0:00V. Schwab's on the show today who's written 27 books and is one of the top fantasy writers in the world. And I noticed her gift immediately. So, right before we start recording, we're walking through a garden and we see this little bell. We start joking about the bell and I notice that she's joking about it in a way that's magical and wondrous and fantastical [music] and also a little spooky. And I'm like, "Ha, I see how your brain works. This is interesting. I want to learn about this."
0:24>> [music] >> And so I said, "Okay, you got to tell me how is it that you take that imagination and turn it into these incredible stories on the page? Why do you take outlining so seriously? Why is it that you start with setting whenever you write? And also, how do you take characters and your imagination and make them real on the page?" And so if you want to learn to write fantasy, well, you're going to love this conversation with me. Ew.
How she builds a book
0:480:49Where I want to start is on the difference between narrative order and chronological order. as you're thinking through stories. >> Yeah, of course. Well, stories can exist in both directions. Um, the narrative order is the order in which the reader will experience the story. The chronological order is the order in which the characters experience the story. So, when I'm building a book, I build it into the narrative order so that I see, you know, we might start in the present, then we cut back to the past, and then we cut back to the present. That's a narrative order. We cut across characters. But then when it's time for me to actually write the story, I break the narrative order down into the chronological order, the order in which each of my point of view characters experiences the story. And then I write them in chronological order. And sometimes that's really important for a book like Bury Our Bones
1:30in the Midnight Soil where we're tracking three women over 300 years because I have a moral decay element in that story where each woman is is disintegrating their humanity over time. And I want to be able to track the nuances of the emotional arc as well as the physical journey. So it's easier to move through time with them. So I'll build the book one way, break it into the other way, and then reassemble it into the first way. And if I've done my job correctly, it'll it'll all work.
1:57[laughter] >> So, help me understand. >> Yeah. >> How it is that you go about thinking about that. So, there like two strips or what does it look like? >> So, I build a book before I write it. And part of this is just I'm a very anxious individual. I like to play God in my world. I like to understand everything about it. I'm kind of building a maze, running my characters through the maze until I understand what I want the maze to actually be. It's almost like a dry run. Like, so when I'm building a story, it might take six months or six years to be very honest.
2:25That's my playground time. People think because I'm an extreme outliner that the there's no joy. They'll be like, "Oh, but if you outline everything, then there's no joy in the drafting." And I'm like, "That's right. There is no joy in the drafting for me. I'm an extreme perfectionist." The first draft for me is an exercising control failure. I hate it. I spend the entire first draft just keenly aware of the gap between the idea in my head and the thing I'm putting on paper. So my play time is what happens before the first draft, which is this months or years long process wherein I'm I'm gaming it. I'm building like a Sims, right? And I'm like I'm designing my characters. I'm designing my world around the crux of a whatif or a conundrum. And then I'm essentially running the numbers over and over again to say, "Okay, I I get to this point in the story. I'm happy, but I don't know where to go next." And I just choose my
3:10own adventure and I play out the the iterations of what it looks like if I go A, B, C, or D. And then I go that way until I reach the next thing. And for a year, I just get to play. I get to brainstorm on paper. And so I build this map for myself. And then only once I've run the narrative order map and I've seen the story as it's going to be for a reader. That's the only time that I break it down into the chronological
Start with the ending
3:343:33order. >> So take me all the way back to the beginning. As you're thinking through a story and you're thinking through play, imagination, is that kind of in your head? you're like lying down on the couch and you're sort of being like, "Wow, it could be like that." Like what is that world that you're building? Like >> it's it's on paper. It's on paper. I have to like continually ideate on paper. I do start all of my stories with the end so I know where I'm going, what I want to land on. That's like the taste left in your mouth at the end of the meal. And then I rewind the whole story to find the unfinished version of it.
4:03The point where we're going to start our characters, where we're going to meet them. I'm going to come to the idea with the ingredients for my meal. And then I'm going to collect ingredients over the course of 6 months to 6 years and to continue enriching this meal that I'm going to make. But I don't really know what the meal is right away. I just have like some of the primary ingredients. So what will often happen for me is that I will get the initial ingredients and then I will set them aside for one to two years. And that works for me because I have so many projects going on that I can afford to do that. If I had to sit and just wait for the thing to cook on the stove, I would be I would be miserable the entire time. But it's usually like like last fall I had an idea for a children's story for a middle-grade novel and I just had like a few of the not even the primary ingredients just some of the the
4:50aromatics spices the seasoning some of the the setting and I put them aside. I was like you're not ready yet. Something's going to come along though to become the the fusion for this this meal. Sure enough about two weeks ago I was like oh there you are. I got you. I got you. So I pull the ingredients back out. I add this new ingredient to them and I'm like, "Okay, we can start to build a meal." And then what happens or what I'm doing right now and and in the ideation stage. So now I'm like, "Okay, okay, okay, I have some of the crux. I have some of the backstory. I have some of these pieces that are kind of scattered across. And now it's my job to kind of find the way between them." And that's when I'll be like, "Okay, what's the ending?" And I'm like, "Okay, what's a really interesting beginning that's going to help lay the table for this ending? That's going to help set up the pieces." And then I'm like, okay, what's
5:33uh a really fundamental moment in the book that is going to need to happen? Okay, I'm going to set that there. And I start to just kind of build a sense for myself. And then I just open open consecutive Word documents, which I should not do. Word it will crash. If you play in Word enough, you will lose in Word. It's like gambling, right? You're going to go play, you're going to win for a little while. The house is going to win in the end. I have Scriber, which is a really nice place to organize all these. I can't help myself. I have this need to have just a fresh blank document every time I'm thinking and I'll just open like 20 of them and there'll be 20 different scenes and I'll just start outlining. I'll be like, "What's something that could happen in the scene?" Okay, maybe I want to start with a festival. I want to start with a festival because it's a really interesting way to set the stage of the
6:16world that I'm playing in for the reader without it feeling like I'm just setting the stage. So, I have a character moving through a festival, a festival they've been through their entire life, but something about it is unusual today. What about it is unusual today? and I just start playing. Mel, my rules for myself are that I never set design sets I won't use. So, so a way to think of that is I'm never going to set the table if we don't eat. I choose setting and worldbuilding elements that are vital to the plot or the character. They have to be tethered in some way to one or the other. One of the best examples I like to give is anime. I grew up on anime.
6:50One of my favorite things about anime is nine times out of 10, it doesn't tell you what's going on. It thrusts you in at episode one. just drops the viewer in and is like, you're going to figure it out as it's relevant. You're going to find the rules as you need the rules, not before. And so I think I kind of operate by that system when I'm building, which is like what rules can I build or what setting pieces can I build that will help the reader infer the rest of the world from them. Some piece of fashion might tell us about society.
7:19Some piece of what they worship at this festival. What kind of celebration is this festival? Is it their equivalent of a Halloween or is it their equivalent of a saints day? Is it the does it can it tell us something about their religious system, their cultural system? So, I try to find ways to anchor all of my worldbuilding elements in the necessity of plot. And then I'm just I'm just playing. I'm just playing for as long as I can until at some point I realize that I have played enough that I have no excuse but to start the actual drafting part.
7:48>> You used the word unusual when you were talking about the festival and I was like that's an interesting word. Why is unusual such a juicy tool to play with? >> I think it's it's juicy if your character is of their world. So, if you're playing with a stranger to a place, everything is unusual. But if you're playing with a character who is born of a place, you kind of have to manufacture unusualness. It's it's a little bit of a farce. It's a little authoral hand. If your character is born of a place, lived in that place, grown up in that place, and suddenly they're noticing things because we wouldn't. I think whether you're writing fantasy or reality, you have to come back to the nuts and bolts of how we actually move through the world. And the fact is a a local a native person in their environment notices different things than a stranger to that environment. So, it's really important that you not give
8:38the noticing to the character that wouldn't notice it. So, in A Darker Shade of Magic, there's a moment where Kell and Laya both land in Red London. Red London is a place that Kell has spent almost every day of his life. Red London is a place that Lyla Bart has never seen before. I separate them immediately so they each get a point of view scene because Kell is going to notice completely different things from Laya. In for Laya, everything she's seeing is new. For Kell, there have to be only a few things he's seeing that are unusual. And so unusual is really important not for the author unusual is important in relation to the character because even if you're not in point of view even if we're writing a third person close point of view or where it's you know he she or they said and it's not omnisient I don't really I don't really do omniscience in books generally I have a narrator I have a a person who
9:27who we're hovering behind if like not inside for them we need to understand that like they're not objective every character you right, is subjective and so you need to tie your narrative to them in some way.
Are slow beginnings bad?
9:419:41>> Early on, how do you think about suspense? And there's a certain slowness, I think, that comes with exposition. And how do you think about the slowness of exposition with the what you were saying earlier about anime that blast off right into it? >> Absolutely. Here's the thing. I laugh because I've written 27 books. The thing I will get consistently dinged for is that I have slow beginnings. [laughter] But I and for maybe 20 of those books, I it was an insecurity. I was like, "Oh, wow. Maybe I'm doing this wrong." You know, I would every single time, even when readers were like huge fans, they would be like, "Stick it out." This is I would see this in reviews. Stick it out.
10:14The first 100 pages are slow. And for a long time, I kept trying to think, how do I make them faster? How do I make them faster? And then I realized that I don't want to. The slowness at the beginning of my books is an investment. I am We're going to play a game together. And I want you to care about the game. And I want you to care about the outcome of the game. In order for you to care about the outcome of the game and the game, you need to understand the game. So, I need a beat to set up the game for you. I need to be able to set the game board. I need to be able to teach you the rules and I need to be able to put the pieces on there so that when we run the game, you're going to care about the outcome of it. And something that happens when you start and you put action above everything is you don't give the reader a chance to understand or care about the game. And I think that one thing that I do get from
11:01readers is that almost invariably they care about my endings. The the impact is there. But but so many don't understand that the only reason the impact is there is because of the investment earlier. So I have over the last maybe five years just been like you know what it's a feature not a bug. This is a thing you just have to buy into especially as a fantasy writer. Uh you there is a moment of education. I try to bury the broccoli in the mac and cheese so to speak. I try to make sure that the the examination and the exposition is buried in a slowb burn plot. So there is still always forward movement, but it might be deceptively quiet for the first 100 pages as I'm getting you to know the atmosphere. I want you to understand I want you to have a quiet immersion in it. It's not that I'm averse to starting in Medius Race. Vicious starts in Medius Race. It is possible to do. The more complicated the book, the more steps it
11:52takes from our reality, the more it just takes a moment for me to set the stage for you. >> And how did you find peace with this? Was it something internal or was it something external? Finding stories that you like that you admired that they also started slow that you were like, you know what, if this great writer can do that, then so can I. >> Oh, no. I'm my worst critic, right? So, I never can look at other writers and be like, oh, they're doing a great job.
