A trading card and sticker maker that held major sports league licenses.
Panini held major sports league licenses for trading cards and stickers, but it was reportedly for sale for 15 to 30 years straight, which Michael Rubin says left it selling instead of innovating. That opening let Fanatics enter, and the category grew from tens of billions of dollars to much larger. Lesson: incumbents that stop investing leave room for a challenger.
From Michael Rubin on Panini and Topps
Owners who wanted to sell stopped investing in Panini. Michael Rubin says Panini had been for sale for somewhere between 15 and 30 years. In his view that left it focused on selling rather than innovating in product, marketing or the business.
Rubin saw the same pattern at Topps, which was owned by Michael Eisner, who was taking it public through a SPAC, with owners in their 70s. He read a big category run by sellers rather than builders and entered to out-innovate them. The idea first hit him in November 2020 and Fanatics launched on January 1, 2022. His line: "you think about how to get the check."
Panini is suing Fanatics yet may gain most from category growth. Rubin says Panini is suing Fanatics over rights it used to hold itself, and still calls it possibly the biggest beneficiary of the growing category.
Fanatics set a goal of growing collectibles 10x and says it has already multiplied several times. The market was tens of billions of dollars before Fanatics entered and is now much larger. Rubin says it is Fanatics' responsibility to grow the category, and he does not tell people which cards to buy.
Panini had been for sale for 15 to 30 years, which Rubin says left it selling rather than innovating. It is suing Fanatics over rights it once held, yet Rubin says it is the biggest beneficiary of the growing category.
Owners who wanted to sell stopped investing in Panini. Michael Rubin says Panini had been for sale for somewhere between 15 and 30 years. In his view that left it focused on selling rather than innovating in product, marketing or the business.
Rubin saw the same pattern at Topps, which was owned by Michael Eisner, who was taking it public through a SPAC, with owners in their 70s. He read a big category run by sellers rather than builders and entered to out-innovate them. The idea first hit him in November 2020 and Fanatics launched on January 1, 2022. His line: "you think about how to get the check."
Panini is suing Fanatics yet may gain most from category growth. Rubin says Panini is suing Fanatics over rights it used to hold itself, and still calls it possibly the biggest beneficiary of the growing category.
Fanatics set a goal of growing collectibles 10x and says it has already multiplied several times. The market was tens of billions of dollars before Fanatics entered and is now much larger. Rubin says it is Fanatics' responsibility to grow the category, and he does not tell people which cards to buy.
ShoppingAn online retailer and platform company that also runs AWS, Kindle, Echo and Prime.
ShoppingA global athletic footwear and apparel company that began as a shoe importer called Blue Ribbon Sports.
ShoppingA discount retail chain built on everyday low prices, started in small Arkansas towns.
ShoppingA membership warehouse retailer selling a small range of bulk goods at capped markups.
ShoppingA Swedish furniture retailer selling flat-packed, low-priced home furnishings through large stores and a catalog.
ShoppingA live stream shopping marketplace where sellers auction and sell products to buyers in real time.
ShoppingThe world's largest home improvement retailer, selling tools, building materials and supplies through big-box warehouse stores.
ShoppingAn online marketplace for new and used goods, including collectibles.