate it. I think I actually was able at the age of 20 to articulate it, but I was like, you could really get up in here, you know, like people say things very casually and very confidently and there's cruelty and there's there's clicks and there's exclusion and there's diminishment. There's all kinds of like lunchroom politics here. And I kind of also knew that I didn't want to find my voice in a room filled with other young people trying to find their voice. Like I just had to go out and find it someplace else.

Working at a bar vs grad school 31:26
31:26

>> I think the story of your 20s is cool. It's like you're trying all these different jobs. You're doing this thing, did this thing, this thing, this thing. And I want to hear about the bar. It really seems like you took a lot from your time at the bar, working three or four nights a week or whatever it was. I want to hear about that. Well, first of all, I was realizing what a privileged moment it was to be in New York because I was there like when I came back from college. I went to NYU and then I went out in the world and did some exploring.

31:49

Came back to New York and no one in the history of ever moved to New York and thought that New York was affordable, but it always was more affordable in the past than it is now. Like I remember in the 90s being like, "Oh, those people had it so good in the 80s and in the 70s and now I'm like I had a apartment for, you know, $900, you know, like I could work pick up like four shifts at a bar and pay for my life, you know, and be an artist." And of course, no one ever knows they're living in a golden age, but I was I can now clearly see that I was living in a golden age. Um, but I was working and then I had worked at a diner in Philadelphia that served the same purpose, which was just for a writer, learning about voice and story and narrative, bartending and being a waitress was amazing because I was encountering hundreds of people a week and their dramas and their stories and their voices and their expressions and

32:46

their accents and their like so many characters. Like I was just sitting there. It was like a reverse stage. like I was behind the bar and then this theatrical performance was going on all night in front of me and I was getting paid and it wasn't just any bar. It was the Coyote Ugly Saloon, you know, [laughter] it was the bar that they made the movie Coyote Ugly out of based on an article I wrote about that bar. But but it was wild, you know. It was humanity unhinged. It was people drunk and open.

33:13

It was people crying. It was people fighting. It was it was so it was so good. Um, and and I remember thinking at the time like, thank God I'm not sitting in a graduate school classroom right now and this is my graduate school classroom, you know, like this is and the diner is and the ranch where I worked and all these places. This is school. This is like school. >> Tell me more about picking up on voice. Well, I I knew that I had I mean I grew up in a family with big characters, but also like we were um my my family are weird people. So there was eccentricity within my family, but like I from a very young age felt restless and a desire to know things beyond what was available to me.

34:04

And I felt that that world was too small. Um and and I was very hungry to know the world. And I also knew that I wanted to be a writer and I was like everybody says write what you know. I don't know anything like I don't know anything except like my field hockey team you know like I don't know I don't have anything here and that's why I went to school in New York and it's why I became a traveler was to expose myself to as much different kinds of humanity as possible.

34:32

>> To your point about voice you just cannot fathom the range of human character >> Yeah. and personality. >> Yeah. >> So vast. >> Yeah. Go outside and talk to people, you know. Um like that's what I did through my whole 20s. And then when I started working as a journalist, my beat kind of became eccentric, weirdo, outcast, um subculture, outside of culture people. That's what I was the most interested in. And my very favorite thing was to go into a culture, a subculture that was so siloed that it didn't even know it was a subculture. It just thought it was that everything was like that, [laughter] >> you know, and it's like, oh no, the world is not at all like what your world is.

35:21

>> Would this be like the Amish? >> Um, that would be I alo I think they're pretty aware of how how how separate they are. I would say like going to Maine and working on lobster fishing boats and being in these small island communities in Maine where the stakes of these interpersonal conflicts that people have in these tiny little remote islands where they're all intermaring and they're all interwaring, you know, because there's like territory wars and battles and and um and a lot of drinking and a lot of violence and a lot of rough living. you're going out in fishing boats off the main coast in November.

35:59

It's tough, you know, like and and their world is so contained. When I was there, their world was almost like frozen in amber. It was like these brigadeoom worlds that I would go into. And I don't know, I I'm assuming that still exists, but I think the world has become more homogenized. But certainly when I was in my 20s, you could still go to places where they were just doing what they were doing and they had no idea what anybody else outside of the world was doing and the world outside of their community or their or their subculture or there was a mystery to them. They'd never been there. [laughter] They like occasionally a visitor would drift in from the world. um they didn't quite know what the world was, you know, like it was it was wild. And that was my favorite thing would be to disappear down into those wormholes with with those people.