12:14Maybe I can do. So, >> it's a war with yourself here. >> A war with myself. It's still probably one day out of seven bothers me because I just think like it's not a thing that I'm entirely free of. We're all we all have like criticisms that get under our skin a little bit. >> So the thing that's bothering you is reading the criticisms over time and being like, "Ah, I'm doing it again." >> Well, no. It's more that I like can't seem to It's more that the criticism exists. It's more that people don't understand that the thing that they love about my books is also the thing that they're using to criticize. Like they love They'll be like, "Stick with it.
12:44It's worth it. The ending. I can't stop thinking about this. It's a book that I think about every day for the rest of my life. I'm like, the reason that you think about this book every day, the reason you have it tattooed on your body, the reason that it lives inside your head rentree, the reason that you reread it every year is because I took those extra 100 pages at the beginning. And to be clear, it's not that nothing is happening in those 100 pages. But when you compare it to work out there that is hitting the ground at 60 m hour, it might seem like hitting the ground at 30 m hour is slow. But I'm like, we're just getting started. You got to like you got to be with me. Especially because I have so much confidence in my endings, really in my like back halves of the book. I'm like, if you're going to be a V Ewab reader, you got to buy in. This is what I'm asking from you, but I'm promising you it's going to be
The risk of nonstop action
13:2713:27>> In what ways is it like a roller coaster where you get on, it's a little bit slow, and then you get that, >> you know, the little click thing, you get to the top, and then in a weird way, >> yeah, >> that's kind of when the roller coaster begins. >> It is built exactly like a roller coaster. to extend that metaphor a little bit. I think there are roller coasters these days for whom the entire gimmick is you start at the top and fall. So the moment that you're at the top and it's just like woo and it's just like a quick how much can I surge adrenaline into you as quickly as possible. But those roller coasters they're not very long. They're not very like they don't tend to like you don't crave that you're like I got to do it again just so I can get that little hit.
14:02Whereas like the beautiful thing about like a long form classic roller coaster is that it doesn't have one hill, right? is like, so you've got these things now where it feels like you're going to start at the top and it's going to be like like one of those elevator of horror things, right? It's going to take you up to the top. It's just going to drop you. That's it. That's it. You're just going one time. But on a classic roller coaster, you're right. You have that notch up, which is that's our investment period. That's where I'm like, and we're clicking up the temperature. You're getting a little bit more nervous as it climbs because you're like, well, I know I'm on a roller coaster. This part might seem slow, but like I can see this is I can hear I've heard people scream. I know it's coming, right? I'm asking you to buy in on that tension with me. You get to the top and then the roller coaster starts and it
14:43never stops. Now, it doesn't stop, but it slows. A good roller coaster has moments where it lets you catch your breath for just a second before it steals it again. A good roller coaster has that moment where like you think it stopped and then we keep going. You thought it was only one loop, but it's two. You thought there wasn't any blind turn, but it turns out there is. And so, that's the thing is I got to get you on the roller coaster, but once we're on it, it's going to be amazing. And it and a like I say, a great roller coaster doesn't work because it's all scream all the way. A comedy and horror are tied in this way as well. So my my books tend to get very funny before they get very scary or very sad. And it's because it's all breath work. A roller coaster exists in the same way. At some point, your reader or your your your person on this ride has to catch their breath. They have to catch their breath so they can
15:28scream again. And a good story allows really really considered moments, not very long ones, that allow the reader to catch their breath. so that the game can continue, so that the ride can continue. And I think we feel this this compulsion right now as as readers and as writers, like it better be all all guns blazing the whole time. It better be all drop. It better be all scream. And I'm like, that's not actually fun. Because what happens is your nervous system gets equalized. If you're too even the whole way, even if that even is way up here, even if the bar is all the way up here for action, what happens? There's nowhere to go.
16:03>> Yeah. I was out on for drinks on Saturday and my buddy loved this sweet sweet drink >> and I said, "What do you think of the pretzels?" He said, "I don't really like the pretzels, but they serve a very important function." >> Counter. >> The saltiness of the pretzel makes the sweet way better. >> Exactly. And I would argue that some of the books these days that start at that really high octave note that are dropping you in at the highest action moment, there's really nowhere to go from there but down. So they either have to try to maintain it, which is exhausting in and of itself to a reader and also doesn't allow you to really start getting to know the characters. If your action and plot first the whole time, uh where are the characters?
16:43They're second. And my my greatest belief is if you do not care about the characters that the story is happening to, you do not actually care about the story. You might enjoy it while it lasts, but the moment you put the book down, you're you're put the book down, you're done. >> This episode is sponsored by Alpha School. When you think of school, what comes to mind? For me, it was lectures, homework, being stuck at a desk. And the worst part is that it doesn't even work.
17:0854% of Americans read below a sixth grade level. That's over half of Americans. We need something new. And that's why I'm excited to have Alpha School as the flagship sponsor of How I Write. At Alpha, you go to school, you get all your academics done in only 2 hours per day. So that then you could spend the rest of the time learning life skills like running a business, writing a musical, giving a TEDex talk. You know, the kind of things that make you a capable and well-rounded person. And it's working. They have the academics figured [music] out. Alpha classes test in the top 1% nationally, and more than 90% of students say they love school.
17:45Now, I used to live in Austin where Alpha School started and I was consistently blown away by what was happening [music] there. I personally mentored a bunch of the kids and what stuck out to me is how much their team believes in the potential of kids. Alpha's approach and the success it's already having is why it's the most talked about K through2 school in the world right now and also where I want to send my kids to school one day. So, if you want to learn more, visit go.alpha.school/howite.
Know your character's backstory
18:1418:15So, we talked about endings and you have that clear sense of where you're going. Can you talk to me about character development and where that comes from? >> Yeah. So, I I don't know my characters MyersBriggs types. I don't know their birthdays most of the time. People think because I know them really well. What I will say is that I know I know my characters as if they are real people. I build them as if they are real people. I build them so that their existence is not contingent upon the reader's attention. Meaning when the reader puts the book down when they finish, I don't want them to believe the character stops existing. I want them to believe they're no longer invited to follow the character story. And and to do that, I need them to feel like real people. And it can it seems like a silly obvious thing. Write your characters like they're real people. But there are a few really intentional ways that I do that.
18:59I look at their backstory. And backstory is something that often gets a bad rap because it's seen as exposition. But backstory, even if it never makes it onto the page or it makes it onto the page in the smallest doses, is one of the most important things you can know about your characters. I do not mean David Copperfield style backstory where you know them from the moment they're born until the moment we follow them.
19:17But what I do mean are the highlights and low lightss of their life, the defining moments that made them the person that they are at the moment we are meeting them in the story. Because if we look at ourselves, we are the result of everything that's happened to us, but we are the most the result of the best and worst things that have happened to us and the way we've reacted to those. If you want to design a character that has trust issues, you know, and you're like, "This is this thing. They're a rogue. They're a loner.
19:42They have trust issues." Okay, so someone broke their trust at some point. So that's what you need to know. You need to know the formative moments in their past. They don't have to be trauma, but they have to be shaping. They have to be is there were there was their heart broken? Did they lose someone they love? Did they what is like what has built the person they are at the point we are meeting them in the story? And as an author, I think the best thing you can do for yourself and for your characters is to understand the hills they will die on and why they will die on them. The trust issues they have or the their greatest strengths and weaknesses of character. Those are not born out of nowhere. I feel like we often, you know, there's a temptation especially for young to treat them as just kind of like ornamentation. No, no, no, no. Look at yourself like you are foundationally formed. Did you have a
20:26good family upbringing? Did you have a bad family upbringing? Did you have a best friend? Did you have siblings? What happened to those siblings? All of these things. Did you have a trauma? And if you didn't have a trauma, that's fine, too. But what shaped you as a person? We have all been shaped. So, if you can build your character that way, maybe some of those low lightss and highlights will come into it. Maybe we'll find a place for a flashback and you will want to have that. But it's essential. One of my favorite things to do is read memoir.
20:54I read a ton of memoir. And the reason that I do that is one, it's a great voice exercise. You get to read a person from their own perspective. So this is the difference between biography and autobiography memoir. I seek out memoir because it's the person according to themselves. And often it is that person choosing their own highlights and lowlights of their life. It is, you know, a memoir doesn't tell you everything, but it tells you a snapshot.
21:17It tells you the most formative moments. So, as a character build exercise, I think one of the great things writers can do is go read memoir because what a great just capsule exercise in what forms a person. And once you understand what made that person where they are now, you can roll them forward. You can create new crossroads for them because your story is going to be about creating new highlights and lowlights for that
Give characters a mantra
21:4221:41person. >> Can you talk to me about the hills that they die on idea? I remember when I had Richard Powers on the show, I said, "How do you bring characters to life?" And he said, "Push them to the wall." And I said, "What do you mean?" He said, "Well, often people will have two values that they have very strong, but then there'll be a moment where they have to choose between them." So, for example, I really value justice, but I really value loyalty. Okay, I'm all about justice, all about loyalty, but now my sister has just murdered somebody, and now I got to go to court, and am I going to be loyal to my sister, or am I going to believe in justice? And it's in that moment of conflict, extreme tension, that now we see who the character is.
