All apps and companies

Company · Shopping

Fanatics

A sports platform selling licensed fan gear, collectibles and sports betting to fans.

fanatics.com1 source19 tips

Where Fanatics comes up1 episode or test

David SenraWhat It Means to Be a “Real” Entrepreneur | Michael Rubin, Fanatics
In short

Fanatics grew to about $14 billion in revenue by entering stagnant markets with complacent owners, like Panini and Topps in cards, and innovating the product. Collectibles went from $500 million to $5.5 billion in five years, and betting reached about 10% share in three years by extending its existing fan base. Lesson: grow the category, then cross-sell your customers into it.

At a glanceFanatics grew collectibles from zero to $5.5 billion in five years
  1. Idea strikes RubinIncumbents Panini and Topps focused on selling
  2. Leagues offered guarantees100% of current earnings as minimum
  3. Collectibles launchesTopps bought in 2022
  4. First-year revenue$500 million
  5. Category leader$5.5 billion in revenue

From Michael Rubin interview

What was said about Fanatics

1How Fanatics took over trading cards

  • Fanatics entered collectibles because the incumbents were sellers, not builders. Panini had been for sale for 15 to 30 years, and Topps, owned by Michael Eisner, was heading to a SPAC. Rubin's read was that owners focused on cashing out stop investing in product, marketing or the business.

    The idea came to him in November 2020 and Fanatics launched collectibles on January 1, 2022. On owners waiting to sell: "you think about how to get the check."

  • Rubin won league rights by guaranteeing the market's high-water mark. With cards at an all-time high in late 2020 and a cyclical drop expected, he offered leagues and unions 100% of current earnings as a minimum, a higher royalty, equity in the new company and a share of secondary sales on eBay and Whatnot. A league like the NFL or MLB went from about $30 million in 2021 to about $150 million today.

    Deals ran 8, 10 or 20 years, and some partners asked to go as long as he would because the offer seemed almost too good. Fanatics collectibles grew from $500 million in year one to $5.5 billion five years later.

  • Debut patches and achievement cards gave an old product something new. Fanatics puts a patch on a player's jersey for his first game and turns it into a one-of-one card, now used in baseball, the NFL, the NBA and global football; it does the same for achievements like an MVP season. An Ohtani MVP card pulled from a $1,000 box sold for $13 million.

    Cards had always been about the rookie and product innovation was close to nil. Marketing the hobby and getting athletes engaged pushed social reach for Fanatics and Topps cards to about 100 times what it was three years ago.

  • Rubin borrowed from the art market to make cards collectible art. He commissioned George Condo to hand paint cards of Tom Brady, LeBron James, Lewis Hamilton and Djokovic. Originals go randomly into packs and replicas get wider distribution.

    Rubin started buying art in 2019 and owns tens of millions of dollars of Condo paintings. Brady and Karl-Anthony Towns held up the Condo cards at Fanatics Fest.

  • Fanatics aims to grow the whole category 10x rather than fight for share. Rubin says the category has already multiplied several times from tens of billions of dollars, and sees growing it as Fanatics' responsibility.

    He thinks the biggest beneficiary may be Panini, which once called itself the global leader and now sues Fanatics as a monopoly over rights it used to hold. Rubin says of the lawsuit, "I love the fight."

2Selling more products to the fans Fanatics already has

In a pictureFan cash turns every bet into spending across Fanatics
  1. 1Fan places a betInjured players voided from bets
  2. 2Earns fan cashOver $1 billion out this year
  3. 3Spends across FanaticsMerchandise, collectibles, events or bets
  4. 4Returns to bet againOver 90% redeemed within the year

From Michael Rubin interview

  • Fanatics treats its fan relationships, not commerce, as its main asset. In 2020 Rubin decided the 70 to 80 million fans buying gear were the company's most valuable asset and asked what else they would want, leading into betting and collectibles. Fanatics now has 140 million fans and about $14 billion in revenue.

    Rivals must buy customers through advertising while Fanatics already had them and their trust. Fan gear, started in 2011, is about $7 billion and includes Nike NFL and MLB lines, Champion, the league stores, team sites and Lids. "Our best customers are people that do things across multiple different businesses."

  • The sportsbook won share with fan cash and voided injured players. Fanatics gives fan cash on every bet, spendable on merchandise, bets, collectibles or events, and removes a player who gets hurt from a bet so it no longer loses. It went from nothing to about 10% of regulated sports betting in three years.

    Over $1 billion in fan cash went out this year and more than 90% is redeemed within the year. Both features came from asking "How do we make it better for the fan?" rather than copying FanDuel or DraftKings.

  • Rubin uses being a distant third in betting to push innovation. The theme of Fanatics' leadership offsite was "number three is irrelevant, number two sucks, number one is everything." In betting Fanatics trails DraftKings and FanDuel, and Rubin says he likes that challenge.