What she learned from Dickens 36:54
36:54

>> You were talking about voice earlier and how about reading novels from say the 18th 19th century and learning about the voice of people like George Elliot and Dickens and other writers of that time. >> Yeah. So that's when I when I I started by writing short stories. I read a lot of short stories. The first thing I got published was a short story and I had short stories written. And when I finally met with an agent, she said, "You know, it's hard to sell a collection of short stories, but if you've got a novel proposal, then we can sell a twobook deal." And I didn't know how to write a novel. I only knew how to write things that were like 10 or 15 pages long. So that's when I started studying Dickens because I think he was the greatest novelist. Um, and he of course was the greatest character writer ever. Um, and his characters are all so very different and they you never have any trouble

37:48

remembering who somebody is. So you can read Blee House and there's a character who shows up on page 10 and doesn't show up again on page until page 380 and when they show up, you remember exactly who they are. >> And do you have a sense of what he's doing in order to achieve that? He's making them so distinctive that there's no mistaking whatsoever who anybody is, which is a gripe that I have with when people try to get me to read their big giant serieses of science fiction novels or high fantasy, you know, worlds world building. So I'm like, wait, who wait who which which alien general is this? Like which one?

38:26

you know, like I've I'm 10 pages in, I can't remember who's who's talking, right? Like, and and and I think that my service to the writer reader is that you should never I want to make sure that never once in a book of mine that you read are you lost. And Dickens had that too, where once when he began to tell a story, the feeling I always have as his reader is, I'm in such good hands. He knows exactly what he's doing. He knows exactly where he's going. I just get to go on this ride, you know? I don't have to labor to understand what's happening.

38:58

And that's why he was a populist novel and a popular novelist and and a populist novelist as well. And I am a populist writer. Like I don't want to write things that exclude people. I want to write things that if you can read the English language, you can read it. And I don't want anybody be like, who's this? You know? Um so he just he just distinguished each one of those characters so precisely that there's no mistaking who they are. For me as a novelist, the hardest part is the plot.

39:26

The first thing I always have is like where like where in time and where in space do I want this book set? Like setting comes to me first and and and era like like City of Girls. I was like, I want to write a book set in New York City in the 1940s. So, I have that. And then the next question is who like who who is it about? who's in who's in this New York City in the 1940s novel? And then the last thing is like what are they doing? [laughter] What is the point of this book? What is this about? Like where what are they up to? And that's hardest for me. Um but I find that as I do my research and build the characters and build the setting, then the plot starts to come. But I'm not great at advising people on how to create a plot because I I struggle with

How she does research 40:20
40:20

it. When I talked to Lee Child, he basically said that whenever you establish a setting, you're just eliminating so much. So if you get the winter in Maine versus the summer in Arizona, >> oh, you're >> the range of possibilities is already so it's so different. >> Great. That's so great. >> And he equated to like a key in music. Like every song is in a specific key. >> B flat. >> Here we go. >> That is so good. And then if it's New York City in the 1940s, then what I would do is go learn what's the key, right? So that means I'm going to like for a year or two all I did was read novels that were written in the 1940s by lots of times by people who aren't being read anymore. Like I read a bunch of John O'Hara and I read like you know I got a bunch of old New Yorkers and like read what were they saying in Talk of the Town. How were they speaking? and and and also letters like for me as a novelist like reading

41:14

people's letters is how you find out how people actually spoke then because especially their casual letters um because in the days before telegraphs and telephones like letters was the only means of communication and a lot of times there were like three mail deliveries a day because it's like you're sending an email and you're getting the response back by noon and then you're sending it in the next mail and you're getting the response back that evening. If you lived in London, you'd put a a post something, you know, and it you'd get it that afternoon, you'd get a letter back and then so so you're like that's how you're talking across town and you don't have time when you're writing those letters to like be very formal and artistic. You're chatting. So that's how you hear people's voices. Like that's how I gathered the key that these voices would be in is like this is what they probably this is the closest thing to what they

42:03

probably actually sound. M >> well we're talking about the prep and you're looking at voice. How does all this research accumulate before you actually start the work of writing? >> Okay. So I have a very um elaborate very analog system of research and it was taught to me in 1983 in my western civilization social studies class by one Mr. Kisco at Lichfield High School and I have taken that system. >> Shout out Mr. Kiskco.