22:26>> Exactly. My version of that is I say, I like to make my character have a mantra uh like if if a thing is worth having, it is worth taking. That was Llaya Bar's mantra. or with Victor Veil in Vicious like nothing is more important than his own ambition except of course when he ends up finding people that are more important than his own ambition and he's so give people a mantra I have one tattooed on my body uh either I will find a way or make my own right um in Viotein Alfaxium and and I think you find the mantra and then you put your character in a situation where they have to break their own mantra and that's an kind of an extension of the give your character what they want only for them to discover it's not what they need it's a it's a situation where it's a really good crucible for your character. It does not have to happen at the midway point of a book. It can happen at the end of a book. It can happen at the end
23:12of a series, but you need to know what your character's line in the sand is that they're like, "This is the thing I will never do." It's like, can you make Superman kill a man, right? It's can you do the thing. Um, and you also though very carefully need to understand I I will dock a book immediately if I feel like they are doing it for the plot and not because it is true to the character. So if you are building a character who genuinely like Superman's a good example there, I think if you make Superman kill somebody, you've broken Superman. It's not actually like you have broken the intrinsic foundation of character that is built. So that's not what I'm saying.
23:46You have to it has to be a self-defin they think is true about themselves but isn't not a firmament on which their whole identity is built. That's very, I think, a careful distinction because if you are breaking it for the plot, you have done a disservice to the character you've built. And I think that can really inhibit reader trust. So, I can tell when a character gets killed off for the plot, not because it was built into the story or baked into the story.
24:11And I get really frustrated at that because I'm like, you could have built the story to justify. Like, you could have built the story in a way where it felt, you know, grievant but inevitable or felt like it was important to the narrative. But sometimes I'm just like, "Oh, you got stuck and then you thought blow something up or kill somebody, you know, and that's not always the solution." It's kind of the same way in an extent. People always say like, "Oh, do you like when your characters surprise you when they tell you some like they do something?" And I'm like, "No, no." Because to me, that's a bug, not a feature because of the way I build stories where I am the god of the world that I'm building and I run the game so many times before I write it. If my character suddenly goes off book, that's my problem. That's not cute. That's not my character being, you know, nice and surprising. that's a fundamental flaw in
24:53something I have designed. And so I think it's really important when you're building your character to understand the difference between a defining aspect of the person you've made and a self-defining aspect that is not actually true for them. And the self-defining aspect, you can look at it as a necessary evolution or maturation of their character. Like Victor saying like no one is more important than my own ambition. Like well that's a immature take. But as he matures and finds people in his life that he actually does care about, he has to take it back. Llaya Bard, a lot of times it's self-interest versus self-sacrifice, right? Llaya Bard and Shades of Magic being like, "Yeah, I'm going to take anything I need." Um, you know, no one again, no one is more important than than my freedom. And she finds Cal. So, like, you have to create a situation that is something they can evolve through. Can you walk me through the the
25:44mantras and character a little bit more of how you get down to the essence of who these characters are? And is the mantra something that you're doing for yourself, something that you're doing for the reader? >> It's totally for myself. It will come through for the reader in different ways. Um, so like Addy Laru, the invisible life of Adi Laru. Adaru's mantra was defiant hope. And that wasn't a mantra I wanted to break. It was a mantra I wanted to challenge. And this gets into like uh I have this issue with immortal on Wii. Um like it really really bothers me because again at the end of the day I'm a rule maker, okay?
26:16I'm a I'm a world builder and as a fantasy author sometimes people think that means you're not beholden to logic and reality. And I'm like oh no I'm triply beholden to logic and reality. In order to make a believable fantasy system your underpinning has to be as intuitive and as innate and as logical as possible. So I get really perturbed and most of my books are born out of this by something that I feel like is a logical fallacy. One of them is the immortal on Wii, which is you'll oftentimes happens in like vampire lore because they're a classic immortal.
26:43Well, you'll have an immortal. They're alive for hundreds of years and they're like, "Woe is me. I am so bored by existence. If only I could end it." And I'm like, "Walk into the sun." Like literally, you haven't designed a world where they can't end it. You could pay someone to hold a stake. Like if you truly want an out, there is an out. So if you're the if you're being only like encumbered by your own like narrative on Wii, like it I don't buy it. I don't buy it. So like when I was designing The Invisible Life of Addy Laroo, I started with her as that immortal on Wii when I first started writing her and I realized it doesn't work. She is in control of when this experiment ends. So I had to give her the exact opposite of immortal on. I had to give her defiant hope. I had to give her a kind of relentless optimism that that whatever she might experience tomorrow was worth the pain of today. And then it wasn't about
27:32breaking that, but it was about Luke, the other character, trying to break her of it. So that's what I mean when there's a difference between uh a defining principle of a character and a self-defining principle that they need to evolve past. Addy Laroo's defining principle is defiant hope. If I had broken her, I would have killed the story. So in that case, it's about somebody else trying to break it and her having to be challenged to the point of that resilience. So that's the difference. That's like less a mantra and more of a a foundational principle on which I built her entire identity.
28:04The moment like at the moment Addie stops feeling hopeful, it's over. It's over. And so what we need from her is for her to never break. But we need to see her almost break. We need to see her get close. And then we need to see her become stronger for it. I need to be more resilient for it. But I build them for myself so that I understand them because I'm not my characters. Each one of them holds a small fragment of my personality from which I have grown an entirely new person. So I will take a a fear, an antagonism, a a a desire, and I will then grow a new character who is not me from that character, but I need a little mirror. I need a little reflective moment so that when I'm looking at a character who is vastly different from myself, I can still hear their heartbeat. I can still lock in on them. And the mantra helps me with that.
28:48The the defining principles of their I mean what is a defining principle of your life? >> A defining principle of your life by >> um man let's see don't turn your back on people. >> All right. See so would then if I'm trying to build you as a character um first of all I'm like what leads you to believe that? Did someone turn their back on you? Is it something that you've just always believed? Have you been betrayed by a friend at any point? Have you been the betrayer? Is it something wherein that is something that you were raised with? Was that you know as a child your parents instructed you to do this and why? And then have you ever let anyone else down and that has like followed you or is it something that it is like never been challenged in your life? If it's never been challenged in your life, let's challenge it.
29:32>> Yeah, it's interesting to hear you say that because this is totally something that emerged through life experience and not something I was raised with. >> Yeah. And most of the time our our principles have been born from nurture, not nature, right? And that's the beautiful thing. It's hard to build nature in a character. You can start with them. It's way more fun to work with nurture because if something has been taught, it can been be untaught. If something has been proven, it can be unproven. It can be tested. So, I love building a character like that.
29:58>> Yeah. It was just with someone whose core principle was never give up. >> Yeah. >> Never give up. >> Yeah. >> And when his father was was dying, that was like one of his final words to his son to him. >> And he was like, "Do not give up on what you're doing." and all of his favorite biographies about not giving up, not giving up, not giving up. But my mantra assessment of this person is he would be so much better off if he had given up a few times.
30:24>> And that's the thing where in a a mantra can be seemingly really good and also become toxic for us if we are intrigent with it. Intrigence is one of my favorite things to work with in a character because stubbornness, intrigence, and unwillingness to bend is what is going to break a character spirit in some way. And the nice thing about breaking them is we can rebuild them most of the time. But yeah, so that I just build them the way I would psychology. I build them the way I would people. They are sitting in my office and I am talking through them about why they are the way that they are.
30:55Sometimes it comes from my own life, something that I've suffered or something that I'm afraid of suffering. But and that's why a lot of writers will ask me like, well, how do I write about something I haven't experienced? And I'm like, well, you don't have to experience it, but you have to experience the underlying thing. You know, you have to know what it feels like. If you want to write about loss, you have to have lost something. Doesn't have to have been the exact loss that you're writing about.
31:18But if you have never in your life perceived of a loss, it will be hard to write about loss. But the beautiful thing about writing is that you can analog it. You can say, I have not lost X, but I have lost Y. How can I imagine the gap between these two? And then work toward the center point of it. So you don't have to experience things but you do have to kind of be able to relate to the character. It is very hard to give a character a set of core beliefs or systems that you in some way do not relate to. Even if it's you can relate to the polar opposite of it and build them in reverse. You can say well I know what it's like to be this extreme over here. Can I invert it to find this extreme over here? But you really are building or at least for me from a self- principles at the certain time. I know what it is like to be betrayed by a friend. I know what it is like to have a grievance. I know what it is like to
32:05lose somebody. So I'm building from the things I feel in that moment. I'm just painfully introspective. So I'm very very good at like self assessing even from within an experience and thinking okay how would I articulate the thing? I
Magic must have a cost
32:1832:18want to throw a maxim on the table and see how you react to it. Like true, false. >> In fantasy, there always has to be a cost to a superpower or a certain magical power. >> There should be. I don't think there always is. There always should be because that's nature. I have a really big issue when magical systems and fantastical systems don't actually hold to like laws of physics and nature because that's everything in our world does. like physics can be reduced to very simple principles as well in terms of like cost and blowback or you know um efficacy loss. So the difference between potential and kinetic energy but like everything around us obeys a rule. So if you wanted to design a system of magic that then doesn't obey any of the rules of nature. It's pretty hard to latch on to mentally from a place of within reality. Personally I just believe that all powers should have a cost. I think
33:09all powers, especially superpowers, it's why I've always bought more into like the Flash because I'm like, if he keeps running fast enough for long of it, he's going to run out of calories. It's just it has to be a cost thing. It has to be a give. There has to be a pushpull between all things because if there is no cost to the use of power, then there is no interest. >> Yeah. I think that many of the great stories, they take something that you have a deep and intense desire for where you almost say, "If I could only have that, then I'd be happy."
33:40>> And then it takes you there. Like the ring in Lord of the Rings, you have the ring and then the ring destroys and it corrupts and it just grades at the people who have it. And I think that's part of the reason that that story is so good is >> it takes this thing that you almost it like wets your appetite. Oh my goodness, I want that power. I want that power. I want that thing, whatever it is in my life. And then you begin to see all the different ways that that would actually maybe even destroy you.