  • Rubin invests in prediction markets but expects their legal setup to change. About 80% of prediction market business is sports and closely resembles regulated betting; their billions in advertising made betting much harder. Fanatics is investing hundreds of millions in prediction markets anyway.

    He expects state regulation, taxation or politics to change the construct within a couple of years. He says he has a 0.0 chance of putting his own money into Kalshi or Polymarket at announced valuations.

  • Growth is organic, with small acquisitions only to gain capabilities faster. Fanatics will grow over 40% this year, all organically. It bought Topps in 2022 and PointsBet, with about half a percent share, in 2023, then improved them and invested heavily.

    A leadership offsite study found Apple, Amazon, Google and Meta got much of their growth after their first 15 years by adding products. Fanatics has bought very little of materiality in the last couple of years.

3Rubin's near-disasters at 16 and in 2009

  • A bankruptcy scare at 16 launched Rubin's closeout business. After a snowless winter he faced $200,000 of bills against $80,000 of inventory; since a minor cannot legally take on debt, he settled for $35,000. He then borrowed $13,000 at $1,000 a week to buy a bankrupt store's $200,000 of inventory and repaid it in three weeks.

    He had started tuning skis at 12, had a store by 14, and got arrogant from early press, even buying half a Porsche. By 21 he did $150 million a year in closeouts. "Each disaster, if you learn from it, leads to your next success."

  • Rubin was hours from losing GSI Commerce to a margin call. His GSI stock fell from about $250 million in 2007 to about $25 million, and the advance ratio dropped from 40% to 15%. He cut the loan from $50 million to $3 million, and a hedge fund manager returned $5 million after about a hundred calls, hours before the bank would sell his shares.

    He had borrowed against the stock to invest, which worked from 1999 to 2007. eBay bought GSI for $2.4 billion in March 2011.

  • Rubin treats crises as interesting problems and keeps working them. He has built through the 2001 internet bust, 2008 and 2009 and COVID, and calls those the most interesting times. In 2009 he says he was never frazzled and just kept working the problem.

    "A lot of people give up too easy."

  • Rubin says a real entrepreneur is born with it, loves it, and can't stop. He says a founder who sold for $20 billion and stopped caring is perhaps not an entrepreneur anymore, and that he is not selling Fanatics.

    He credits killer instinct over raw talent, citing Tom Brady's work ethic in business. "I'll stop playing when my heart stops beating."

4Fair dealing with partners and investors

  • Rubin stopped trying to win deals and started trying to win partnerships. He is fine being out-negotiated by sports properties because Fanatics is lucky to work with them. It has about 7,000 athletes on individual contracts and a thousand sports properties.

    Big deals like Disney's take six months to a year and a half. He wants partners to root for Fanatics and come back to do more.

  • Robert Kraft told Rubin to sleep on a broken deal before reacting. A very important person in sports found a cute way to violate a deal, and Kraft told him to take a deep breath since he was in the business forever. Days later the issue felt smaller and Rubin reached a great outcome.

    Rubin says Kraft and his son Jonathan have helped him most, with no agenda.

  • Fanatics returned over $100 million after three months in NFTs. Rubin decided the NFT business was not a real business and repaid investors in full.

    "This is stupid."

  • Rubin repaid Mitchell & Ness backers with a 20% return after a collapse. Fanatics bought it at the peak of a retired-player jersey trend, and within a year it went from very profitable to losing money. Rubin returned friends' money plus 20% to protect his reputation for fairness.

    The earlier Lids investment with a private equity firm and friends had returned 40 times the money in a couple of years.

  • Silver Lake's Greg Mondre stopped a multibillion-dollar mistake. Mondre staged a mini intervention on a big deal Rubin was fixated on, noting Rubin owned 31% with a super majority but was getting it wrong.

    Rubin agrees he was dead wrong and called to thank him, and credits being a good listener.

More in Shopping

Shopping

Amazon

An online retailer and platform company that also runs AWS, Kindle, Echo and Prime.

59 sources · 108 tips
Shopping

Nike

A global athletic footwear and apparel company that began as a shoe importer called Blue Ribbon Sports.

11 sources · 47 tips
Shopping

Walmart

A discount retail chain built on everyday low prices, started in small Arkansas towns.

15 sources · 41 tips
Shopping

Costco

A membership warehouse retailer selling a small range of bulk goods at capped markups.

B12 sources · 29 tips
Shopping

IKEA

A Swedish furniture retailer selling flat-packed, low-priced home furnishings through large stores and a catalog.

3 sources · 34 tips
Shopping

Whatnot

A live stream shopping marketplace where sellers auction and sell products to buyers in real time.

4 sources · 15 tips
Shopping

Home Depot

The world's largest home improvement retailer, selling tools, building materials and supplies through big-box warehouse stores.

5 sources · 20 tips
Shopping

eBay

An online marketplace for new and used goods, including collectibles.

7 sources · 13 tips