42:32

>> Shout out Mr. K. Tough but fair teacher. >> Best ones. The best ones. He was good. Also so funny. I'm just gonna throw out a Mr. Krisco line. He one time was talking about William Penn and he said he was a good Quaker and a good soldier which meant that he was a better soldier than he was a Quaker. So funny. >> Banger. >> Banger. Right. Anyway, he taught us this system. You get a shoe box. You get index cards. You divide it into categories and subjects of what you're researching. You read books. You find something in the book that you want to put. You put one, you take something out of the book you're reading, you write it on the index card. At the bottom of the index card, you have a key. Each book is a key number. A, B, C, D, and the page number. So, it says A14. So, that's the book you used. So, when you go to do your footnotes, you can quote this thing and you can say what book you used. And

43:25

then you and then you put that card in the subject where it should like in the file subject of like where it should be. I wrote a term paper about the Oracle of Deli. So it's like the history and like the poetry of it and the blah blah blah. So each one has its own little section. So I took that idea that index cards and the thing I love about it is because all the information is on each card, you can shuffle them up and put them wherever.

43:49

But what I've done over time is like as I'm doing research and I find something that I think would be good for a novel for a character, I'll like take it and I'll write the character's name on the top of the index card. So Viven, right? And then I'll put some sort of a line or a turn phrase that she would use or something about some kind of clothing she would wear and I'll put it in the packet in the shoe box that says Vivian. And then I'll find something that's about what kind of cars people would have been driving. I'll put it in the section that says cars, you know, post World War II. Okay, here like theater stuff, theater details, architectural details of theaters, playwriting ideas for the playright in the in the novel. So shoe boxes fill, but they're orderly with like each character. And then when it's time to write, you just reach in. You're like writing Vivian, this character. and you

44:42

reach in and you pull out and you've got all this data on her and you can just begin to build her character on the page and you've got all these lines and terms of phrase and costume and hair and descriptions and it's all there. There's a whole box of Vivian and you can move the cards around and move the plots around kind of visibly. So, I like it. The danger of it, of course, is like your house catches on fire, [laughter] everything's gone. And I once left a shoe box filled with stuff on a Metro North train. Um, that was one of the worst days of my life. Did >> you ever get it back?

45:12

>> I did get it back, but it was shook me so much. I almost feel like I've never recovered from it because it was like two years of work. >> Um, but that's but now what I do is I every few weeks I take those two boxes and I photocopy them so that I've got extra copies someplace else. Mhm. >> So, if we were writing like about 1880 Mississippi and I was like, "All right, let's write a short story." >> Mhm. >> And let's say we had a week to do the research, like where do I begin?

45:42

>> Um, with the weirdest thing that's out of print. So, go to an actual library. Like, don't go to Don't go to online and find things that are not online. Go to Mississippi first. >> Go roll around in it. >> Yeah. you know, like go smell it and feel it and taste it and get your body there. >> Um, that's essential. Like you've got to go to the place >> and then go to real things, you know, like go to the historical society in the smallest town in Mississippi that you can go to and be like, "What have you got here?" And um and and that's your treasure trove. Go find just ephemera that's not been cataloged except for sitting in boxes in the back of some building. Um, and then go talk to old people. Um, and gather stories. A week's a short amount of time. How long is this story?

46:39

>> You need a year, kid. >> You need a year, kid. >> Give yourself a little more time. >> It's your problem. You're trying to do it. And then and then what you need is to make friends with somebody from Mississippi and ask them to read it and be like, where have I embarrassed myself here? >> I wrote this novel called Snow Forest that was set in Russia. And when I was done with it, you know, I found a bunch of Russians and I was like, and a bunch of Russians of different ages and you know, because what a lot of the people in that book are are geologists. So I was like I'm like I got to find some Russian geologists. And I did. and um and I found um Russian writers and I you know and I and I just gave them a manuscript and I was like imagine imagine that you're a Russian writer and you came and you're writing a novel set in America in the 1930s and you're only doing it from what you've researched and you've got imagine

47:30

that you've got your characters at a baseball game and they're watching a baseball game and they're eating omelets and any American would be like what Right. It's a hot dog. It's a hot dog. >> You got so many details right here, but like why is there an omelet? So I was like, please find the omelets in this book. Like any place where it's like anybody who knows anything would be like, "No, no, no, no, no, no, no. That's that's not how it would be.

