CaddieOpen in CaddieDownload for Mac

Copy This Meta Ads Strategy to Scale Your Web2App Campaigns (Part 2/2)

Shared by Caddie Library · Updated
App Masters21:37Open on YouTube
Chapters show their main points

The bottom line

Web2App campaigns on Meta scale profitably when you start with cheap proxy events to train the pixel, switch to purchase optimization, and grow by testing creatives and duplicating winners. Judge everything by return on ad spend, because it shows whether the money you spend comes back.

Key takeaways

  • Purchase optimization is the long-term goal, but it is costly at the start. 0:17
    • The pixel does not yet know who buys, so it sends random users, and you can lose hundreds or even a thousand dollars.
    • The goal is to sell, not to get a completed quiz or a started payment.
  • Proxy events let you train the pixel on a small budget. 1:40
    • Events such as complete registration, initiate checkout or lead give about 10 times more signals than purchases.
    • Steve's team had to start with a paywall view campaign because Meta showed no purchase events, and moved to purchase once sales came in.
    • About $50 a day for 7 to 10 days is enough to educate the pixel.
  • Creative testing finds the few ads that carry the account. 6:13
    • Test 15 to 20 creatives at about $100 each, so $2,000 to $3,000 in total.
    • Usually 60 to 70% fail, and the top 20 to 30% get the focus.
    • Make about 70% of new ads variations of winners, and add new ideas every couple of months as audiences tire.
  • You scale by raising budgets slowly and duplicating campaigns that already work. 12:56
    • Raise budgets 20 to 25% every few days, never two or three times at once.
    • Editing a working campaign, including its targeting, restarts its learning, so copy it instead and change only the geo.
    • Start in the United States, then expand to other countries.
  • Return on ad spend is the metric that decides whether the campaigns pay off. 17:56
    • Without day-one data, predict lifetime value, for example 50% of monthly subscribers renewing in month two and 25% in month three.
    • Then track revenue retention by channel and campaign.

In the end the most important metric that you have to focus on is the return on ad spend.

Igor Lyubimov

Chapter summaries

0:00 Two ways to optimize a campaign on Meta

Optimizing on purchase is the main strategy, and a proxy event is a cheaper way to start.

  • Optimizing on purchase is what you always use at scale. 0:05
    • The pixel has no buyer data on day one, so it sends mixed audiences.
    • Interest in a creative does not mean the user is ready to pay.
    • Early losses can reach hundreds of dollars, sometimes a thousand.
    • Bigger budgets learn faster: $500 to $1,000 a day can spend $5,000 in a week.
  • A proxy event lets you start small and check the funnel. 1:40
    • Pick any standard event before payment, ideally one where the user opened the payment form.
    • Watch where users drop off, fix the funnel, then switch to purchase.
    • Run two campaigns at once, one on purchase and one on registration, and compare.
    • A small budget also shows whether payments work and the funnel has no bugs.
    • Winning creatives from the proxy campaign can move to the purchase campaign.

5:26 How to test creatives

A first test of many creatives finds the few winners, which you then vary and refresh.

  • Build the test set from audiences, hooks and formats. 6:27
    • Define 2 to 4 audiences, give each 1 to 3 hooks, and make 1 to 3 formats per hook.
    • Run them in one campaign, one creative per ad, and let optimization pick winners.
    • That gives 15 to 30 creatives, video and static.
    • Winners get more than $100, losers get about $100 and stop.
  • Most of the new ads should vary the winners. 8:46
    • About 70% should vary top performers by idea, format, color scheme or structure.
    • Test new campaigns beside the main one, then add proven creatives to it.
    • Some businesses live on one or two creatives for months, but most need new ideas every couple of months.
    • Make several size versions of each creative, so 20 creatives can become 60 files.

10:49 Pruning creatives and picking platforms

Cut dead ads on a schedule, and master one platform before spreading budget to others.

  • Remove ads that waste money, and recycle the losers later 10:57
    • Cut ads that spend without purchases.
    • Cut ads that get no spend at all.
    • Keep removed ads in a "trash bin" and run a contest with them every couple of months.
    • Don't spend long on this. Finding new ideas pays more.
  • Start with one platform, then add others 11:37
    • Meta is usually the main one.
    • Give some budget to TikTok and Google later.
    • Meta and TikTok have strong algorithms.
    • Google search is hardest because you must keep adding negative keywords by hand.

12:34 Scaling without breaking what works

Leave working campaigns alone, and grow by copying them.

