All apps and companies

Company · Business software

Fair

A car subscription company founded by Max Rhodes.

fair.com3 sources3 tips
In short

Fair grew by building the marketplace first, then a free tool that onboarded brands' existing retailers, who were cross-sold to other brands without a sales team. Many VCs passed after asking if founder Max Rhodes was a good employee, not a world-class entrepreneur. Lesson: use a free tool to pull existing relationships onto your marketplace, and judge founders against the role. The sources give no figures.

At a glanceVCs passed on Max Rhodes by asking the wrong question
Good employee?
  • Asked: was Max a good employee?
  • Answer: mixed
  • Many VCs passed
World-class entrepreneur?Won
  • Asked: could he be world-class?
  • Answer: yes
  • Delian: Fair could make him leave VC

Same person, wrong question, wrong result.

From Reference-check lesson from Fair's page

What was said about Fair

  • Many VCs passed on Fair by asking the wrong reference question about Max Rhodes. Many VCs asked whether Max Rhodes was a good employee and got a mixed answer, so they passed. The better question was whether he could be a world-class entrepreneur, and the answer to that was yes.

    Delian Asparouhov called Fair the one company that could make him leave VC. The lesson for reference checks: frame the question around the role the person will actually do. In the words of the source: "Same person, wrong question, wrong result."

More in Business software

Business software

Microsoft

A software company founded by Bill Gates and Paul Allen that made BASIC, MS-DOS and Windows.

40 sources · 100 tips
Business software

Figma

A collaborative design platform with design, whiteboarding, slides, dev handoff and AI prototyping tools.

20 sources · 81 tips
Business software

Shopify

A commerce platform that lets merchants build online stores and sell to customers.

23 sources · 55 tips
Business software

Atlassian

A software company behind Jira, Confluence, Trello and other team collaboration tools.

13 sources · 40 tips
Business software

Slack

A workplace messaging platform for teams, acquired by Salesforce.

25 sources · 46 tips
Business software

Airtable

A no-code platform for building collaborative business apps on a real-time database.

9 sources · 43 tips
Business software

Miro

An online visual collaboration whiteboard for teams.

7 sources · 36 tips
Business software

37signals

A small, independent, profitable software company behind Basecamp, HEY and Highrise, run remotely with about 60 people.

5 sources · 41 tips