47:57

That's not what they would be eating. It's not what they would be wearing. It's not how they would be speaking." And and that's where at this point I'm I'm past my vulnerable first draft stage. So, at this point, I'm like, do give it to me. I would much rather be embarrassed in front of you than be embarrassed in the New York Times. So, please tell me where I've got it wrong. >> What makes for really fruitful travel?

48:20

Like, what are the things when you're setting off that you're keeping your mind if you want to fuel a book or something that you're working on? Um, if I'm going to a place to do research, then I've planned it before I got there and um, and I'm making a bunch of stops because there's certain things that I need to see. So like with the signature ball things I went to Tahiti and there was a bunch of pre-ressearch where it's like who can connect like for me it's a lot of like who knows someone [laughter] like who knows someone who knows anybody who's got a farm in Tahiti like who knows somebody who know like just start asking around because the main thing is like we have you have to find the person who feels like the key there's like a person you're going to meet and they are the key to that story and they're going to open up that whole world for you and if you don't have them and they're not

49:11

opening up that door, you're not getting into that world. Um, so a lot of it is just asking and asking and asking. Um, and then like I had a list of like I need to see a cave. Like I knew there was going to be a scene in a cave. It's like I need to go see a Tahesian cave. I need to see a a waterfall. I need to see like what it feels like to climb a cliff next to a waterfall. my need to go to this particular beach where Captain Cook first landed and see that nowhere in all my research that I did when I was sitting in my house in New Jersey did it say that that was a black sand beach. Um I didn't I couldn't have known that unless I went there. So in my mind I'm picturing a white beach, right? And I go there I'm like, "Oh, it's a black sand beach. Oh, it's a black sand beach with weird like it's a weird bay. It's not really waves." Okay, so like there's no waves on this beach. There's there's

50:04

lots of holes and lots of crabs. That's cool. I'm going to put that in the book. Like, so I start with like destinations of what I have to go find out and go see. And then I'm open to be surprised by things that I couldn't have known until I got there.

Should you pursue greatness? 50:18
50:18

>> What is your sense of your identity as a writer? And do you have like this pursuit of greatness or is it just like something else that has to do with the vow that you made? >> I've definitely pursued greatness. like I I've wanted to be a great writer and and I've tried to be a great writer and it's meant a lot to me when I when people say this is a great book like that's that's been important to me and when I go back to that vow that I made when I was 16 it's like I can mess up everything else in my house [laughter] you know but like relationships can end friendships can end family dramas can and catastrophes can occur externally and internally like there's always been this sense that I've had that like and you're a writer and you have that and I think that's probably also why it felt of God to me from a very early age that it's like here's where you can here's where you can know who you are

51:23

and here's where you can know that you know how to do this. After my partner Rya died, six weeks after she died, I started writing the novel City of Girls. I started I'd been working on it, but I started really working on it because I felt in my grief that I was in such um grief can feel like a head injury. That's how I've experienced grief. It's very disorienting. Like there is no ground under your feet. And so I turned to the thing that it's like, okay, I know that if I that I can touch ground here. I know how to get my shoe boxes. I know how to get my index cards. I know how to do my research. I know how to create my outline. And I know how to write a novel. And and in the writing of that novel, I remember who I am. Like, all right, I'm the person who knows how to do this. Um because in the aftermath of that great loss and that g great grief, I'm like I'm so unmed, I don't know who I am and I don't know where I

52:24

am and I don't know what I am. Now I will say as anchoring as that has been for so many decades of my life, I do think it's a teeny tiny bit dangerous to link at this point. And I'm at a point in my life where I would think it's slightly suboptimal to identify yourself as anything that can be lost and everything can be lost. Um, so I'm, you know, clinging to the idea of being a writer like it's a lifeboat has gotten me through some storms. But I think as I become more mature and more spiritually cognizant, it's like, well, you might have to let go of that lifeboat too at some point.

53:07

There might be no ground under your feet, right? Can you relax into sort of not having an identity at all? >> I guess it'd be fair to call grief a difficult emotion. It's certainly not an easy emotion. Um, but when you're feeling a difficult emotion like grief, do you first of all try to cope with it through your writing? And then when you're feeling that, do you feel like you want to press deeper into grief and basically bring grief into your work or do you feel like no, I kind of want to go to the opposite?