  • Don't touch low-budget campaigns on bad days 13:12
    • Low budget means under $1,000 a day.
    • Stop a campaign only after 2 to 3 weak days.
    • Bad days happen, so don't panic.
    • Never scale on a bad day.
  • Spend more on the days that convert best 13:45
    • Steve's team saw better numbers Friday to Sunday for one client.
    • They raise budget on strong days and lower it on weak ones.
    • A Facebook rule can do this automatically.
  • A copy of a winning campaign repeats its results 14:19
    • Raised budgets can make a campaign worse, so you lower them again.
    • Copies in the same account perform like the original.
    • You can run 10 campaigns with identical settings.
    • Add new creatives to the copies, but don't replace all the old ones.

16:55 Advanced optimization and final checklist

Value-based bidding and steady creative work come after the basics.

  • Worldwide campaigns and lookalikes come later 16:58
    • A worldwide campaign needs different prices and local currencies.
    • Lookalikes work only with a good customer base.
    • Always add completely new concepts next to the winners.
    • Don't use lookalikes at the start.
  • Optimize for value, not just event count 17:34
    • Target users who bring a set amount of money.
    • One example is buying only yearly subscriptions.
    • Revenue retention can be tracked per channel and campaign.
  • Success rests on a short weekly routine 18:52
    • Make new creatives every week.
    • Send every pixel event with exactly the same data.
    • Wait about 3 to 4 days before judging a campaign, so it gets enough events.
    • Keep tuning quizzes and paywalls for each audience and creative.
  • Meta ads also lift branded search 19:56
    • Corivo runs many Web2App campaigns and has a branded search score of 30+.
    • The same happens with regular app install campaigns.
    • App Store search tends to rise too.

In the growth library

Igor Lyubimov and Steve P. Young, Igor Lyubimov is CEO of web2wave; Steve P. Young hosts App Masters. Explains how to run and scale Meta Ads for web2app funnels: start on a proxy event, move to purchase optimization, test creatives in bulk, then scale by duplicating campaigns. Gives concrete budgets, thresholds and pacing rules, such as $100 per creative and 20 to 25% budget raises every few days.

Lessons that draw on this:

More from App Masters · The whole library, and ask it anything

Transcript451 lines
0:05

There are two ways how you do campaigns on meta. It's really simplified way how you can do that. Um so the main strategy and first and main and u the strategy that you will be using always on scale is optimizing on purchase event. uh this is like your goal is to sell not to complete the quiz or start the payment. So you want to optimize on the purchase event. And uh think the problem with this event is when you set up campaigns for the very first time, Facebook pixel basically doesn't know who will purchase uh who will purchase your product. So it starts sending you people they may maybe not your target audience. They may react to your creative. So they kind of may be interested in your product but still they may not have money or being interested not that doesn't mean um to be ready to pay. That's why in the beginning you may lose hundreds sometimes thousand dollars because Facebook sends you some random users and

1:32

it can be painful in the beginning. So in this case we recommend setting in parallel or starting with the strategy tool. It's it is good for the beginning. And in this strategy, you optimize your campaigns on different events that are happen happening before the payment. So for instance, it can be complete registration if you ask users for email. It can be initiate checkout when they opened the payment form. Um it can be a lead event if you send them. So you can select almost any uh standard event that is relevant to the situation when the user completes the quiz and it's better if they like kind of interacted somehow with the payable like open the payment form something like that. you will have way more events like 10 times more events um of this step. Because of that your uh quiz completion conversions will be higher and even the conversions from viewing first screen and going to second

2:50

screen will be higher and with a relatively small budget I'm putting like the the minimum amount of money obviously like if you have thousand of dollars it will it will be way more fast if you spend I know like 500 a day 1,000 a you can spend uh 5,000 in a week and you will get results faster. But if you are tight on budget, start with really small um daily budget. See how your users behave on the on the funnel, optimize the funnel if you see some drop offs and then uh switch to purchase optimization.

3:33

>> Hey Eigor, I I'll start with this. We had to start with strategy two because strategy one Facebook was saying we don't have any purchase events. So we couldn't particularly optimize for a purchase event until we started with strategy 2 which if you go back real quick to that screen we will see that what Eigor is saying is complete registration same as paywall view. That's so when we're setting this up for our client using web towave we had to start off with a payw wall view. So complete registration campaign first until we got it start we started getting some purchases in there and then we were able to start our purchase campaign.

4:08

That's just my experience. I'm not saying this is what is for everybody but I'm just saying this is our experience. >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's a it's a great way to do like you can even start with two campaigns uh at the same time. One will be for the purchase and one will be for complete registration and you will see which performs better. But usually the complete registration on small budgets uh is performing better in the beginning. So you can spend I don't know like week maybe 10 days with a 50 day $50 a day budget and uh you will kind of educate your pixel and then you will scale it. Wrap up about the strategies.

4:48

Strategy one and the main strategy that you will be optimizing in the end is when you optimize on purchase. It is great for the performance but maybe costly in the beginning. The other strategy is to optimize on uh proxy event that happens before the uh purchase and with that you can start with lower budgets and be sure that your funnel works everything is good with that um you have no bugs payment systems are working and then you can scale it.