34:08>> I also think that like it's just not fair and and our world is not fair, right? We see people amass mass quantities of power with and then the people who don't have power absorb the cost, not them. And so I think one of the things that we do seek out in fiction is a sense of like fairness in the system of the world even if not in what the characters are going through because one of the great unfairnesses of the world in which we live is that the people paying the cost for the people having the power is not the person having the power. And I think it's one of the things that we gravitate to. I mean, in comic books, one of the things people gravitate to and that I don't and that I was fighting against in Vicious is the kind of moral absolutism of good versus evil, which is not a thing that I buy into. I don't like the idea that like the vicious was born out of the concept that superpowers don't make you
34:54a superhero. Because if we look at the world, 99.9999% of the time power does make you a worse person. And I've yet to see people get power and suddenly overnight be like, I think I'm supposed to protect everybody with this power. I'm like, this never happened. That's never happened. No one has gone and become a billionaire overnight and been like, I'm so good now. I'm so good now. So, I think that one of the things that we do seek out in the kind of wish fulfillment of storytelling, no matter how dark the actual stories are, is a sense of balance. Is a sense that like either good will out or bad will fall, but there will be a cost for the kind of the kind of power that people take in
How dialogue reveals character
35:3235:31stories. >> Can you talk me through the relationship between dialogue and character? How dialogue can reveal character? And you talked about voice and memoir early on. So, let's bring that into this conversation, too. >> Dialogue is essential for me, but I'm also I like to think or I'm starting to think that I might be a method writer, meaning like, you know, with method actors, they get into the character and then they take like, you know, time to integrate with the character and then time to pull back from it. I am lightly possessed by the characters that I'm writing when I'm possessing them. So, I'm very I'm very aware of them. I like need them to settle over me a little bit like a a cape or an article of clothing.
36:05And that's one of the reasons that I write chronologically for the character so I can hold their voice as long as possible. His voice to me is essential. I come from a poetry background. So syllabolic rhythm and semantic and not even just word choice but sentence structure, length of phrase is really essential for me in writing. The difference between an introspective character who has an internal monologue and one that doesn't. Victor Veil in the villains trilogy, we spend a lot of time inside his head and absolutely none of that is feeling. He is an analytical character. The time that we spend in his head is the time in which he is diagnosing a problem and coming up with potential solutions to that problem. A character like Sabine in Bury Our Bones, no internal monologue, no internal monologue because zero introspection.
36:44Whereas Charlotte, one of the other characters in that book, almost entirely internal monologuing, deep empathetic emotional introspection. I will look at the form in which each character speaks. Sometimes I will use a poetic underpinning. So for instance, when I was writing Luke in the invisible life of Addy Laroo, one of the early early early ideas I had for him, which I didn't end up using, was that every time he would greet Addie in the course of history when their paths crossed, he would greet her with a line of contemporary poetry from the time.
37:15>> And one of the very first lines that I played with for that was, "Come away with me and be my love." And I ended up not using it, but I ended up holding the syllabolic rhythm of the line, "Come away with me and be my love." It's a it's an it's an it's a command, but it's a gentle command. It's a seductive command. And so when I was building Luke's dialogue, I made sure that the dialogue almost always held that rhythm of the cadence. Whereas another character, I mean, all of us speak differently. We speak differently. Some people use more breaks. Some people will use more filler words. Some people use higher language. Some people use shorter sentences. I use run-on sentences.
37:51Adnauseium because my mind is a kind of constantly running line that has very few punctuation marks. And I think you can use that not only in the literal dialogue that is bracketed by quotation marks but in the internal dialogue of a character as well. So understanding the voice and the cadence of your character will tell you a lot about that character and how they think.
Read your work aloud
38:1438:14>> How do you think of on one hand there's all the different voices of the different characters. So this character might be like that, that character might be like that. And there's a diversity that versus your voice as a writer and finding your voice and the the Schwab motto. You know what I mean? >> It's hard because my books are so different, but the only thing they have in common is that I am the one writing them and that I am writing for a version of myself. So when I'm writing my children's books, I'm writing for 10 or 11 year old me. I don't know who anyone else was at 10 or 11. I was a super weird kid. So, I just am writing for her. When I'm writing my YA novels, it's for 17-year-old me. When I'm writing my adult novels, it's for whatever age I am at the time. So, those are the two points. I'm the writer and I'm the reader. That's this is like my little the the electrical current needs to go
39:04between these two metal points for myself. And so, I um I think about that. I It's weird because I'm always terribly afraid that my books are not going to feel cohesively enough me. And yet readers can always tell, especially something like Vicious and The Invisible Life of Adi Laroo, have completely different writing styles. One is highly, highly fractious because I wanted it to feel like a comic book without pictures.
39:27And one is highly lyrical because I wanted it to feel like a piece of classical music. But I think that the paying attention to rhythm, whether I'm shortening it or elongating it, is one of the things that makes my voice. There is a rhythm. I think you can taste my sentences. I try to taste my sentences when I'm writing them. The other thing that I do is I read all of my work aloud. So I know that the work works not only on paper but auditorially. And that's because I want all of my work to have a slight sense of an oral tale. I want my my I want my work to feel like it's being read to you the way a bedtime story would be or over a fire or in a cafe corner, but I want it to feel intimate. So, one of the ways that I achieved that intimacy in my work is by making sure that it could be read aloud to you. You could hear it over a table.
40:16And that's something that I think is essential for young writers. Take a moment, read your work aloud to yourself. You will also catch what doesn't trip to the ear. And when you're working on dialogue, tripping to the ear is essential. Absolutely essential. The other thing I do is I build conversations from the inside out. It's it's really tempting when you're first getting started to be like, "Hello, hello. How are you? How are you?" That's not happen when two people come to a conversation. Each one has an agenda.
40:45Each one has something they want to get to in the conversation. Somebody has something they are trying to bring up. And it's about how do you find the moment? So, I get to the moment first and then I work backwards and I find their inroads into the conversation. But it just just like anything else. It's not the author trying to make two people have a conversation on page. It's two people trying to each get to a point in the conversation that they're trying to get to. And then you streamline it a little bit. You have to just kind of pull out some of the the small talk, some of the distraction, which I hate anyway in real life. So, I'm I'm glad to do it. But even that is an opportunity to examine your character. What do they withhold? Are they the kind of person that gets straight to the point? Are they the kind of person that is trying to help the other person get to the point so that they can think it was
41:29their idea? conversations, like every other point of story, like setting, like endings, like every opportunity doesn't have to look the way you think it does to tell a character, to tell the reader who a character is. Every chance you have a character, especially a character with somebody else, because we are so often we see ourselves through other people. We don't really exist in a void very well as people, as characters.
41:54The best way to show a character to the reader is by putting them in a group and seeing how other members of the group interact with that character and how they interact with them. Bouncing off another character or off an entire ensemble of characters is one of the best ways. I have characters in the Shades of Magic series and it's like I have one character who is antagonistic to every other character there. Like every character hates this character for a different reason. So, it's so much fun to set that character in the middle of the group and just see what happens. So, yeah. I mean, conversation is one of the best ways to learn character.
42:29>> Is there a kind of scene that you love to write? A love scene, a fight scene, a party? >> Yeah, it's all fight scenes for me. It's fight scenes for me because my greatest goal is to make I see a movie in my head and then my goal is to write it down so that the exact same film plays in your head down to not only the action and the beats, but the way the camera moves through the scene, the where it settles, what the lighting is, what the the mood music is, what the pallet is. I want you to have all of it. And so my goal when I'm writing a fight scene is like I'm moving the lens. I'm I'm I've watched like again growing up on anime and growing up on like movies that had just gorgeous fight sequences. I'm like I want to this is my greatest challenge as a writer is whenever I have to take something that is so visually dependent and put it on a paper in the hopes that I can tell you how to imagine it.
Why Britain feels haunted
43:2343:23>> You live in Scotland and when I think of Scotland in case you didn't know you live in Scotland. So when I think of Scotland, I think of Scotland, Ireland, England, even Norway to be a part of the world with these great storytelling cultures. >> Yeah. >> What is it about >> that part of the world? >> It's just haunted. Like it's just haunt. It's haunted in a way that you don't even have to believe in ghosts and you will still be like, "Yeah, it's haunted." Like you'll meet so many people. And I say that like glibly, but I'm not like it's a culture. It's really hard to explain. Um, I've lived in both England and Scotland. I haven't lived in in Ireland or in Norway or in in in any other places there. But there is this normalization of magic. There is this sense of a mundanity of ghosts. Whether or not you believe in the supernatural, it doesn't really matter. They still exist there. And there is a kind of
44:17local acceptance and understanding. You you could in two sentences. You'd be like, "Do you believe in ghosts?" Someone would say, "No." And then you'd be like, "Do you have any ghost stories?" and they'll be like, "Oh, yeah. Well, I was in this one place and this happened." Like, it's it's not skepticism isn't really in it. It's just baked into the fabric of history. I wrote this entire children's series called City of Ghosts wherein like the theory behind it was essentially any place that has history has hauntings.
44:43Any place that has history has ghosts. And I just feel like the abundance of history in these places, the absolute like thousands and thousands of years worth of history in these places is just steeped into it. So yes, we have the atmosphere. Yes, we have the weather. It lends itself very well to a kind of like um sitting in a coffee shop on a rainy day typing or writing by hand. Like there is a sense of real romanticism of creativity in places like this. They're also just spooky. They're just spooky.
45:16And the sense of like I mean Shades of Magic was born out of the idea that when I was in London, you felt like you could turn a corner and go back 200 years in a single footstep. >> There is a layering. It's one of the the first places I remember being like 11 or 12 when I went to England for the first time and walking through a cemetery in Canterbury where my family was from and every graveyard in this tiny cemetery was older than our country. And I was just like, "Oh, oh, I have been thinking of time on the wrong scale." And you could reach out and you could touch a wall that had been there for a thousand years. And you realize that you are touching something that has a thousand years of time on it. And it could almost come off on your fingers like dust.