53:41

>> Well, I definitely want to you use because I use writing for different things. So, I have personal writing, too. like I journal and I like that's mine, you know. Um, and so that's not anything that belongs to the world. So there is where I can I have an I have a note on my desk that I heard somebody say in a 12step meeting, remain visible to yourself, you know, and so writing in a journal and is a place where I am able to remain visible to myself. um if I'm not careful, I can become invisible to myself through the torments of the world where I can get lost, right? So, I think what I how I interpret remain visible to yourself is kind of like stay in touch with yourself, you know, be able to feel, be able to to know what what's needed. Um, but after Rhea died, and that's the worst grief I've ever gone through, I wrote the most upbeat, scintillating, champagne happy book of my life. Um, because I needed to

54:45

get off of the grief. And so, although the book City of Girls contains reference to grief um, and loss, I went I went in the very very opposite direction. Like, I I was like, I've got to write something fun. like I [laughter] have not I am in so much darkness and that's one way to do it you know and then seven years after she died I wrote the book about I I was able to then have the fortitude to go back and revisit that grief and actually write about it in a in a very open way but I couldn't have done that three months after she died um you get to be many different things um and life has many chapters And that's true both of your personal life and your family life and your professional life and your creative life and your spiritual life. My friend Rob Bell sometimes somebody will bring something up about his life and he'll say, "Oh, that was like seven Robs ago."

55:46

>> Uhhuh. Uhhuh. >> Like they're like, "Oh, are you still into" and he's like, "Oh, yeah, that was like seven." There's been like seven iterations of me since then. And not that you throw any of those parts away. I remember reading an interview with Bruce Springsteen once where he was like, "Everyone I've ever been, I still am. They're all in the van." Like, we're all driving together in the minivan. They're all still there. Every age of me, every every thing I was ever into.

56:14

Um, and I'm evolving at the same time while still containing all of them.

The importance of fun in writing 56:18
56:19

>> Yeah. What's the role of levity, playfulness in your creativity, in your right? It's key. You know, it's my friend John Hodgejman always makes fun of me and by extension my friend Margaret, they both quote this a lot that years ago, John and I were having a deep philosophical question about like why do we write, why do we do this and and he was like, you know, I'm struggling to try to find my voice and this and that. And he's like, why do you write? And I said, because it's fun, easy, and profitable. [laughter] and and Margaret, my friend Margaret and her kids quote that all the time whenever they have a writing assignment.

57:03

They're like, "Don't forget writing is fun, easy, and profitable." Um, you know, and and in a weird way for me, it's true. Meaning that even when it's not fun, it's still more fun for me than almost anything else. Um, I'd rather have the not fun of being in a writing project than have what other people might consider fun. Many other people would not consider it fun to spend three years studying >> next century moss or you know or whatever, but like to me that's the most fun you can have. So, and easy >> again it is in that I know how to work through the hardness of it.

57:49

You know what I mean? So, like that's why I what I mean when I say it's easy is that like here's a puzzle, here's a challenge, and for some reason I if I work hard enough and stay with this, I can solve this puzzle. And it's a very hard puzzle, but I have a gift for solving that puzzle. And and profitable is like there's no other way I would rather make a living. [laughter] >> And I've and that that model has changed in the 35 years that I've been a published writer. Like there were ways I used to make a living that don't even exist anymore.

58:20

>> Like what? >> Um writing for big money for big magazines. >> It's gone, you know? Like that world is gone. Some of those magazines still exist, but like when was the last time you went to a, you know, a magazine rack and bought like a big fat September issue of GQ magazine and read the 50 articles that were in there that were each 9,000 words long. You know, like it's gone. Like that's how I made a living for the for a good four years of my life. And that's no longer available.

58:48

But Substack exists now, >> right? >> And that didn't exist. >> 200,000 subscribers. Congratulations. [laughter] >> You know, >> I was like, man, >> there's other ways like, you know, like it's weird. It's like, you know, nobody ever said go into this to make a living and yet

Has publishing gotten harder? 59:06
59:05

made a living. >> How much do you think about the business of writing? >> I've been thinking about it a lot lately because it feels like it's harder than it used to be. It feels like it's less easy, less fun, less profitable [laughter] than it's ever been. And I've been doing it since like 1994, but it feels it feels like a lot of people aren't having fun doing this anymore. It's harder for the the publishers to figure out how to get the attention of a distracted world to let them know that a book exists. Um, it's harder.