5:26

>> Yeah, you can use strategy 2 to test creatives and then move it to Yeah. the creative winning ones to strategy one. Uh so about the creatives when we talk about the creatives I usually answer the question that I asked a lot about like what should be the budget for the test. So if you never never launched any paid um campaigns on meta and you want to start with web to app the thing is that you are starting not with web to app you're starting with paid traffic uh in general. So at first you have to understand what is my target audience what should be the creatives and the very first step for you is to um is to test your creatives. So at first we recommend starting with 15 20 different creatives. Um I would recommend thinking about this as uh you have to define two three four target audiences.

6:31

For every target audience come up with one, two, three hooks or ideas that you sell in these creatives. And for every hook uh or idea create one, two, three different formats. It can be video, it can be static. Um, so by that you will have around like 15, 20, sometimes 25, maybe 30 different creatives that serve different needs for different um target audience. Um, then you have to test them. I'd say you have to spend around like $100 per creative, which means if you have like 20 creatives, your first budget just to test creatives will be like 2 3k.

7:27

>> Sometimes you will understand that these creatives work and you kind of can scale it. sometimes and in a lot of cases it's not enough because like you just starting doing your paid debts h you don't know your target audience. It's great when you have a competitor that you can copy that you can learn from but it may be not the case and uh so here you have to spend two 3k just to test the creatives then you understand that half [snorts] of them or more than half 60 70% of creatives are not working. So you focus only on the 20 30% of top performers and uh yeah and to do this test you create one campaign you create um multiple ads and you add uh each creative in every ad. Then you launch the campaign you create the optimization on the campaign level and it decides which creatives are performing better.

8:28

Then after you spend uh 100 per creative. You will see that some creators will will get this 100, some creatives will get more money just because they're performing uh better. You will understand who are the winners and on which creatives you should focus. And when you tested your first creatives, you have to start doing uh iterations on these creators. I'd say like 70% of the creative that you're running should be variations of top performers. Buy ideas, buy the formats, by I don't know like the color scheme or structure, but you always have to look for new ideas and new approaches. Um there are businesses that live on one or two creatives like for months but usually it's not like that. Usually you have to create uh new creatives, new ideas every couple months uh because like people saw these creatives and they're like tired of what they already saw. So you have to come up with new ideas. You understand

9:40

your top performance. you make variations around them. You always you have the main campaigns that uh bring you money that are performing really good and in parallel with them you create new campaigns to test uh the creators and once you find that there are some new creatives that are performing really good you may add these uh creatives to the main campaign that is performing. So here how how you prepare the creatives.

10:12

Um you have to make different size versions for every um creative. It may be tiresome to when you have like 20 of them, you better create different formats for every creative. So it's like be 60 creators. But well this is how you do how you do the traffic. There are a lot of tools on the market that simplify that. Then uh you have to wait for well at least 3 days for the creative to to be alive on the campaigns to before they make uh decisions.

10:57

um you remove the creatives that are either spending money but not bringing you any uh purchases and you also remove those uh who does not have any spent. If you trust in these creators, we usually recommend like collecting them in some trash bin and once in couple months uh launch new competition with all the losers that you love. Uh but like don't spend too much time on that and uh it's better to find uh new ways um every time.

11:35

>> I like the trash bin idea. >> Yeah. So for the platform in the beginning we recommend starting with just one platform but once you see that it is performing like depending on your use case and your target audience and the the way how they look for products like yours you have to choose one of these platforms usually it's meta as the biggest one but we also recommend allocating some budgets to Tik Tok and uh Google. Google is the hardest one because with Meta and Tik Tok they have really good algorithms. With Google with Google search you have to spend a lot of time doing all the all the words minusing all the worlds u because well it's it's a big process and you have to spend a lot of time on that. Then for uh the scaling when you launched your first campaign you added 20 creative there. Uh you understood that like five creatives are performing really good. Then you create a new campaign with these five

12:47

creatives. Then you wait for it to be successful. When you see that in two three days it's working pretty good. You may start increasing budgets. Don't increase it uh two three times at a time. Increase it gradually adding 20 25% uh every um every few days. Um do not change the campaigns when they are not performing and on low budgets. I mean low budgets is like less than 1,000 a day something like that. there will be really bad days. So like don't don't panic, don't worry. It happens. Um and um yeah, so on these days don't change anything. Just wait it. If it will be not performing for two three days then uh then you can stop this campaign.

