All apps and companies

Company · Shopping

Fanatics Collect

A marketplace for buying and auctioning trading cards and collectibles.

fanaticscollect.comApp Store1 source2 tips

Where Fanatics Collect comes up1 episode or test

David SenraWhat It Means to Be a “Real” Entrepreneur | Michael Rubin, Fanatics
In short

Fanatics Collect, a marketplace for trading cards and collectibles, started three years ago and Michael Rubin expects $6 to $7 billion in gross sales next year. He won league rights by guaranteeing the market's cyclical peak (the NFL or MLB earned about $30 million in 2021 and about $150 million today), and made cards new with debut patches and achievement cards, lifting social reach about 100 times. Lesson: pay up for exclusive supply, then give the product fresh reasons to collect.

At a glanceFanatics won card licenses by guaranteeing leagues peak earnings
  1. 1Spot complacent ownersPanini long for sale, Topps heading to SPAC
  2. 2Guarantee peak earnings100% of current earnings, plus equity
  3. 3Sign long deals8, 10 or 20 years
  4. 4Reinvent and market cardsDebut patches, achievement cards, athlete marketing
  5. 5Business multiplies$500 million to $5.5 billion in five years

From Rubin interview on Fanatics

What was said about Fanatics Collect

1How Fanatics won the trading card licenses from complacent owners

  • Fanatics entered cards because the incumbents were waiting to sell. Panini had been for sale for 15 to 30 years and Topps was heading to a SPAC. Rubin saw owners who were not innovating and moved in.

    Rubin says many competitors were bad and uninnovative, so Fanatics reinvented the product and marketed the hobby. Its broader pattern is entering stagnant markets run by complacent owners.

  • Rubin guaranteed leagues the market's peak earnings to win long deals. In late 2020, with cards at an all-time high after COVID and a cyclical drop expected, he offered leagues and unions a minimum guarantee of 100% of current earnings, a higher royalty rate, equity in a new company, and a share of secondary sales on eBay and Whatnot.

    Deals ran 8, 10 or 20 years, and some partners asked to go as long as he would because the offer was almost too good. "Look, we'll guarantee you the high water mark of the business."

  • The bet paid off for both Fanatics and the leagues. The business went from $500 million in its first year to $5.5 billion five years later. A league like the NFL or MLB went from about $30 million in 2021 to about $150 million today.

    Rubin says the new model is better for athletes, hobby shops, breakers, collectors and sports properties.

  • The displaced rival now calls Fanatics a monopoly. The collectibles company that once called itself the global leader is suing over rights it once held. Rubin says he finds it intellectually interesting and loves the fight.

2Debut patches, achievement cards and marketing the hobby

  • Debut patches turned a player's first game into a one-of-one card. Cards had always centered on the rookie, with product innovation close to nil. Fanatics put a patch on a player's jersey for his first game and turned it into a one-of-one card, now used across baseball, the NFL, the NBA and global football.

    "Everyone wants to get the debut patch because there's only one in the world."

  • Achievement cards made career milestones into scarce collectibles. Fanatics added achievement to cards, so an MVP's jersey patch becomes a one-of-one card. An Ohtani MVP card pulled from a $1,000 box sold for $13 million.

  • Marketing the hobby and engaging athletes lifted the whole category. Fanatics marketed the hobby for the first time and got athletes personally involved. Social reach for Fanatics and Topps cards is about 100 times what it was three years ago.

3The Fanatics Collect marketplace

  • Fanatics Collect grew fast by selling to fans Fanatics already had. The marketplace started three years ago, and Rubin expects $6 to $7 billion in gross sales next year. Athletes like Karl-Anthony Towns check its auctions even in the locker room.

    It fits Fanatics' approach of adding products for the 140 million fans it already reaches.

More in Shopping

Shopping

Amazon

An online retailer and platform company that also runs AWS, Kindle, Echo and Prime.

59 sources · 108 tips
Shopping

Nike

A global athletic footwear and apparel company that began as a shoe importer called Blue Ribbon Sports.

11 sources · 47 tips
Shopping

Walmart

A discount retail chain built on everyday low prices, started in small Arkansas towns.

15 sources · 41 tips
Shopping

Costco

A membership warehouse retailer selling a small range of bulk goods at capped markups.

B12 sources · 29 tips
Shopping

IKEA

A Swedish furniture retailer selling flat-packed, low-priced home furnishings through large stores and a catalog.

3 sources · 34 tips
Shopping

Whatnot

A live stream shopping marketplace where sellers auction and sell products to buyers in real time.

4 sources · 15 tips
Shopping

Home Depot

The world's largest home improvement retailer, selling tools, building materials and supplies through big-box warehouse stores.

5 sources · 20 tips
Shopping

eBay

An online marketplace for new and used goods, including collectibles.

7 sources · 13 tips