59:40

I think fewer people are making most of the money and it's harder to get a piece of that I think than it was. I mean it was never easy. It was always unfair. Um but I think it feels less easy and more unfair now. Um you have to like almost every field I am aware of at this point in latestage capitalism you have to work harder to get less. Um, so I have been thinking about it a lot and I've been talking about it a lot with people who are in publishing in various levels and being like, are you having fun?

1:00:17

[laughter] Are you enjoying this? Are you enjoying this anymore? Do you want to keep doing this? Like, is this still working? I don't know. We none of Nobody seems to have the answer, but everyone seems to be feeling like it's harder. Hm. And what are the talking me more about those those those conversations like what are the fault lines of conversation and why is it that people aren't having so much fun? Is it a fear? Is it just feel like you have to push harder now? I think people's attention has been so hijacked and I think the distraction industry has become so huge um that like people will say to me like I love you like people on the street will stop and be like I love you. Your work has changed my life. Big Magic made me into an artist or Eat Pray Love got me through my divorce. You are the most important writer in my life. And they have no idea that I've written three books in the last 10 years. They're

1:01:21

like, "Do you think you'll ever write another book?" And I'm like, "Do you mean the book that I um published this year that I did a 4monl long eight hour day publicity campaign for that you didn't hear about and you follow me on social media [laughter] and you missed it?" You know what I mean? like they're not seeing it. I think it's an interesting moment because nobody knows what to do about that. And I think like an evolutionary bottleneck when you reach this sort of moment of crisis where the old thing doesn't work anymore and we don't know what the new thing is yet. It's a moment that's filled with opportunity for somebody who might have a new idea. Um, that person is in need, [laughter] but I'm watching. The world is changing and moving so quickly right now. I don't know what that thing will be. Um, but we talk about that a lot and we talk about how careful people feel they have to be

1:02:13

um to not be cancelled. Um, and to not um inadvertently step into controversy. It's much much easier to find yourself in a a massive controversy than I think it used to be. Um, I don't think everything about that is bad. I think you should be careful um about some of the things that you say and write. But I do know that my dear friends in the publishing industry who work especially in the publicity realm and the marketing realm spend a lot of their lives putting fires out. And I don't know how much fun they're having doing that. Um you know just like oh my god we didn't see this coming. Like we didn't see that one line would be taken out of this book put into an early review jumped on by the internet and now this person's got death threats at their apartment. you know, like um I mean this is the the world in which people are putting work out and it's fraugh um and it's hard and my heart goes out to everybody involved and

1:03:11

I don't know what the future will hold for that. I just know that if I it's maybe not my place to know um it's my place I think to honor the vow that 16-year-old made and to keep creating things because it was hard to it was hard to do in 1984 and it was hard to do in 1994 and it was hard to do in 2004. Sorry, it was hard. You know, it's hard. June in 2014, like never in the history of ever did somebody say, "Go into the arts. It's easy, you know." Um, but yet we do it. Oh, and now there's AI, you know, and and people have I've know people who are very they're like within a year AI is going to be able to write a better novel than I can. And I'm like, there's already humans who can write better novels than I can. George Saunders writes better novels than I can. That doesn't stop me from writing novels. Um, I don't write novels to write the best novel. I write novels to write the best novel I can write. Of

1:04:05

course, a robot will be able to beat me at that. Humans can already beat me at that. And yet, here we are with the creative urge. What are we going to do? Not create.

Herzog's advice to artists 1:04:14
1:04:14

>> You were talking about the challenges of making money as an artist. And many years ago, you wrote this awesome piece called Thoughts on Writing. And in it, you pulled this Warner Hersaw quote. And I want to read the whole thing. Quit your complaining. It's not the world's fault that you wanted to be an artist. It's not the world's job to enjoy the films you make. And it's certainly not the world's obligation to pay for your dreams. Nobody wants to hear it. Steal a camera if you have to, but stop whining and get back to work.

1:04:41

>> He said that wrote that to a friend of mine who was a a >> So this was letter to your friend. >> Yeah. This friend of mine was a an aspiring filmmaker in in Rome, Italian guy, and he wrote him a letter where he just basically cried his heart out about how like how hard it is now. I mean, everyone, I've been doing this a long time. In every decade that I have lived and made art, what I have heard is it's really hard now to make art. This is a hard time in which to make art. This is a hard climate in which to make art. So, I've been hearing that like constantly now for like almost 40 years.