45:54There is a sense of that that kind of collapse the boundaries of what is real and what is now into a this this little sphere of potential. And it kind of just it fits me so well because the kind of fantasy I want to write is fantasy that is grounded in our world. Is fantasy that isn't departed so much that you can only reach it through the pages of a book. My whole goal as a fantasy author, as the kind of fantasy author that I am, and we can sidebar and talk about fantasy with a capital F and all of the assumptions that go with that category and why people think they don't like it if they don't like dragons and we can come back to that, but like my goal with fantasy is to make you doubt your reality. And it's such an easy thing.
46:32People think that means I need to make a believer out of you. That's not what I'm saying. You can be 99% skeptic. All I need is 1%. All I need is a tiny crack in the firmament of your conviction that you know everything about the world. And if I can see doubt, 1% doubt that you don't understand every little aspect of the world, I can make you believe in magic.
Keep one foot in reality
46:5346:53>> I'm seeing this deep connection between the way that you talk about fantasy and the way that someone like Andy Weir would talk about science fiction. >> Absolutely. Absolutely. really similar. >> Well, so I have a science background too, which is so I was supposed to be an astrophysicist. So I I changed my course uh at 18. I was supposed to go into astrophysics. I still have a deep passionate fascination with space. But also anyone who has a fascination fascination with space can tell you like we know nothing. We know so little about anything. I mean even here on earth we know what 2% of the ocean 2% of life in the ocean we know. And there's a really fascinating theory. I don't even know if you came if you talked about it with Andy about this idea of alien life. And what we're now actually like what scientists believe we're probably going to discover is that it's simply an order of magnitude issue. Meaning we as people
47:39are capable of perceiving one order of magnitude in either direction. One order of magnitude smaller than us, one order of magnitude larger than us. It's why we didn't know there was an atom until we had the technology to perceive of an atom. It's quite possible we are the order of magnitude outside of an alien life. Meaning we are the universe or we are the atom. is a scale issue, not an existence issue. And I'm like, what a brilliant like the potential. And as a fantasy author, that's all I'm doing is saying like, oh, guess what? There's a potential. You don't know everything.
48:10>> So, take me back to this idea that fantasy should feel real. >> I mean, maybe other people will disagree with that. For me, the best thing about fantasy is that you can take it with you. And the thing about a fantasy like Tolken, okay, so if I have two feet on the ground, this is me. I'm standing right here in reality. Okay, Tolken is 50 steps away. Tolken has written something that you can only access through the pages of the book. You cannot go there. Does not exist except when you are sitting there reading a book. Great book. Have fun. It doesn't exist when you put the book down. CS Lewis is halfway. CS Lewis is 25 steps.
48:43CS Lewis says, "We're going to start in our world, but I have to find a portal. You're going to go through that portal into a world that doesn't exist >> through the closet and wow." >> Exactly. But I don't want that. And I never wanted that. I want is one foot here in reality at all times and one foot in fantasy because if I can do that I can take it with me. Meaning I want the magic to come in to our world so that when I finish reading or when I finish writing and I go about my life I think it was an art of noticing issue and not an existence issue.
49:12>> Can you help me kind of think through a scene like right before this we were standing in the courtyard and that felt like a very real moment. It started kind of looking around and we're talking about kind of felt like London. So, if we're in a scene like that and we're trying to basically leap into fantasy but also keeping our feet on the ground, what does that look like? >> Well, I think it depends. You have a few options. We were standing in a garden.
49:34We touched a little windchime bell. Okay. Now, it's possible that touching that little windchime bell made that one of the doors on this street now opens to somewhere else. Maybe it was a secret code. That's a departure because that means that when we go through that door, we're somewhere else. So, that's one kind of fantasy. That's more of a CS Lewis style fantasy. That's a portal fantasy. Shades of Magic is a portal fantasy.
49:54>> Well, we were joking if that bell is good luck or bad luck. >> Exactly. Exactly. Good luck or bad. But let's say we want to stay in New York. What if that bell is a signal? What if that bell we was really funny about the bell is I couldn't hear it. We touched it, but I didn't hear the little bell inside the bell. What if I can't hear the bell inside the bell because I'm human? What if I can only hear the bell inside the bell if I'm something else?
50:15What if somebody else in this building could hear the bell inside the bell because they are not human? What if they're something else? And what if we knock on that door and we go into that place? Well, we're still in this building, but we talk to somebody inside that room who's maybe been in that room for 95 years. They've been scared to leave, but it's okay because they spent the 600 years before that somewhere else. This is the place that they've decided to inume themselves. Well, now all of a sudden, we know that there's something out there that's not human, right? Maybe they have a basement. Maybe they lead us down into a basement and they have all of these artifacts that they have collected from across time, from across the world. And maybe they're like, "Don't touch that one thing." And then we touch that one thing and now all of a sudden like we've now been exposed over the course of 10 steps to the fact
50:56that magic is real. Fact that people who aren't humans are real. The fact that it's been living with us all along right here in this city. Maybe the thing that we touch allows us to see a version of New York that we couldn't perceive before but was there the whole time like kind of infrared light on a spectrum. Maybe there's an entire version of the city that only exists if you have the right glasses or the right eyesight to see it. So like you can choose the level of separation. The first door one is fun because we go somewhere else. But the problem with going somewhere else is that when we come back here, there's no magic here. We still have to leave here.
51:28Whereas I want you, my favorite kind of fantasy, both as a reader and as a writer, is the kind that convinces you, oh, no, no, it's here. You go, go past, go past the street, turn left. You know that little side street that you always kind of like your eyes skim past that you almost forget to see because you're not supposed to see it. Okay. um blur your vision so that you're not making direct eye contact because you can't actually make direct direct eye contact at it. But if you can blur your vision and just take a leap of faith, take a step through that little gap, you're going to find the alley.
51:55>> Wow, that was beautiful answer. I cannot believe you saw all that little bell that we were just going, >> right? What does that bell do? That one little bell hanging in the tree that I couldn't hear. Okay, who put it there? Is it a ward? Is it protecting this building? >> Yeah. What's cool about that bell is I've walked by that bell. >> Have you ever noticed it before? >> No, I've walked by a thousand times. I've never noticed.
52:19>> It's been there the whole time. >> Nope. >> Might be new. >> And this is the thing. When I was like 17, I have themes in my books that come up all the time. And one of them is doors. And when I was 17, I have this viv vivid memory of walking past a yard. And you know when there's wooden slats vertically, but there's a gap between them. So if you walk past at a certain pace, you almost see like a stop motion. And I walk past this empty yard in my neighborhood in Nashville. And there was a door upright in the middle of the yard. It had like a foundation around it as if the rest of the house had been knocked down, but the house had to have been knocked down like many, many years before because there was no trace of the rest of the house and there was like weeds growing up and there was just a door. And I was 17. And I just remember the absolute conviction of if I go and I open that door, I'm not going to see the
53:02yard on the other side. But I'm not gonna go and open that door because I don't want to be proven right or wrong. And like that is kind of what I want to do with fiction all the time is like can I get you to open that door and what do you think you're going to see on the other side and can I surprise you
Why you should read poetry
53:1753:17>> with everything we've been talking about here? How did William Blake and poetry >> shape this imagination? >> So I grew up uh inundated with poetry. My parents read it to me before bed every night. It was Dickinson. It was Blake and it was Shell Silverstein, the magical weird, right? And the thing is there's a whimsy to those poems and there's an incredible darkness to those poems as well. And there's a sense that they all coexist. I mean, William Blake famously songs of innocence and songs of experience like things that masqueraded on one hand as being for children and on one hand as being absolutely for adults.
53:52And I love the poems exist on those both layers. They exist multiply though I for years as a kid I talked in like syllable rhythms. I talked in like poetic meters because it was just the way my brain worked after being read this every single night. In fact, I wanted to be a poet so badly. But when I got to be about 18, I realized like I probably couldn't make a living at it. And I was like, I wonder if I could become a novelist but use my poetic sensibilities in the pros. Could I bury it again? Like the broccoli and the mac and cheese. And in fact, when I was writing Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil, I wanted to try it as an epic poem. I wanted it to feel like an epic poem and my publisher was like, "Please don't." My publisher was like, "If you could write that as a novel instead of an epic poem, we would just super super appreciate that. So, please do that." But I just feel like for me, poetry is is in everything.
54:42Poetry is such a good skill for novelists to have because poetry teaches economy of of pros. Poetry is like you do not need five sentences. You need eight very carefully chosen words. And and even though my books have gotten longer over the last few years, I have obviously used more words, I still try very very hard to be incredibly specific with my words. And I think that the poetry education that I had as a child and that I continue to make sure that I read a lot of poems now, I think it's just essential. I also just think it's I'm a very firm believer in reading far outside the boundaries of what you write. I call it a creative cross-pollination. If you want to be a good fantasy writer, of course, you should read fantasy. But you should also read memoir. You should also read historical non-fiction. You should also read children's books. You should also read poems because that's where creative
55:34cross-pollination happens. It's just that my early creative cross-pollination happened with poetry. And it has become the tempo by which I live my life. All of my books have their own little tempo piece in them. A little piece of poetry or a sentence that is embedded in the work that is the metronome of the work for me. Um, the very very first book that I ever wrote, the near witch that was my first published was, "The wind on the moors is a tricky thing."
56:00>> The wind >> the wind on the moors is a tricky thing. That was the line buried in it. The line for me buried in um the invisible life of of Adi Laroo is never pray to the gods that answer after dark. Right? There's just a meter for for villains. Uh it is I am not a sidekick. you know, like that's this. It doesn't always have to be poetic and or it doesn't always have to be soft to be poetic, but it can hold the tempo for
What each genre taught her
56:2756:26the work. >> I want to basically run through different genres. >> Sure. >> Different kinds of reading, and I want to hear pretty fast for each one what the thing you've taken away from them has been. Let's start with children's books. >> Oh. Um, pace. Pace. And also priority. like we think that children's books are, you know, children's books are often the darkest books that that I read and that I write. Um, children are way braver than adults, but they also don't have a lot of patience for things that are irrelevant. So, coming back to that anime of like use the world building you need. You like use the world building that ties to plot and character. Don't go on side quests that are essential.