13:45

>> Well you what we've also done for some of our clients because we've seen better numbers on like Friday, Saturday, Sunday for this particular client. We'll even increase budget on those days and lower budget on the the bad days. And so you can set up a rule within Facebook to to do just that as well. >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Great advice. So look for the timing of the campaigns uh in the week or like during the year. So for the scaling um I'd say like the simplest way to scale is uh to add budget um a little bit and then you just copy your performing campaigns. That's it. Like you see that this campaign is performing. Sometimes at some point you will start increasing the budget and it will not perform really good. So you will need to lower the budget. But if you copy the same campaign in the same account, it will be performing uh with the same results as another campaign. So you may have like 10 different uh

14:46

campaigns but with the same uh settings. And um for the geos like usually we recommend uh in the beginning focusing on for instance just United States and when you understand that it is performing in the United States then you can launch like worldwide campaign or start uh creating new campaigns in other countries. So focus on one market in the beginning and then scale the same campaigns just by changing the geography on of the campaign >> when you duplicate it. Okay. Yeah. Why are you duplicating it? Are you duplicating so that you can target a brand new geo?

15:25

>> Yes. So you better not change the campaign that is already working. So every time you change the targeting of the campaign, it starts to learn from the beginning. So if your campaign is performed, you're not touching it. you may increase some budget and that's it. But if you created the campaign for instance for United States and now you want to go to to United Kingdom or to Canada then you have to copy this campaign and change the the geo or in general your campaign is performing for United States make a copy of the same campaign don't change anything and launch uh like kind of the same campaign in parallel and it will be performing better if you would uh just increasing the budget.

16:12

Really? Okay. Interesting. I didn't know that. That's so cool. Okay. >> Start duplicate the same budget. So, here are some advices on how you can uh scale the campaigns. Um so yeah if to sum up the scaling strategies that you have like uh increase budgets then duplicate uh campaigns and you may add additional creatives uh but not like changing all the creatives but add new creatives to these new campaigns when uh in the moment when you're copying them and uh do different uh campaigns for different geographies But still you may have the worldwide campaign that will be optimized to like everyone in the world.

16:58

Uh but in this case you have to focus on different uh for instance different payables with different uh prices. When you sell worldwide you better support local currencies. Yeah. For the creatives you do um you you focus on the winners but you also add uh completely new concepts always. Look alikes. It's an option when you have a really good user base um of um of customers. Try look alikes. It may work for you but not in the beginning. And another way on how to optimize your campaigns is optimize on the value not only like the number of events or the CPA but on on the like you can optimize campaigns for only the users who will bring you some particular amount of uh money or like buying only yearly subscriptions and in the end the most important metric that you have to focus on is the return on ad spend. If you will not have 100% on day one, try to predict it. Uh if you don't have the data, well, you can get it from us uh on

18:11

the platform or from other benchmarks or make your estimations. For instance, okay, like I have a monthly subscription like 50% of the users will renew it on the uh second months. So on the third month, I will have like 25% of the users. So predict LTV and try to set up your campaigns in the beginning using this uh predicted LTVM and track how they will behave after they made the purchase. So you may see retention, revenue retention based not only like on all users but also on different channels and uh campaigns.

18:50

Um so yeah and then then you're good to go. And to finalize uh create new creatives weekly, you have to find new ideas always like precise technical implementation of the pixel. You have to send all the events exactly with the same data. It's actually like a hard part. Um wait for like don't panic if your campaigns are not performing. just wait for 40 to decay to get uh enough events. Um yeah, never scale on bad days and uh always try to optimize your quizzes and pay walls for the campaigns, changing the fill screens and pay walls for different target audiences for different creators. Um, yeah, and you can do everything on web towave. So, yeah, that's it for now.

19:53

>> I love it. Thank you so much, Eigor. I know one of the things I wanted to add on too is as you're running meta campaigns, one of the things you should pay attention to is that search volume for your brand. Because one of the apps that we looked at, Eigor, that I know is running a lot of web two app campaigns because I've been targeted for their ads is corive. And we did a video about them. We broke down their web 2 app funnel, but essentially if you look at their branded campaign, I'm looking at app follow right now. It's like a search score of 30 plus. So we've seen this with other apps too where we're running meta, whether it's a web to app campaign or whether it's a typical app install campaign. Your branded search goes up and your search app store search tends to increase too. So there's equal benefits to that that you know, Eigor didn't even take credit for. He's not even taking credit for that. All that

20:42

wins too. Eigor, if the audience wants to connect with you in any other way, do you want to send them anywhere else besides Web2 Wave? >> I mean, you can sign up on Web2. There is a form you can message. I read almost all the messages and either I or someone from my [music] team will connect with you or find me on LinkedIn. It's pretty easy. We are [music] on the top uh top results. >> Yeah. and Egard and his team have been so helpful along the way with setting up our own internal web 2 app campaign and then definitely helping our clients because when we've had questions with the meta campaigns, we've gone to them and they've answered the questions perfectly. But go check them out. It is web2wave.com and Eigor, thank you so much for coming on doing this.

21:26

>> Thank you, Steve. All right, thank you guys for watching. I'll see you on the next video. [music]