1:05:17

>> So, >> it's starting to look like maybe it's just never a good time [laughter] because we weren't walking around in the 80s being like, "This is a great time to be making art." you know, like artists have always complained. So, this guy that I knew wrote this in the '9s to Verner House and he's like, there's no there's no funding, there's no, you know, like there's no grants, there's no like basically like no one's taking care of me. And Ber House wrote him that letter which he had framed in his in his office which was like, stop whining and steal, oh, you can't afford to buy a camera, steal one. Um, and he did.

1:05:55

Bernard Hersog stole a camera from film school when he was in film school because he couldn't afford to keep going. So, he walked out of there with a camera and took it and just went out into the world and did it. So, there's always going to be reasons not to do this. There's always going to be reasons that it's too difficult, too expensive, um, and yet always there will be people doing it.

What to do when burned out 1:06:14
1:06:14

>> When you feel like your creative well is dry, >> what do you do? >> I stop. Um, I just stopped for six months. I just took a six-month sbatical for the first time in my life and did nothing. And the rule of my sbatical was no writing. Um, and a friend of mine who knows me really well was like, "Lol, you're going to come out of that with a novel." And I'm like, "No, I'm actually not. Like, I'm broken and I need to stop. And until it feels fun again, I'm not going to do it." And I feel just now like little tiny sprigs of green starting to come up in my imagination.

1:06:50

Um, but I was burned out and and so I stopped. And I think stopping is really important. It's another to go back to the agricultural metaphor is there are fields that you you cannot overwork those fields. You have to have seasons where they layow or else you're going to just destroy the soil and never be able to create anything again. So stop and do nothing or do something completely different than what you do. >> What did you do?

1:07:14

>> I rested. Um, and it's more about what I didn't do. I didn't get on a plane for 6 months. Um, which is wild for me. I spent a lot of time with my dog. I spent a lot of time walking. I healed an a physical injury that I had. Um, I organized my house. I got rid of a lot of things. And I spent a lot of time with my friends, having coffee and talking. Just a lot of time. Like I when I'm working on a book, I don't have time for anybody. So, it was really special for me to be like, "Let's go out. let's go out again tomorrow. Like, let's hang out again tomorrow. Let's hang out again Saturday. I got time. I got nothing on the agenda for four months, you know?

1:07:54

And um and I needed that very very

Elizabeth's writing inspirations 1:07:57
1:07:57

>> Yeah. I want to go through some of your uh inspirations. And I want to kind of like pop through them pretty fast um and hear how these different writers shaped your work, inspired you, moved you. Let's start with George Elliott. >> Oh, [laughter] George Elliot. um fearless, her fearlessness as a writer, her um as a woman, you know, like to God, she was so self-confident, you know, in in an era where that was not encouraged. She knew she had the goods.

1:08:35

She knew she had the goods and she knew she could not publish under a woman's name. And and she was right in both regards. She's like, "I'm a boss and I've here I am. My name is George Elliot." Um, she brilliant and cunning, you know, like it's a foxy move. Like I don't mean sexy foxy. I mean like cunning like a fox to change your name so that you can be published. It's Foxy. The way when Wittmann wrote Song of Myself, he wrote publicity for it and published it in all the local newspapers and said, "Walt Whitman has just published a book and it's the greatest talent of of of our age."

1:09:13

>> Saunders, >> I was about to say there's nobody better, both as a human being and as a writer. I love a genius who's not an Um, and I love it because it proves all the geniuses wrong when they're like, I get to be and have to be an because I'm a genius. And it's like, oh, let's spend some time with George Savers, who's who's writing circles around everyone, who's better than anyone in the game and is a kind, decent humanitarian, who always has time for others, and has a Buddhist practice in which he works very hard to become an even better human being. So, uh, no, I reject your assholery as a side effect of your genius. You're a genius and separately, you're an >> right? You are not an because you're a genius. Like you're using that as a as like a cover for just treating people terribly.

1:10:09

>> Uh Hillary Mantel. >> God, when she blasted Wolf Hall out and I've read all of her books and talk about an artist who deserves a retrospective, every one of her books is so completely different. And then I went, you know, I found out about her as most people did with Wolf Hall. And then I went back and I was like, what? you also wrote this and you also wrote this and they're not at all like these other things that you've written. How she wrote a historical novel that was also a literary masterpiece and also feels incredibly modern without once being anacronistic is a magic trick unsurpassed. Um, so that's in recent years I would say like in the last 15 years I would say Wolf Hall is the book I've read the most often. Like I read it, I study it like it's the Torah. like I I'm like, "How did you do? How in the world did you do this?" Um, she's she was amazing.