57:04Children's books are really great at maintaining the essential story. Like they have a main road. You know, a big big fantasy book might have a main road and then seven inter intersecting side quests that come along the way and we veer away from the road. A children's book has a main road. >> Tell me about the poetry of Shell Silverstein. Oh, >> I mean, phenomenal. So weird and always slightly magical, always slightly a skew. The world is never quite what it seems. The world is always slightly stranger and more magical than you think it is. There's a there is um a whimsy to it. Shell Silverstein was infamous for doing some of the darkest work and making it so whimsical and realizing that those two things could coexist, that you could have things that were on one hand sinister and on one hand childlike and that that especially as a young person being told I didn't have to think in only whimsy was such a powerful
57:56thing that every now and there would just be this little slash of shadow in it. And I thought, thank you for taking me seriously. Thank you for letting a child have shadow as well as light. Wow. Yeah. As you were saying that I think about a lot of the people I admire the most. They're always pushing beyond the material into awe into wonder into kind of turning their head 20° to the side and saying something a little different's going on there.
58:21>> Exactly. >> Uh science fiction. >> Ooh, ambition. I like it. I like it. Scope and ambition. I'm I fall in the line of science fiction is 99.9% science fantasy and that is an incredible thing. And obviously as a fantasy author there's there's weird hierarchy games that get played where suddenly science fiction has like the rules and the maturity and fantasy we just make stuff up and I'm like okay but science fiction is great.
58:46I just read seven Eaves for the first time which is a huge tome by uh Neil Stevenson but like I mean it's 12200 pages long but much like a memoir I tend to take like one thing from a science fiction and I'm glad that I read the whole thing. Like the whole book doesn't stay with me, but a crux of a concept at the center stays with me. >> What makes for a good premise? >> Fear or uncertainty or oh god, what would I do in that scenario? I mean, really, the what if of it? 70s is like, um, what if the moon was destroyed and you realized you had two years to get off of planet Earth? Like, what would you do? So, it's got to be something relatable. Not like that's relatable, but relatable in that what would you do, >> right? like the what would you do of it is is the the thing for me like what would you do if >> well that's a good example because all of a sudden I can start thinking for myself I can come to my own conclusions
59:38and then say oo now I have an invitation >> it's an invitation in that's exactly what no matter what we're writing we need an invitation in >> history >> departure >> huh >> like history I I watched for all mankind recently and like the so that that show is predicated on the concept of what if uh the space race never ended >> and it's so fun because on some like history continues and then over time the departures just start to like become broader and broader and broader. History is wonderful. One, it repeats. It just repeats adnauseium. It's also a great place to go looking for story ideas.
1:00:11Absolutely. And I don't mean story ideas like let's just repeat Henry VII, right? But like what you can do is you can find a tiny kernel of a tiny scene or a tiny thing that maybe didn't get as much attention throughout history and it can be a really beautiful ingredient in the meal. Again, it's that what if like what if this was different or what if you know what if Julie Albony who's this really fascinating historical figure um almost certainly queer who definitely like broke into a nunnery at some point and she also wielded swords like what what if we could attach to her some form of a supernatural story as well like what if what could I do there? Um there like famously I keep thinking about it.
1:00:47I know everyone always thinks about it but like there is a very famous weekend that birthed Frankenstein and the vampire um essentially in which Mary Wellings and Percy Shelley and John Polyor I think it's Polydori and Byron they were all in Italy together uh spending the summer uh because there was an ash storm from a volcanic fallout. There was no real summer and one weekend they challenged they were challenged to a writing competition and Byron started writing the original vampire pieced out at some point John Paulori took over wrote the vampire which has became the um kind of a very very seinal vampire work and also that weekend Mary Wilston Woolen Stonecraft wrote Frankenstein and it's just like there's so much where you just think what went down like what went down this weekend what an incredible piece of history >> are you somebody who believes that maybe something divine descended.
1:01:41>> Yes, of course. However, I'm like something cursed, you know, something happened here. Like, and it's not that it did, but I love that there's a crack in the firmament of history that allows because the only people who know what happened there were the people who were there. This isn't something that was recorded by other people. So, like any one of them could have lied. And that's one of my favorite things to think about with characters that I think so often we forget in fiction is like even if you are presenting a protagonist, your character can be an unreliable narrator. You can have your character lie. And I think it's something we don't it's something I played with ad nauseium and bury our bones because I was like you should not trust. You are being told a story by three women and not all none of them are objective and they're all telling you the version of the story they want to tell you. Do not mistake
1:02:25that for the truth. So, the fact that like we don't I don't think play enough with the fact that our narrators can lie to us. >> Why is that such an important idea? >> Well, I think it's undermining because I think if you go into a book and you think what I'm reading is the truth, it's fun to play with that assumption. I understand why we assume it because you assume someone is telling you a story. But it's very important to remember that like a story is an invention and you can really nest uh you can unsettle the reader if you start to allow them to understand that maybe they're being lied to. It also just encourages much like a thriller or a mystery encourages the reader to participate to start looking for cracks in the story.
1:03:05>> How did your love for comics inform your fiction writing? >> I mean I love the pace. I love the speed, but also much like everything else that I write is born out of an annoyance. I was really annoyed by one, the superheroism of it all and the idea that like we're suddenly morally obligated to do good things if we get powers, but also I just didn't love the arbitrariness of so many powers in comics. So, in the villain series, your superpowers are born out of near-death experiences, and they're a reflection of who you are, what was happening to you in that moment, and what your final thoughts were. And to me, I just liked building a system that made a logical sense for how powers came about. But not only that, our your superpowered self was then really a reflection of your non-suppowered self.
1:03:49>> So what I'm hearing from that is like there's some things that I like about comics, but a few things that I don't like about comics. And it's in that >> that's how I write. Basically, Shades of Magic was written because there was a lot I loved about the fantasy scene, and there was a lot I didn't love about being a young woman in the fantasy scene. Um, my early YA novels were written because I was really annoyed by like this romanticization of an extremely problematic male love interest because he had, you know, because he looked a certain way. And I'm like, "Oh, no. What you actually want is a roleplay scenario where a good person dresses up as a bad person for a night. You don't actually want a bad person." But in YA, so often if you have a 13 or 14year-old, they might not really have an understanding of the gap between those two things. So most of my writing is born out of my love of a space and my
1:04:33frustration with an inadequacy that I perceive within that space.
1:04:37>> Can you talk to me about the business of writing both >> Oh yeah. >> Okay. Well, I Well, I feel like we just got it. >> Add nausea. >> And what about it? You know, that the even just the the the tenor of your voice there is completely different from anything else you said. So, is there an exhaustion there? Like, talk to me about it. >> I mean, it's a business. This is the this is the hardest thing about what I do is that writing is an art and publishing is a business and they have to intersect for me anyway that I've chosen to be in traditional publishing even if I was in self-publishing it's a business. Um I also think so before we do that there is a really fundamental difference that personally for me that I want to address which is the difference between a writer and an author.
1:05:16And I think that so many you know young and aspiring writers will come up to me they'll be like I can't call myself a writer though I haven't had anything published. If you are taking yourself seriously and you are putting in time and you are writing things down and you are telling stories to yourself, you are a writer and you can always be that and you will always be valid. Being an author is the professional version of that. But it is also the side that predicates an audience. It relies on an audience. I have always wanted to be an author. The very very first time that I read a book that made me forget that I was reading in which like the the words on the page disappeared and I saw it and I I lived a story. My first reaction to that wasn't, "Oh, I want to feel it again." My first reaction was, "I want to do it to other people. I want to create a a a mass hallucination. I want to be able to cast a spell over other
1:06:04people using just words." That is an author. An author relies on a readership. It is an interaction between creator and audience. So when writers come to me and they say I want to be a writer but I am scared of letting other people read my work. I don't want other people to read my work. I say you might want to be a writer and that is completely full stop valid. But if you want to be an author which is a business relationship that also predicate like is predicated on an audience. You have to make peace with the concept of being consumed. It's the feature not the bug.
1:06:35And I think many aspiring authors see it as the bug. And I'm like oh no no no. I want to be read. I don't want to just tell myself stories. I tell myself the stories first but after that I want to tell other people the stories too. So first division of my mind and just to say >> author and writer >> the author is the business as well. Author is a job. I have a lot of issues with the business but I have to say I have all those issues and I am still part of the business and I am a part of the business because I have found a way to work in the business on my terms. I started very young. I wrote my first novel when I was 19. I sold my first book when I was 22. Uh I am now 39. So like and I have and you've written 27 books.
1:07:16>> 27. Yeah. So yeah, I've been doing it but it has not been smooth. So first book, The Near Witch, came out, taken out of publishing after 18 months. They were like, "Well, you failed." >> Second and third book, The Archived and The Undone, come out. They were supposed to be a trilogy. Publisher decided, um, we don't want to invest in the third book in this series. We're just going to cut our losses. Must be your fault. You aren't trying hard enough. I'm 25 at that point and being told that like it's my fault. My books have not succeeded by a metric that I was not provided with.
1:07:47You know, it it was like I didn't understand. I was like, what do you need? What do you need from these books for them to succeed? One of them had already earned out. I just hadn't met the arbitrary metric that publisher had decided for me. >> Okay. >> So, I was three books in and a canceled trilogy among them and I was going to leave. I was like, you know, again, I I can do something else. >> Was that a I'm tired of it. Yeah, it was emotionally um one I was not making I mean I was not paid I was paid a penny and a good luck charm for each of those three books, right? Like there wasn't I could not make ends meet. I am very very fortunate I was able to move back home and my family um displeased but they like they were like okay you can move back home for a few months while you sort this out. So I'm like I can't make ends meet. I can't I can't pay my bills.
1:08:28I can't do anything. I can't keep doing this. I was devastated because all I've ever wanted was to be an author. And two things happened. Um, I was writing Vicious in secret and I was told multiple times by many people in my life it was unsellable because at the time, not because it was bad. Everybody loved the idea of it. Um, this is two men discover the key to superpowers or near-death experiences, set out to manufacture their own abilities, controlling their deaths and resurrections. Everything goes wrong.
1:08:53Book of my heart, but it was comic book without pictures. It wasn't Marvel or DC. Nobody knew what to do with it. Um, two things happened that saved my career, which was tour took a flyer. My adult publisher was like, "Here's $5 and a good luck token and we do not think this book will sell either probably, but we're really interested to see what you do next. So, we will help you keep your foot in the door here for one more book." The other thing that happened is I took on a work for hire. And the work for hire is really, really looked down on by so many writers in the industry because a work for hire in this case was Scholastic. It's a children's publisher.
1:09:27They came to me and they're like, "We have an we have a hole in our market for for kids for our school book fairs. We would like these three books. They're essentially like self-help books for pre-teen girls using a guardian angel." And I was like, I will do it if I can make it like Doctor Who, right? Like I will do it if I can do it figure out to do on my own terms. Those two book deals, neither of which was enough to keep me afloat, together bought me a year. They bought me a year of like I could I could still live at home.
1:09:53Financial solveny was far on the distance. And then two things happened which is that that children's book sold like a million copies in Scholastic Bookfairs. So I suddenly could keep my lights on for another year. Um and cuz the royalty rate is much smaller. They're like small paperbacks and everything. But I suddenly like had a royalty check for the first time in my life. And my publisher for tour was like, "What else do you have?" And I went and I wrote a darker shade of magic. And the thing about Vicious though that would for form the relationship for the rest of my career was that I wrote Vicious for nobody but me. I thought to myself, I tried for those first three books to write as a young writer to find this the middle ground between me and an audience, me and the market. Didn't work and it doesn't work. But with Vicious, I was like, well, if I am the only pair of eyes that ever sees this story, it has
1:10:45to be enough. And that has been the rule that I have kept forward for every single book that I have written since vicious which is it can't be about the market. It can't be about the audience. You know I now have a million you know millions of readers. Who am I? If I'm writing for them which one who who am I writing for? I cannot write for them. I write with them in mine for them in the end but like every book I write is because it's the book I want to read. I am the first and for years at a time the only reader for those books. So I have a lot of feelings about the business. Like I say, I was not treated well early on in it and there have been a lot of hills and valleys since, but there have been more hills and then valleys. And the trick is at the end of the day, and I think the way I've been able to navigate this business is you write another book.
1:11:33Because if you're an aspiring author and your book doesn't sell, you write another book. If you're an aspiring author and your book does sell, you write another book. If you're an aspiring author and your first book comes out and it does well, you need another book. If you're an aspiring author and your first book comes out and it does not do well, you need another book. And so on and so forth and so forth. So I just never stopped. And there are a lot of places in my journey where I could have paused to see how things were going or to like take a breath. But I just didn't. I just said I am going to focus on the thing I can focus on, which is the stories I want to tell. I'm just going to keep writing.
1:12:08And that decision to keep writing regardless of whether I was having feast or famine years is what has now created this this this landscape for myself. But it started as a teacup. I had a teacup worth of readers that grew into a saucepan that grew into now a lake. And the nice thing about that from a creative perspective is that all of my books are different. But when you have a lake, the it doesn't evaporate very quickly. So like when I have a lake, I now have an audience stability which allows me to experiment which is very very tolerant of me taking chances and doing new things. Whereas if I had had my debut novel and they had paid me six figures for it, it would have been a puddle and it would have come out and it would have made a splash and it would have immediately evaporated and I've never had to deal with the evaporation because the the growth of my audience has been so slow. But it's a it's a hard
1:13:02industry. I have I mean I had a book come out this spring called The Ending Race Itself under a pseudonym Evelyn Clark with one of my best friends that was just literally talking about
Schwab's honest business advice
1:13:101:13:09publishing trauma. >> And so what advice do you have like if I were to come to you and I were to say hey like let's assume I'm a decent writer let's assume a decent writer and I say can you help me out like what are the things that I need to keep in mind as I navigate this industry want to get my book sold. >> Okay there I have two pieces I have a couple pieces of advice. One of them is one of them is brutal. If there is something else in this world that brings you more joy, do that. I mean it. I mean it because like if you will want to be an author because you're hoping to hit it big and have a bestseller and like have an experience of what it means to be an author with a capital A, this is not the business. It is not I and I say that because I do meet a lot of writers who are like are more interested in being an author than in writing the books. And there there's a a very well-known quote um that I think was
1:13:56recently rementioned by Elizabeth Goldberg which is you're not entitled to the fruits of your labor, you're only entitled to your labor. And it's very very important to believe that. So if you are in this game for the fruits of the labor and not the labor, it is a matter of time before you are disappointed. You might make it a few years, but like it's just not a good found it's a shaky foundation on which to build yourself if you're in it. And this happened to me. A reader asked me this the other night. He's like, "I write books the way you write books.
1:14:22They tend to have a slow buy in. They're not like straight out the gate, I I'm worried I'm never going to be big." And this is the thing. You are not going to have the same arc as someone who has a moment book. A moment book versus a movement book. Like I've never wanted to have a moment. I want to be a movement, right? >> But if you are a movement style writer, someone who takes three to 10 years for your audience to really lock in on a work, um, you cannot hold yourself to the standards of a moment book. So, you cannot expect that book to come out and do the kinds of things that a book of the moment is going to do. You need patience. Patience is hard because it's not always up to the author. One of the best things I ever did for my career, and again, it wasn't really my choice was I left YA for adult. And the difference is not equality, not an audience. The difference is the the publishing market in YA at the time when
1:15:13I was in it, I can't speak to it right now, would give you 60 days. 60 days to decide if your book was a success or a failure. And that was >> so you had to be a moment, not >> you had to be a moment. And also 60 days because that was how long your book would generally last on a bookshelf because the turnover in the stores was so high for ya because the audience was growing was aging that like you were not guaranteed more than two months on shelf. And I remember when Vicious came out and I went to my publisher after two months and I was like to am I a success or a failure and they were like what is wrong with you? It has been two months.
1:15:47They were like, "Check back at a we'll talk at a year. We'll talk at two years. We'll talk at three. We'll talk at five." What I realized was the luxury I had bought myself by moving into this different space was the amount of time my book would sit on shelf. >> Yeah. >> And the thing is we talk like look, I have a new release right now as we're talking. We talk about books as if they're only new the week that they come out. A book is new the day a reader picks it up. And so the greatest thing you have to work toward if you're the kind of writer who takes time for your audience who is going to probably like have a slow build is to put yourself in situations and in spaces where your book can be on shelf long enough to be discovered. That was the difference until The Invisible Life of Adi Laroo which was my 20th book. My books took three to five years to find their audience. Three to five years. Meaning
1:16:32instead of having like my first my biggest sales and then they would go off like this, my sales would go like this for 3 to 5 years. Wow. >> Because my books are word of mouth books traditionally, which means you need someone to read it and then hand it to a friend who reads it and hand it to a friend. And it takes longer than a book that has a publisher driven marketing campaign that is designed to hit that first week sales for the list. And that's kind of their prime concern. And it's a really shitty thing to hear, like, oh, you have to be patient. But you have to be patient and it's hard because it's not always in your control.
1:17:04So you have to figure out where to position yourself in the market that is going to give you the most opportunity for readers to have time to find you.
What to do when your heroes fall
1:17:121:17:12>> Can you tell me what you've learned from uh Neil Gaiman? This is a tricky thing to talk about and yet I have a video online where I have given a lecture for the Tolken series at Oxford and the and one of the things that I open with that lecture with was like I have this amazing creative parental lineage meaning there is an author that made me a reader and an author that made me a writer and I talked about it earlier. I was like the first time I was 11 I read a book I forgot I was reading and it was Harry Potter.
1:17:36>> Yeah. >> So on the one hand I stand here this is like 2018 and I'm like I have this parental creative lineage that has informed me so much. on the one hand is JK Rowling, on the other hand is Neil Gaiman. This is a very hard thing for me because both of these authors have fallen for me. They they don't occupy those places of esteem in my life anymore due to actions of their in their own life not because of their work and we can try under some situations to separate an artist from the art but in certain cases it is a very personal choice. sometimes it's a systemic choice or sometimes it's has a societal underbearing like JK Rowling wherein I as a member of the queer community I can't I can't support anything that she does and it really breaks my heart that she has decided to use her immense power and platform to negatively impact others that are part of my community. Um, I I cannot reccon my life and I and I
1:18:29cannot reccon my story and there are so many days that I wish I could now because like these two figures were so important to me and their work was so important to me. But I think my agent told me something recently because I was really stressed about book release. And I have this underdog mentality because for the first nine or 10 years of my career, I genuinely was an underdog. And when you're an underdog, you're hustling and you're like, I have to sell more books. I have to sell more books right now. And I have to think about more books right now. What happens if I take a moment to pause? And my agent said to me, you can thank the things that got you here without taking them forward.
1:19:05And I think a lot about that in relationship to these writers whose work in so many ways did get me here. Like Harry Potter made me a reader. Discovering Gaiman's work in my teens. The thing that impacted me so much was this idea that he had a creative liberty. He was writing short fiction and novels and screenplays and poems and nobody was telling him that he had to pick a lane creatively. And I was, you know, 16 and already being told that I needed to pick what kind of writer I was going to be. And that level of ambition and freedom was so f foundational for me. So these two writers were absolutely foundational. I don't know that I become the writer or the reader without either one of them.
1:19:47>> They carried me a distance and I have had to set them down. >> And and I think that that's okay. And I know a lot of readers out there have really struggled in the wake of it as well. And I think it's just really important that like you don't have to erase the importance that something had on your past and to build you. Coming back to backstory and like these fundamental things which make us who we are, but that doesn't mean that we can't find new creators and stories to carry us forward.