1:11:01

>> What have you found about her writing that you want to bring into yours? >> I'm trying to figure out how to explain this, but there's like a kind of historical novel where like from the first page I'm like, "No, it isn't." I'm like, "No, you didn't. No, you're not. I'm just I'm I'm not buying it." you know, where it's like there's almost like there's too many twe historical novel details where it's like somebody did a lot of research and now we must all pay, you know, like like he he woke and and and carefully lit the the oil lamp, you know, beside his bed using the whatever like and I'm like, "No, you no, you're trying to show up.

1:11:39

>> No, no, you didn't. And he this person's not real and this doesn't exist." And and there was something about how vivid and present her character felt, maybe because she was sitting there interviewing Thomas Cromwell all day and he was there physically in the room. Um that I don't doubt for a minute that that that's exactly what went down. Um and and it feels of this moment.

Get out of the classroom 1:12:06
1:12:05

>> Yeah. >> I was pretty struck by these words from the poet Jack Gilbert. We must risk delight. We can do without pleasure, but not delight, not enjoyment. We must have the stubbornness to accept our gladness in the ruthless furnace of this world. >> I have the in white ink, stubborn gladness tattooed on my >> Oh, wow. >> Yeah. And you can't see cuz it's it's not quite the right light, but there it says it. Stubborn gladness.

1:12:32

>> So, I came across that in my prep. I was like, that rocks, does it not? >> You are. Tell me like why get it tattooed? >> Because that's it. That's everything. That is everything. I mean, he's not denying. It's from a a poem of his called A Brief for the Defense. And the defense that he's defending is the defense of enjoying the world even as it's on fire and you might be, you know, um he's not denying the reality of suffering. He's saying and also we must have the stubbornness to enjoy our gladness and the ruthless furnace of the world. Like why would the summer mornings would be made so fine if they're not to be enjoyed? You know, like there's there's so much that's also going on in in the madness, in the inferno, in the cauldron, in the horrible diagnosis, in the like in the addiction, and like there's also miracle upon miracle upon miracle unfolding like an opening hand in front of us at all times. And and when I'm in

1:13:35

deep connection with what I call God, what I'm often being told is what a pity it would be if no one saw this, you know, like could you slow down today and actually see creation because it's pretty incredible and worth spending a minute with, you know, before you just become a list of things to do. Look, smell, taste, touch. when I told you when you were writing your imaginary Mississippi, roll around in it. Like, >> taste it.

1:14:04

>> Get out there and roll around in it. I I did teach I don't have an MFA, but I did teach for one semester at an MFA at the University of Tennessee where which is where I came upon Jack Edwards works. He had taught there the semester before me. But the frustration I felt with the students was I didn't want them in that room. You know, I loved them and some of them were really great writers and all of them were amazing people and I was like, please don't sit here under these fluorescent lights, you know, like please go out and roll around in the world. Go experience it, you know, even if it hurts. Please, please don't miss it.

1:14:40

>> Wonderful answer. What else did you want to tell those students? We'll end there. >> I wanted to tell them not to go into debt to become [laughter] >> Don't go into debt. >> I wanted to tell them to go get jobs. You know, like they were trying really hard to get grants, but I wanted them to get jobs. I'm like, you're going to learn so much more having a job than you're going to learn having a grant. Like, go get a job working with human beings, seeing people all day. Like, go wash dishes on a nuclear submarine.

1:15:11

[laughter] >> Like, go like go do go do go do something, you know? Like I wanted them to be doing a lot more and thinking a lot less. >> Doing more. Thinking less. >> Doing more. Thinking less. Yeah. >> Well, thank you. >> You're very [laughter] welcome. >> This was fun. >> What a delight. Thank you for inviting me. >> Of course. >> Yeah. >> Of course. >> It's been lovely. >> Come back anytime. >> Don't go into debt to become an artist.

1:15:37

[laughter] >> I'll try not to. I'll try not to. >> That's my conversation with Elizabeth Gilbert. And if you liked it, you'll also like my interviews with Richard Powers and an Lamont.