1:20:14>> As you're writing, we've talked a lot about the way that you write for yourself. And then also there's this deep sense of care for the reader and editing and all of that. So, how do you kind of bring those two things together? Sort of the desire to >> create a great body of work for your reader, but then also to do something that's for me, myself, and I. >> It's challenging because like the demon that lives on my shoulder and whispers in my ear every day only has one sentence, and the only sentence the demon whispers is, "They'll say, "Your last book was better." It's the fear that drives me through my entire life.
1:20:46That's the only time that the readers come in in that way. Because at this point, I think I understand my audience pretty well and my audience understands me pretty well. That I know that if I write for me, it'll be for them because at this point, like they've chosen to be there with me. Um, I think it's imperative that I write for me and I don't really have a hard time doing that. I think part of that is like I know I can't I can only write the story that I believe in and that I feel passionately about. So it really becomes a matter of like after the story is written then I think about okay how am I going to hold hands with my audience while we go through this because once the book is written that's when it becomes for them and then it's really hard because it never stops being for me but at some point it has to be for us.
1:21:27>> When you say it's written do you mean that you finished the draft and you're going through revision or do you mean you've published it and now it's in fully edited and drafted? Yeah. like my relationship with my readers like I love them but I also did have a moment when I turned in victorious where I thought oh good if I die now fewer readers will be disappointed in me because this trilogy was like so I feel a lot of pressure I love my audience but I think that that's why I feel so much pressure they have held me for so many years they have been there with me for so many years they are that lake I was talking about and I'm so afraid of disappointing them >> but at the same time I don't know how to ensure that I don't accept to write the best thing that I can write. So, I can't. It's not like I sit there and think, "Oh, between decision X and decision Y in this book, which one is going to make the readers happier?" I
1:22:16don't think like that, but I think like I hope that the book is good enough that they like what I've done with it.
Diving into Schwab's writing routine
1:22:231:22:24>> How do you structure your life to get writing done? Like what is it that you actually do? Like one of the things that I think I picked up on was >> you'll sit down for 20 30 minutes then go get some tea, come back and what else have you done to make sure that you continue to get the writing done and not be distracted either by >> your own anxieties or being stressed or just the demands of the world? I >> say the demands of the world are a much bigger problem than my anxieties and stress. The anxiety and stress are so constant in my life that like every time I sit down to work, they're the first things I need to tackle. And I've structured so much of my creative process about getting them out of the way. My favorite thing to do these days as an extreme perfectionist who can get really stymied by it is when I sit down to work on a scene, um, I don't tell myself I'm writing the scene. I tell
1:23:09myself I'm outlining the scene. I'm like, "Don't worry, babe. These are not book words. These are not book words. All we're going to do, we're going to take the like three sentences, you know, about what needs to happen in the scene. We're just going to build. Let's just turn those three sentences into 10 sentences. Let's just expand." And what's going to happen over the course of the next 15 to 20 minutes as I start to build the scene for myself, I'm just bulletpointing it, is my brain will supply a line of dialogue or my brain will be like, "Actually, you don't even need a a bullet point line here because I have a sentence for you." And I'll ease myself out of the anxiety and into the creativity. Um, I write in small segments. I write usually two to three hours a day and I write in 20 to 30 minute snippets. That is how my brain works. I'm also I I do a lot of other like I'm a very active person. I'm a
1:23:55endurance runner. And so like I'm a body in motion more than I'm a body at rest. And so I'm kind of always writing. It's just that I sit down to type for 2 to three hours a day. And I think that's a really big difference. One of the greatest things that I did for myself was I stopped measuring word count. A lot of writers will be like, I need to write 2,000 words a day. And I'm like, okay, I get that. I measure time because I will have days where I write 2,000 words and I will have days where I write 200 words because I was deleting, editing, thinking, doing all of the other work that I think if we only measure word count, we're a disservice to our own creative process. And also, we might push ourselves to hit words that we're not actually going to need for the book. I would rather take a little bit of extra time, delete a bit, a little bit less. So, what I will say, people think I'm a very fast writer
1:24:42because of the number of books that I have out. I am not. What I am is a relentless writer. So probably in a 365day year I write 320 to 330 days and and not all of those days are big word days. Many many of those days are uh just small thinking days. But you know it all adds up. It all adds up. I write basically two books a year and I brainstorm or plan on two books a year. >> When you're working on a new book, what is the feeling that you have that's pulling you towards where you're going?
1:25:12Is it like an excitement? Like the story's in my head. I need to put it on the page. Is it like a sense of duty? I owe this to my audience. Like what is the thing that's going on? >> Um, there are two wolves that live inside me. One of them is terrified of running out of ideas and one of them is terrified of dying before I write the ones I have. And so it is like this sheer propulsive I I'm like I'm just spilling ideas onto paper. It I'm a very inefficient writer. So like I will write 5,000 words about a scene that is 10,000 words long. I do a huge amount of writing about my scene. I I I will tell the scene to myself. I'll type it to myself over and over again just to get a sense of like, okay, how do I actually want to move through it? How do I want to work with it? So, like if you're if you're looking for efficiency, I am not the person to come to. But I am driven by the like get the thing get the thing
1:26:00out of my head and onto paper. And the whole time I'm working, I'm a little bit like Atlas holding it up. So from the moment I start drafting, so I do all my brainstorming, my outlining, that might take a year. And then the moment I actually sit down and I'm like, we're book wording now. We're book wording. It is a white knuckle race to the finish for me of like how long I can hold the weight up because I'm so afraid of dropping it. And I just get to the end so that I can set it down. So that like six months of writing a book, of drafting a book for me, hell. Absolute hell. But the year before where I'm outlining, planning, brainstorming, where I basically just get to sit down for two hours a day and be like, I would really like to think about this and I just like have a muse with myself for two hours a day where I get to play and I get to think like, okay, um, what's that festival like that I was writing
1:26:48about? Like what what what would what kind of stations does it have? What is the girl going to learn about? How are we going to learn about it? Like I just play and sometimes it's pen and paper if I get distracted. Unfortunately, my handwriting uh combusts over 20 after 24 hours. Like it self-destructs. I can't read it anymore. So, I have to either transcribe handwriting work to a computer within 24 hours or it's gone.
1:27:10>> With imagination, you read a bunch. >> Yes. >> And are there other things that you feel like have expanded your imagination? Like I was just amazed when you were kind of that bell. I was like, [snorts] how did she get there? Like what are the things that underpin that? >> Yeah. I mean that's just constant. Unfortunately, that's just me, the bell thing. But like I So I I'm >> You mean asking what ifs? >> I'm filling my creative well at all times. I think you have to. The more demands you take from your creative well, the more you have to put into it.
1:27:42So I am reading. I listen to a ton. Again, I'm a runner and so I listen to a ton of audiobooks because I'm out for like 3 four hours on exercise and so I need I can I can knock out an audio book in a day between walking my dog, doing my run, like doing errands and stuff. So, I'm consuming books. I watch television shows. I watch movies. My favorite thing about being on tour is I'm like on airplanes and suddenly I will watch every movie I've missed on the airplane. Music for me though is huge. I will write entire books based on how a song makes me feel. So I'll hear a song and I'll think I want to write something that feels like that >> and then that song will become a backdrop song. So we talked about white noise really briefly earlier and it's like this sense of that has become my white noise. I can now make any song my white noise. It used to be I could only listen to Rain. And now what I found is
1:28:35I can take any song, even if it has lyrics. If I play it four times, three or four times on loop, I'll lose the lyrics and I'll just have the energy from it. And then it can be my new white noise. And so now my white noise can have a tone that is the ambient tone for the thing that I'm writing. But music is huge to me.
1:28:54>> Last question. If we were to go to a university, do a semester long class based on how you do what you do, what would you tell students? Like what is the thing that you would want them to understand? >> I think I would want them to understand that we're building a house. A book is a house, right? And like you can build it any way that you want, but if you want it to be structurally sound, there are a few rules. You have to have a sense of like, are we freehanding this house? Is this one of those like clay houses in the desert that you use with like reclaimed materials? Like, what kind of house are you trying to build? If you're trying to build an elaborate house, we're going to need to probably have a structure. We're probably going to want to make a blueprint, but like think about how you're going to get to decorate those rooms once the rooms are built. If you need to on a bad day, we're going to be able to skip ahead and
1:29:44we're going to be able to look at wallpaper, but we're going to have to come back and make sure that the floors are solid before we actually put the wallpaper in. But like we're gonna build a house together. And that can seem like a really really big undertaking to build a house. But the nice thing is if you can think about it like something like that, you can enjoy every single step of it. And you can find joy in the building of the framework and you can have joy in the blueprint and you can have joy in going and looking at paint samples that you can't use yet, but you're going to be able to use them one day and you can have a vision for what that house is like when it's done.
1:30:14>> So make this concrete for me. What are the different things, the different skills that I need to acquire? the different things that I need to understand. >> I mean, you don't have to acquire them before you come to the course, but in the course, what I hope you would start to understand with me is how how the structure of the house becomes s sound, how we make sure that the floor doesn't fall in when you're walking on it, how we know the difference between a sentence that was made for aesthetics only that isn't actually supporting the house and also like how we want to move through it. I think it's really important to understand that there is an architectural element, there is an engineering element to story building, you know, and you don't have to use it.
1:30:50You can fly by the seat of your pants and find your way through that first draft if then you're willing to take that first draft apart, >> right? >> And actually build the framework underneath it. I'm the kind of writer that would prefer to build the structure of the house stable so that I only have to redecorate it. I don't want to have to tear down half of my house. And so I think it's about figuring out what your risk tolerance is as a creative because I've worked with a lot of writers and I've talked to a lot of writers who would rather blitz the house and then figure out where they need to go and shore that house back up. Or maybe they're like, I'm not building a house.
1:31:20I'm building an image of a house, a vibe of a house. I'm building, you know, the vague impression of the house. And that's fine, too. But for me, how I like to build story is with a sense of structural integrity of the house. >> There we go. >> Yeah. >> Thank you for coming here. This was great. >> Thank you so much. It's also good to meet you. >> Good to meet you, too.